31 July 2005

Warren on Ferguson

Columnist David Warren, a recent convert to Catholicism, has taken note of Bob Ferguson's recent CBC commentary:

But that post-modern mind is itself anti-Christian, to say nothing of anti-Catholic. It believes what it believes (nothing, consistently) in defiance of Christian, and all other religious traditions.

Is it a danger to the faithful? You bet. And not only because it offers anodynes, to lure them away from their intellectual, moral, and spiritual commitments.

I felt this danger, last week, in a radio commentary the CBC commissioned from a retired engineering professor -- a certain Bob Ferguson -- who said that the Canadian government should "overcome the inertia" of the Catholic Church by imposing such things as "gay marriage" and "woman's ordination" upon it by law. His reasoning was tortuous, and he displayed no knowledge whatever of church history, but I'm sure his "modest proposal" would be embraced by all aboard that Gananoque showboat.

The glibness with which the totalitarian solution is proposed marks it as post-modern. The result would be two "Catholic churches", as there now are in Communist China. One, faithful to Our Lord, and flourishing underground despite police raids and murderous persecution. The other, an "official" church for show, emptying of membership but obedient to the State's every whim.

St. Anthony of Egypt, the founder of Christian monasticism: "A time is coming when men will go mad, and when they see someone who is not mad, they will attack him saying, 'You are mad, you are not like us'."

30 July 2005

The CCO's groundbreaking campus ministry

In this week's Comment, Gideon Strauss writes of Building Institutions - The Coalition for Christian Outreach, which he dubs "the greatest campus ministry on planet Earth." With the goal of "transforming college students to transform the world," the CCO has had a presence in the western Pennsylvania region for more than three decades. Of course, any mention of this organization inevitably brings up the name of the late great Pete Steen, an itinerant neocalvinist evangelist who had a rather large impact on numerous students throughout the 1970s and early 1980s. The most visible manifestation of the CCO is the annual Jubilee conference in Pittsburgh every February, which I was privileged to attend in 1994. Would that there were counterparts to the CCO and Jubilee throughout North America.
Exciting find

Theresa will be thrilled at this news: the discovery of six dinosaur eggs dating back an extraordinary 190 million years.


Robert Reisz, University of Toronto

An embryonic Massospondylus
Tenth planet discovered

Three-quarters of a century after the discovery of Pluto, Cal Tech astronomers have discovered a tenth planet orbiting the sun. It has been given the wonderfully euphonious provisional name of 2003UB313, but will undoubtedly be dubbed something more in keeping with the names of its neighbours. Might such a name be found here?

By the way, can we assume that this new planet is not simply a redesignation of Sedna or Quaoar?

29 July 2005

Fr. Oakes on evolution

Cardinal Christoph Schönborn's recent New York Times op-ed piece has stirred up some controversy. Here is a two-part interview with Fr. Edward T. Oakes on the Roman Catholic Church's attitude towards biological evolution. Among other things, Fr. Oakes argues that his church has no difficulty with evolution as such, but it does object to those who draw atheistic implications from it as well as to those who would import it into human relations, as was done by the 19th-century social darwinists.

Tellingly, Fr. Oakes does not think much of the intelligent design movement, with which many evangelical protestants have cast their lot, primarily because he sees it improperly conflating finality and design, confusing primary and secondary causality, and reversing the relationship between art and nature. Food for thought.

28 July 2005

And now for the bad news . . .

. . . at least for those having faith in herbal remedies: 'Echinacea no good for colds'. I guess it's back to chicken soup for all of us next winter.
Are 'the Troubles' finally over?

Here's good news indeed, and long overdue: IRA says ceasing all armed activity in N.Ireland.
A new 'city on the hill'?

