31 January 2005

Decent left, decent right?

A question from a self-described fanatical moderate: If there were ever to be a decent left and a decent right, would they come to agree more than they disagree?
Whither Baylor?

After a turbulent tenure as president of Texas' 160-year-old Baylor University, Robert Sloan will step aside to become chancellor of the institution, in a move that would seem to amount to being kicked upstairs, as the expression goes. What will this mean for Sloan's controversial Baylor 2012 programme, intended to push the university to the front ranks of America's major research universities while deepening its distinctively christian character? While I, as a christian academic teaching at a christian university, find it difficult to fault Sloan's desire to recover Baylor's confessional moorings, I do wonder whether he was perhaps overly ambitious and insufficiently patient with those who might have qualms about this agenda. A more incremental approach might have had greater long-term success.

Incidentally, this week Redeemer is privileged to host Baylor philosopher C. Stephen Evans, who will be speaking thursday and friday. The subject? Kierkegaard.

30 January 2005

Iraqi vote today

Today Iraqi citizens went to the polls in the first multi-party election in more than half a century. Although I have expressed doubts over the prospects for a democratic Iraq, we should all hope and pray that the doubters will be proved incorrect in their fears. Nothing would make me happier than having to eat my words because things turned out better than anticipated.
A dangerous bishop

Bishop Michael Ingham, of the Anglican diocese of New Westminster, is supremely tolerant of a variety of lifestyle choices but not of those who disagree with Bishop Michael Ingham. He would, moreover, use the coercive power of the state to force such people to conform to his enlightened beliefs, even if it entails a dangerous abridgement of religious freedom. Funny, but the rest of us were under the impression that the Inquisition had been abolished some time ago.
Psalms in Slovak

Branislav Micieta is a young Reformed Baptist from Slovakia with an interest in the Genevan Psalms. He has written a versification in his own language of Psalm 23 which he has posted here, along with two translations of Isaac Watts' common metre psalms. Those who love the biblical Psalter and want to hear it sung around the world should check back to Micieta's website occasionally as he adds more such versifications.
And now, on to Lotusland . . .

. . . where the following story shouldn't come as too much of a surprise: "Former B.C. Liberal officials charged with fraud, taking bribes." By now I should think people would be more astonished to hear of a BC politician staying out of jail than going to jail.

29 January 2005

A 'blueblood' society for the Antipodes?

Although I have a longstanding interest in genealogy for less purposeful reasons, some people's interests in this field are motivated by the desire to join one of the following "blueblood" societies: the United Empire Loyalists' Association of Canada, the National Society of The Colonial Dames of America, the Daughters of the American Revolution, the Sons of Confederate Veterans, and the United Daughters of the Confederacy. Membership in such societies is undoubtedly a satisfying experience for those able to prove prestigious ancestral connections. However, I rather like the idea behind this website: Convicts to Australia: A Guide to Researching Your Convict Ancestors. Makes you wonder what sort of societies might spring up down under from this research.
Ingenuity in a pinch

You have to hand it to this man for thinking quickly and getting himself out of a life-threatening situation.

28 January 2005

Kay on marriage

As the country awaits the federal government's proposed marriage legislation next week, Barbara Kay has her own take on the issue which is worth reading and considering: "The Broken Windows Theory of Marriage." This article appeared as an op-ed piece in wednesday's National Post and has been republished on Lifesitenews.com.
Welcome to new readers

I would like to extend a warm welcome to the students of Paul Brink's Political Science 330 class at Eastern University, St. David's, Pennsylvania. They are reading my book and have recently discovered this blog. Of course, they are more than welcome to join the conversation! Brink is one of my protégés from my early years at Redeemer and will shortly be defending his dissertation at Notre Dame. When he does, I will certainly mention it here!
An oppressed minority?

It's about time to push for the next item on the politically correct agenda: affirmative action for Franco-Greek-Cypriot-Finno-Anglo-American-Canadians, easily the smallest and most marginalized minority in this country.

27 January 2005

Redrawing the maps

In my personal library I have a number of old maps and atlases dating to the beginning of the last century and the end of the 19th century. Given their age, they include a number of countries which no longer exist, including the Russian and Ottoman Empires and Austria-Hungary. Such countries as Czechoslovakia and Yugoslavia did not yet exist, and a few, such as Greece and Romania, were quite a bit smaller than they are today. Then the Great War broke out in 1914 and everything changed.