While we're on the subject of Christianity's relationship to the larger culture, here is one group which is taking action in a decidedly unconventional manner, as reported here: Christian Exodus urges evangelicals to start anew in South Carolina. Then again it has been done before, hasn't it?
Maxim Institute

I recently learned of this New Zealand-based organization from a colleague who returned from the Antipodes. The Maxim Institute was established in 2001 and has begun to have an impact on that country's political life. This is how it describes itself:

A research and public policy organisation committed to promoting the principles that underpin a Civil Society. It analyses, publishes and comments on important social and cultural issues to inform and inspire the public and decision-makers. Maxim Institute provides New Zealanders with the resources and motivation to be better informed, more active participants in the democratic process.

The Maxim Institute maintains specialized research centres with the following objectives:

  • For the married, intergenerational family to be supported and promoted in policy and culture.
  • For parents to have the authority to select their child's school and for schools to have the authority to select curriculum and use their finances in the way they see fit.
  • For policy and culture to reflect a clear understanding of the relationship between freedom and responsibility.
  • For the next generation of leaders to be informed and inspired by a coherent understanding of Civil Society.


  • This organization appears to merit some attention from those of us in the northern hemisphere. As I myself will be in that part of the world next year, perhaps I should take a slight detour to Auckland and see what the Maxim Institute is all about.
    Strike averted

    Canada is saved: Workers reach tentative agreement with LCBO.

    27 July 2005

    Dinosaurs

    Despite our best efforts to interest our Theresa in the arts and humanities, her predilections are increasingly gravitating towards the natural sciences. (She was obsessed with Barbies for a grand total of two days. Then back to the sciences.) Although she has a bit of a fear of insects, she is nevertheless fascinated by them, especially their life cycles, from egg to larva to pupa to adult. But her greatest love right now is dinosaurs. We initially discovered this three Christmases ago during a trip to the Royal Ontario Museum. When we visited the dinosaur exhibits, she took delight at what we were seeing, even at age four.

    Earlier this month, during a trip out of town, I picked up for Theresa an inexpensive package of 21 small coloured plastic dinosaurs, including stegosaurus, diplodocus, parasaurolophus, dimetrodon and tyrannosaurus rex, among others. They were a big hit. She has now learnt all their names and is interested in finding out everything she can about the different types of dinosaurs that once lived aeons ago. Accordingly, we've been reading books on the subject.



    Stegosaurus


    Not surprisingly perhaps, all of them presuppose the validity of macroevolution, assuming that the various dinosaur species developed out of earlier forms and that their descendants may be found among contemporary reptiles and perhaps even among birds and mammals. I will admit that I've gone back and forth on the issue. In my youth I tended to think that macroevolution probably did occur. I suppose I would have adhered to something like theistic evolution, even if I found some of its implications problematic.

    In more recent years, however, I've become more doubtful about this, since I find it difficult to envision a mechanism which would allow millions of years of accumulated small mutations to enable inert tissue to see or feel or taste. Of what possible use to a creature is 95 percent of an eye aeons away from actually experiencing sight? Would not natural selection have eliminated this redundant appendage somewhere along the way? Nevertheless, I also admit that I am far from an expert in any of this, so I do have to plead a measure of agnosticism on the issue. What I do not doubt, however, is that God created the heavens and the earth and everything therein.

    This is where I run into problems with all the dinosaur books we've looked at thus far. None of them take seriously God's creative intention in bringing dinosaurs into being. To be honest, I'm not altogether certain how the believing Christian should deal with the dinosaurs. It appears that God created a whole series of creatures which once populated the earth and then allowed them to die off some 65 million years ago. Can we celebrate God's creation in these creatures whom we now know only by their remains? Can we affirm that God once pronounced them good and then decided that their time on earth was over? This is undoubtedly something Nancy and I will need to explore further, given Theresa's interests. Book or website suggestions would be welcome.

    By the way, am I the only nonpaleontologist who thought that the sequel to Jurassic Park ought to have been called Cretaceous Park? And is a female of the species tyrannosaurus rex a tyrannosaura regina? Just a couple of questions from a novice.

    26 July 2005

    Official language wanted?