It's All Relative

Potential Central European Federation?


After the war ended representatives of the great powers met in Paris, where they set about to redraw the map of Europe. One of the casualties was the last of the once vast Habsburg dominions in Europe, Austria-Hungary, as shown in the map above. Had I been present at Paris in 1919 and been in a position to influence the proceedings, I would not have favoured the wholesale carving up of Europe. We now know, of course, that this new Europe created the conditions that led to the Second World War scarcely two decades later. Yet even without this foreknowledge, Clémenceau, Lloyd George, Wilson and others ought to have understood the dangers of acting in so rash a fashion. Opening up the question of international borders was certain to leave huge numbers of people dissatisfied, even as it placated some of the louder and more militant ethnic nationalists who had agitated to move them. Short of uprooting countless millions of minorities -- which, of course, is eventually what happened -- drawing new borders inevitably left sizeable communities believing they were on the wrong side of what seemed to them arbitrary lines on a map.

There would seem to be no obviously just way to partition an empire. More than eight decades later, I find myself wondering whether it might not have been better, rather than breaking up Austria-Hungary, to revive it as a Central European Federation within most of its pre-1914 territory. Perhaps the House of Habsburg could have been left as the reigning, but not ruling, dynasty, with representative parliamentary institutions in Vienna or Budapest, and substantial powers devolved to the constituent regions. Within each of these regions, political institutions might have been established to encourage power-sharing amongst the various ethnic communities, along the lines of the smaller consociational democracies.

The one exception I would have made to the preservation of much of prewar Europe is Poland. The old Polish commonwealth had been cruelly extinguished in 1795, after three successive partitions enlarged Russia, Austria and Prussia at its expense. The great powers were right to bring back Poland. But creating new countries such as Yugoslavia and Czechoslovakia, which did not survive the 20th century, was a spectacularly bad idea.

Only if a particular geographically-bounded community is obviously not being done justice within a larger territorial polity might secession or partition become necessary. But it is certainly not an answer to every ill and, even as a last resort, will almost certainly have deleterious consequences for everyone concerned. So although I am generally averse to political slogans, if I had to choose one it would be: Up with federalism; down with partition!
Murder motive being downplayed?

Chuck Colson comments on the Jersey City murders in today's Breakpoint commentary: "Murder in Jersey City." Is the possibility of a religious motive being deliberately downplayed by local authorities? Colson says yes.

25 January 2005

Sephardim in New Mexico?

Our own resident hispanophile, Richard Greydanus, will undoubtedly find this of interest. It seems that a number of hispanics in New Mexico are discovering their genealogical roots in the sephardic Jewish community exiled from Spain after 1492: "DNA tests explain old traditions."
An appropriate appellation?

If neocalvinists are properly nicknamed neocals, might young neocalvinists be known as neocalves?

     
Sources: Parlement en Politiek, Breeders World
Campaign to protect Assyrians

Yesterday in London George Carey, the former Archbishop of Canterbury, launched a campaign to save the Assyrian Christians of Iraq from extinction. Despite the change in régime in Baghdad nearly two years ago, the plight of Assyrians has only worsened. According to Lord Carey, "In recent months and years churches and monasteries have been attacked and people have been killed." Although estimates differ as to numbers, the following is from The Telegraph: "About 800,000 Assyrians live in Iraq with an additional half a million around the world. They still speak the ancient biblical language of Aramaic." We would do well to pray for these brothers and sisters in Christ, as well as to support Carey's campaign.

24 January 2005

Murder of Armanious family religiously motivated?

This is a story which we at Redeemer are watching, due to a personal connection with one of our staff: "Killing of family shatters religious harmony." Given the centuries-old tensions within Egypt between Muslims and Christians, it is not surprising that middle eastern Christians, including Assyrians, suspect the worst in the brutal slaying of the Coptic Orthodox Armanious family in Jersey City, New Jersey. Pray that justice will be done and that at least a semblance of interfaith harmony might return to the Egyptian community in Jersey City.
Unlocking Locke, II: synthesizing conflicting narratives

Last week I posted two back-to-back posts dealing with the Lockean and biblical narratives. Here I will try to bring these two subjects together and, in so doing, complete the argument begun there.

We noted in that first post that Locke borrows the basic framework of his political philosophy from that of Thomas Hobbes, employing the same categories and drawing similar conclusions. Leo Strauss argues that Locke is simply a more moderate version of Hobbes and can be understood only against the larger context of the Enlightenment. Yet we also observed that Locke owes a debt to an older tradition of philosophizing, stemming in some measure from the natural law theories of Thomas Aquinas, as mediated through Richard Hooker. It is this latter influence which often persuades contemporary Christians that Locke is a christian thinker putting forth christian ideas on the nature of the state. Given Locke's influence on Thomas Jefferson and the American founders, Americans anxious to emphasize their country's christian origins have an incentive to claim Locke as their own.

However, as I have suggested below, claiming a particular philosophy as biblical on the basis of certain apparently biblical features found therein, is deeply problematic, particularly if the larger animating narrative is glossed over. (I am here using animating narrative as roughly the same as worldview.) To be sure, one may be thankful that Locke, e.g., believed in limited government, opposed tyranny, favoured consent of the governed and advocated the protection of private property. But there is much more to Locke than this, and one needs to dig deeper to find the narrative undergirding his thought as a whole. Perhaps it would be helpful to compare what might be called the Hobbesian/Lockean and biblical narratives to illustrate how they differ at a basic level:

(1) The Hobbesian/Lockean narrative:
State of nature -> social contract -> civil government -> appeal to heaven

(2) The biblical narrative (in elaborated form):
Creation -> fall into sin -> redemption in Jesus Christ -> renewal in the Holy Spirit -> consummation of the kingdom of God

That these two narratives are in conflict should be apparent from even a superficial reading. A deeper reading will reveal, among other things, that each makes for a different understanding of the role of government in human society. According to the Lockean narrative, political authority is by no means intrinsic to humanity. The more "natural" state is one characterized by equality and independence, which can be given up or modified only by mutual consent. This consent is thus deemed the basis of legitimate government, and its absence removes this legitimacy. However much natural law limitations may make their appearance in Locke's thought, there is no avoiding the fact that the centrality of contract would tend to leave the interpretation of the meaning of such limitations up to the people themselves, who will likely change their interpretation from one generation to the next. Hence the stages in the development of liberalism, of which I detect five in my book.

By contrast, the biblical narrative affirms that the role of political authority cannot be understood apart from the larger context of God's dealings with his image-bearers. There is no prepolitical natural state in which we are all equal and independent of one another. Indeed, the state of nature might be seen as a parody of the Garden of Eden. Political authority arises, not from contract, but out of two elements of human nature: first, our created limitedness and, second, our sinfulness. The first of these elements is intrinsic to our status as creatures, irrespective of our fallenness. The second is, of course, rooted precisely in our fallenness. Because of the latter, the purpose of political authority is, in part, a remedy for the destructive effects of sin. Because of both elements, political authority is called by God to do justice, as affirmed repeatedly throughout scripture (e.g., Deuteronomy 16:18-20; Psalms 72, 82; Proverbs 29:4, 14; Isaiah 10:1-2; Romans 13; I Peter 2:13-14).

Another way to put this is that government has an intrinsic jural task to which the notions of contract and popular consent, with their potential arbitrariness, cannot do full justice. As for redemption and renewal, Christians acknowledge that political authority itself cannot redeem, despite the exaggerated hopes which the followers of secular ideologies might place in it. Yet government, like the rest of God's creation, is caught up in the larger drama of redemption, which is cosmic in scope.


Christian History Institute

Thomas Aquinas


This means that, although we are justified, because of God's common grace, in recognizing the moments of truth in the theories of, say, Plato, Aristotle, Hobbes, Locke, Kant and Marx, one cannot simply lift these moments eclectically out of the larger narratives animating their thinking without doing damage both to the intregrity of these thinkers' ideas and to the biblical narrative which is, after all, the story we are called to inhabit, as Lesslie Newbigin puts it. What might be called a spiritual eclecticism is the central difficulty in, e.g., Thomas Aquinas' grand synthesis of Christian revelation, Aristotle's ethics and Stoic legal theory in his own philosophy. While I have a tremendous respect for Thomas Aquinas and particularly for his neothomist disciples of the 19th and 20th centuries, it is not clear that his enterprise, taken as a whole, succeeds in freeing itself from the aristotelian and stoic narratives from which he borrows so freely.