    Does it make sense for a nascent federation to have 20 or more official languages? Perhaps the European Union should simplify matters by discarding all of these and adopting Latin as its official means of communication. Or, to bridge something of Samuel Huntington's civilizational fault lines, adopt three languages: Latin, Greek and Old Church Slavonic.
    Religious freedom and secularism

    Two recent Zenit interviews are worth taking a look at. "On Religious Freedom in the World" carries an interview with Attilio Tamburrini, director of the Italian section of Aid to the Church in Need. In addition to surveying the state of religious freedom in India, the islamic world and China, he speaks of the role of aggressive secularism against increasingly beleaguered christian minorities in the west, e.g., France. Lest one conclude that these are isolated examples in a world where religious freedom is largely protected, Tamburrini notes that "the only country that has an organization which is concerned with religious freedom at the institutional level is the United States." Would that Canada might manifest a similar concern.

    The second article is a two-part interview with theologian Tracey Rowland on "Benedict XVI, Vatican II and Modernity." Of particular interest is her explanation of two tendencies within Roman Catholic thought, viz., the so-called Catholic Whigs and the Augustinian Thomists, with their contrasting views of modernity. Pope Benedict would appear to fall into the latter category, from Rowland's perspective. Rowland teaches at the same institution as my favourite Catholic theologian, David L. Schindler, who speaks well of my friend Alvin Plantinga and whose weighty writings tend to be more comprehensible to neocalvinists than to many of his fellow Catholics.

    25 July 2005

    Worse than terrorism

    Canada survived last year's hockey strike, but this could very well bring down the country.
    Comment redesigned

    The WRF's newly redesigned Comment has come out with two new articles this week: "Yes, but . . .", by Richard Greydanus, and "Into the Fray," by Brian Dijkema. The subject matter? A lively web-based debate between a certain pseudonymous cleric and that obscure south-central Upper Canadian professor of politics. Perhaps those two should take their act on the road. The Great J/K (Jape/Koyzis) Debate. The P & P (Priest and Prof) Test Match. Or something along these lines.

    24 July 2005

    Ulster and Cyprus

    Writing for the Belfast Telegraph, Alf McCreary notes the parallels between two divided islands in Europe.

    23 July 2005

    A defective working theology

    In recent weeks I have been following the tragic events in Connecticut within the Episcopal Church, where the parish and pastor of a personal friend have been on the receiving end of what can only be described as episcopal tyranny. Philip Turner gives us some insight as to what is behind the disorder within the principal North American manifestation of Anglicanism in An Unworkable Theology. Despite formal adherence to orthodox creeds, liturgies, &c., the Episcopal Church's working theology amounts to a different gospel. This "unofficial doctrine of radical inclusion" demands only that the church welcome without qualification and certainly without demand for repentance and amendment of life. According to Turner:

    In a theology dominated by radical inclusion, terms such as “faith,” “justification,” “repentance,” and “holiness of life” seem to belong to an antique vocabulary that must be outgrown or reinterpreted. So also does the notion that the Church is a community elected by God for the particular purpose of bearing witness to the saving event of Christ’s life, death, and resurrection.

    It is this witness that defines the great tradition of the Church, but a theology of radical inclusion must trim such robust belief. To be true to itself it can find room for only one sort of witness: inclusion of the previously excluded. God has already included everybody, and now we ought to do the same. Salvation cannot be the issue. The theology of radical inclusion, as preached and practiced within the Episcopal Church, must define the central issue as moral rather than religious, since exclusion is in the end a moral issue even for God.

    We must say this clearly: The Episcopal Church’s current working theology depends upon the obliteration of God’s difficult, redemptive love in the name of a new revelation.

    Of course the irony of the situation in Connecticut is that those most vociferously preaching this new gospel of radical inclusion will not shrink at excluding those who do not, even to the extent of banning a recalcitrant priest and seizing a parish's property. This would appear to vindicate the truth of Neuhaus' Law, as articulated by Fr. Richard John Neuhaus: "Where orthodoxy is optional, orthodoxy will sooner or later be proscribed." It seems there are limits to indiscriminate niceness after all, and those believing the words of John 14:6 definitely place themselves outside of these.
    The new pope's legacy?