Two decades ago one of my Notre Dame professors wrote a series of journal articles attempting to determine whether Thomas Aquinas is a natural law or a natural virtue theorist. He argued for natural virtue, but others argue just as plausibly for natural law. My own response would be that Thomas is both and that, if the two positions are not exactly compatible, this is due to the unstable nature of his attempt to synthesize two conflicting narratives. Something similar could perhaps be said of Locke.

So where does this leave us? At square one? Do we spurn all pre-existing philosophies, including political philosophies, and start from scratch? Hardly. In any attempt to gain a theoretical understanding of God's world, we inevitably enter a larger conversation which has been going on for centuries before us and will continue for long after we are gone. Yet there are resources out there to help us make our way through the conflicting claims put forward in academia, in the popular media and in the context of government itself. I trust I am not too immodest in hoping that my own book might be one of these, though I am quick to recommend as well the writings of Skillen, Bob Goudzwaard, Paul Marshall, Bernard Zylstra, Rockne McCarthy, Jonathan Chaplin, Al Wolters, Mike Goheen and Craig Bartholomew, in addition to Kuyper and Dooyeweerd.

22 January 2005

Two inaugural addresses and natural law

As I was reading President Bush's second inaugural address, I was struck by its similarity to one delivered by a predecessor exactly 44 years earlier. Here is John F. Kennedy speaking on 20 January 1961 after being sworn in as president:

Let the word go forth from this time and place, to friend and foe alike, that the torch has been passed to a new generation of Americans—born in this century, tempered by war, disciplined by a hard and bitter peace, proud of our ancient heritage—and unwilling to witness or permit the slow undoing of those human rights to which this Nation has always been committed, and to which we are committed today at home and around the world.

Let every nation know, whether it wishes us well or ill, that we shall pay any price, bear any burden, meet any hardship, support any friend, oppose any foe, in order to assure the survival and the success of liberty.

And now President Bush:

We are led, by events and common sense, to one conclusion: The survival of liberty in our land increasingly depends on the success of liberty in other lands. The best hope for peace in our world is the expansion of freedom in all the world.

America's vital interests and our deepest beliefs are now one. From the day of our Founding, we have proclaimed that every man and woman on this earth has rights, and dignity, and matchless value, because they bear the image of the Maker of Heaven and earth. Across the generations we have proclaimed the imperative of self-government, because no one is fit to be a master, and no one deserves to be a slave. Advancing these ideals is the mission that created our Nation. It is the honorable achievement of our fathers. Now it is the urgent requirement of our nation's security, and the calling of our time.

So it is the policy of the United States to seek and support the growth of democratic movements and institutions in every nation and culture, with the ultimate goal of ending tyranny in our world.

Aside from the strong sense of national purpose invoked by both speeches, both manifest a commitment to an expansive, interventionist foreign policy which would see the United States playing a substantial role in the defence/advance of freedom outside its own borders. Both employ rhetoric manifesting a weak sense of the limits of government and the limits of the resources at the disposal of even a global superpower. We ought not forget that the idealism of Kennedy's administration was soon followed by the debacle in Vietnam. Hard on the heels of Camelot came Chicago 1968, Kent State and Watergate.

Napoleon had virtually the whole of Europe under his control. But he overextended himself and his military by invading Russia in 1812. The US currently has troops in Afghanistan and Iraq, where they are finding it difficult to keep even a semblance of order. Now we hear rumours that covert operations are occurring in Iran. Threats have been directed at North Korea as well. Is Bush in danger of making the same error as Napoleon, Kennedy, Lyndon Johnson and many others? Time will tell, but one would be foolish to deny the possibility.

In the meantime, there are a number of voices in the media castigating Bush for bringing "too much God" into his inaugural address. Joseph Bottum, writing in the Weekly Standard, argues that Bush's speech had just the right amount of God. Far from sounding like a theocrat, Bush is appealing to a natural law tradition extending as far back as Thomas Aquinas. Writes Bottum:

So, we've got an enduring and universal human nature ("ancient hope"). We've got final causation ("meant to be fulfilled"). We've got a moral problematic (the "ebb and flow of justice"). We've got intelligible formal causes (the ideal of "liberty" as shaping a "visible direction" for history). And we've even got a prime mover ("the Author of Liberty"). There isn't much more a natural-law philosopher could want in an American president's inaugural address about nature and nature's God. I'd guess not a lot of gloating is allowed around the throne of the Maker of heaven and earth, but somewhere in the vicinity, St. Thomas Aquinas must be smiling. . . .

Yet Bottum admits there is much in the address to cause discomfort to the more devout believers in his audience.

The president's Evangelical supporters may have been reassured by the public religiosity of the occasion--the prayers, the Navy choir singing "God of Our Fathers," the bowed heads. But the god of the philosophers ain't much of a god to be going home with. A deistical clockmaker, an impersonal prime mover, a demiurge instead of a redeemer: This is hardly the faith Christian Americans imagine the president shares with them. There was not a mention of the Divine in Bush's speech that Thomas Jefferson couldn't have uttered.

So has Bush embraced natural law theory? If Leo Strauss (no, I am not a Straussian) were alive today, he would probably say no, underscoring the considerable distance between the mediaeval notion of natural law and the peculiarly modern notion of human rights: "In the modern development, 'natural law' is as it were replaced by 'the rights of man,' or in other words the emphasis shifts from man's duties to his rights. Whereas pre-modern natural law was on the whole 'conservative,' modern natural law is essentially 'revolutionary.'" There is, of course, more to Strauss' argument than these two sentences, but it would seem truer to observe that Bush is more evidently the heir of Jefferson than of Thomas Aquinas and his scholastic followers. In this respect at least, Bush's speech is unexceptional in his country's history.
World federalism an option?

Are such organizations as the World Federalist Movement and its various national affiliates the wave of the future or are they the nostalgic vestiges of an obsolescent idealism? Here is the WFM's self-description:

The World Federalist Movement (WFM) is an international citizen's movement working for justice, peace, and sustainable prosperity. We call for an end to the rule of force, through a world governed by law, based on strengthened and democratized world institutions. We are inspired by the democratic principles of federalism.

Few are likely aware that John B. Anderson, one-time third-party presidential aspirant in 1980 and long-time member of the House of Representatives from my home state of Illinois, is a world federalist. Anderson is a self-described evangelical Christian who was well known in this community in the 1960s and '70s. He is (or at least was) president of the World Federalist Association in the US, now called Citizens for Global Solutions. Here is Anderson on his vision for the future:

Humankind's best guarantee of peace is a legal system which provides for the resolution of the disputes that will inevitably arise in human society. Resolution by peaceful methods that renounce the use of force as a substitute for reason will contribute to the acceptance of the rule of law as an inescapable paradigm. Peace must be acknowledged as a human right which if violated by nations or by individuals will be upheld and protected by judicial process. No ruler or national leader however described should by claim of state sovereignty be able to subvert the principles of accountability to clearly established legal principles through a democratic process based on an equitable and fair and democratic form of government. I further believe that it is through a democratic world federation equipped with adequate authority to deal with truly supra-national questions that our best hopes for a peaceful and secure future reside.

Needless to say, Anderson's is a minority viewpoing among his compatriots, much less his co-religionists.

My own view is that the movement towards the adoption of effective international legal principles is a needed one, even as the notion of a global federation is almost certainly a nonstarter. Hannah Arendt once said that freedom, wherever it has existed as a living reality, is always spatially limited. Democracy on a global scale is more likely to be an empty abstraction than an effective political framework. Moreover, I become immediately suspicious when I hear people contrast the rule of law and the exercise of force. After all, the very efficacy of law rests on the legitimate possession of forceful means.

The reformational school of political theorizing associated with Kuyper and Dooyeweerd I have found extremely fruitful for understanding at least domestic politics. Yet followers of this approach have done little in the way of fleshing out a biblical, creational understanding of international politics. As there is much work to be done in this area, I have been steering my own better students in this direction. God grant that perhaps fifty years from now they and others will have given us more of substance to work with.

Followers

Blog Archive

About Me

My photo
Contact at: dtkoyzis at gmail dot com