    If God used Pope John Paul II to help bring down communism, might he use Pope Benedict XVI to end the hegemony of decadent secularism in Europe? Archbishop Paul Cordes thinks it possible.

    22 July 2005

    A Supreme Challenge for John Roberts

    Today's Capital Commentary is authored by Dr. Stanley Carlson-Thies, director of social policy studies at the Center for Public Justice, and it is worth posting in full in light of the recent discussions on this blog over the public witness of believers in the gospel.

    John Roberts, President Bush's nominee for the U.S. Supreme Court, faces a major task if he is confirmed: helping to craft a coherent doctrine on the religion clauses of the First Amendment. Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, whose decision to step down created the vacancy, had many strengths, but her pragmatic approach contributed to the confusion about church-state issues. The question is: What's a better approach?

    In a recent New York Times Magazine article (July 3), Noah Feldman of New York University School of Law proposed a "Church-State Solution." His analysis is thought-provoking. But his solution misses the mark. For Feldman, the core problem is how to preserve the unity of our religiously diverse nation. "Values evangelicals," he says, urge the government to adopt religiously based standards for the whole nation. Their opponents, the "legal secularists," claim that religion is divisive and must be confined to private life, leaving government entirely secular.

    Both groups are wrong, Feldman rightly claims. The consensus presumed by values evangelicals doesn't exist, and if the government makes the standards of one religious group obligatory, we will have conflict, not unity. Yet the legal secularists are also wrong. Expelling religion doesn't make the public square equally hospitable to all; rather, it excludes citizens whose convictions shape their whole lives.

    But Feldman's own solution is also a dead end. Here's his proposal: stop excluding religious argument and symbolism from public life and also stop government funding of religious organizations. That is, in order to end the unjust exclusion of religion from public debates, we must abandon the Court's genuine progress towards equal treatment, which undergirds the faith-based initiative.

    Feldman is half right. In our democracy, all citizens are free to make public arguments, so religious views can't fairly be excluded. If secularists don't like the arguments, they should counter them, and if the public doesn't find religious reasons convincing, then arguments based on those reasons will fail. Secularists should stop trying to stack the deck by banning religion from public debate. So far so good.

    Unfortunately, Feldman flirts with authorizing officials to promote a civil religion. He's courageous to oppose the ACLU and others who seek to strip away all religious symbols, as if the Constitution requires the government to pretend that our society and history are religion-free. Still, while the government should accommodate the faiths of the citizens, it must be careful not to create an official religion--not to avoid divisiveness but because Caesar is not Lord.

    The other half of Feldman's proposal is simply wrong. He says that government funding of religious social-service providers creates conflict, not common values, and so it must stop. But creating common values isn't the government's task. On the other hand, it surely is the job of government to deal fairly with organizations of every conviction and not to presume that faith-based services are somehow less legitimate than their secular counterparts.

    There is a solution to the church-state confusion, just not Feldman's. The government should honor the convictions of all citizens, discriminating neither for nor against religion when funding social services and neither for nor against religious arguments and the religious symbols and activities that constitute so much of our history and our lives together. But government officials can't be the nation's clergy. That is not merely divisive but idolatrous.

    We don't know how a Justice Roberts would rule on these important matters. We must hope that he will fight unjust restrictions on religious speech, symbols, and also institutions, while keeping limits on the government's tendency to put itself in the place of God.
    Cyprus stalemate

    Another anniversary passes 31 years after what Turkey euphemistically calls its peace operation in Cyprus. In the meantime relative freedom of movement between the two sides of the divided island has changed the political landscape. Yet the political stalemate continues for now.

    Followers

    Blog Archive

    About Me

    My photo
    Contact at: dtkoyzis at gmail dot com