What? No hockey?
Canada is in mourning today.
16 February 2005
15 February 2005
National flag day
Forty years ago today Canada adopted its current flag.

Four decades after this historic event, there are still some people who persist in believing that the old Red Ensign (not to be confused with the provincial flags of Ontario and Manitoba) is the real Canadian flag. For those interested, I have written before on the subject of Canada's flags.
Forty years ago today Canada adopted its current flag.

Four decades after this historic event, there are still some people who persist in believing that the old Red Ensign (not to be confused with the provincial flags of Ontario and Manitoba) is the real Canadian flag. For those interested, I have written before on the subject of Canada's flags.
Ottawa consultation
This past weekend I was in Ottawa for a consultation on religious freedom sponsored by the Evangelical Fellowship of Canada. It was organized by Janet Epp Buckingham, who spoke at Redeemer's graduation last May. We met at Trinity Western University's Laurentian Leadership Centre, a beautiful old building built in 1909 and used for many years by the now defunct Laurentian Club. Representatives of Trinity Western, the EFC, the Salvation Army, the Ontario Alliance of Christian Schools and Redeemer (of course) were in attendance. Discussions revolved around the institutional manifestations of religious freedom, a principle generally interpreted in narrowly individualistic fashion in Canadian jurisprudence. A plurality of people present were lawyers by profession or had at least some legal training. There was one journalist and one seminary student. Two academic political theorists were in attendence, including yours truly. The first evening three of us set forth the way our own christian traditions have historically related Christianity to politics. John von Heyking, of the University of Lethbridge, described the Lutheran approach. I recounted the Reformed Calvinist perspective. Buckingham defended an Anabaptist/Baptist viewpoint.
Easily the high point of the weekend was a visit to the home of my dear friends, Eric and Bertina Hogeterp and their two young sons. Eric is a 1993 graduate of Redeemer, where he majored in (what else?) political science. He is now research assistant for Rob Merrifield, member of Parliament for Yellowhead in Alberta. After dinner, Eric took me to visit his office in the old Justice Building.

Government of Canada
The following morning I took a long walk around the buildings on Parliament Hill and through the adjacent neighbourhoods to the south. While strolling, I saw the embassies of Iran, Hungary, Nigeria, Ukraine, the Czech Republic and the British High Commission. The Iranian embassy is right across from the Laurentian Centre.
Then back to the train station and home to Hamilton.
This past weekend I was in Ottawa for a consultation on religious freedom sponsored by the Evangelical Fellowship of Canada. It was organized by Janet Epp Buckingham, who spoke at Redeemer's graduation last May. We met at Trinity Western University's Laurentian Leadership Centre, a beautiful old building built in 1909 and used for many years by the now defunct Laurentian Club. Representatives of Trinity Western, the EFC, the Salvation Army, the Ontario Alliance of Christian Schools and Redeemer (of course) were in attendance. Discussions revolved around the institutional manifestations of religious freedom, a principle generally interpreted in narrowly individualistic fashion in Canadian jurisprudence. A plurality of people present were lawyers by profession or had at least some legal training. There was one journalist and one seminary student. Two academic political theorists were in attendence, including yours truly. The first evening three of us set forth the way our own christian traditions have historically related Christianity to politics. John von Heyking, of the University of Lethbridge, described the Lutheran approach. I recounted the Reformed Calvinist perspective. Buckingham defended an Anabaptist/Baptist viewpoint.
Easily the high point of the weekend was a visit to the home of my dear friends, Eric and Bertina Hogeterp and their two young sons. Eric is a 1993 graduate of Redeemer, where he majored in (what else?) political science. He is now research assistant for Rob Merrifield, member of Parliament for Yellowhead in Alberta. After dinner, Eric took me to visit his office in the old Justice Building.

Government of Canada
The following morning I took a long walk around the buildings on Parliament Hill and through the adjacent neighbourhoods to the south. While strolling, I saw the embassies of Iran, Hungary, Nigeria, Ukraine, the Czech Republic and the British High Commission. The Iranian embassy is right across from the Laurentian Centre.
Then back to the train station and home to Hamilton.
Coren converts
This is old news, but I somehow managed to miss it at the time. The British-born Canadian journalist and author, Michael Coren, who has been consorting with evangelicals for some time now, returned to the Roman Catholic Church last year. May we expect him to write his own version of Newman's Apologia Pro Vita Sua to recount his spiritual pilgrimage?
This is old news, but I somehow managed to miss it at the time. The British-born Canadian journalist and author, Michael Coren, who has been consorting with evangelicals for some time now, returned to the Roman Catholic Church last year. May we expect him to write his own version of Newman's Apologia Pro Vita Sua to recount his spiritual pilgrimage?
14 February 2005
Tribute to a once and future neocalvinist
Four days ago a rather remarkable lady, Mrs. Clara DeSchiffart, celebrated the centenary of her birth. She is part of the first generations of neocalvinists in the Netherlands, and her life overlapped that of Abraham Kuyper himself by 15 years. The following brief (and slightly edited) account of her life and times was written by her devoted great-grandson, Brian Dijkema.
Praise God for the life and testimony of this devoted servant of his kingdom over the course of 100 years.
Four days ago a rather remarkable lady, Mrs. Clara DeSchiffart, celebrated the centenary of her birth. She is part of the first generations of neocalvinists in the Netherlands, and her life overlapped that of Abraham Kuyper himself by 15 years. The following brief (and slightly edited) account of her life and times was written by her devoted great-grandson, Brian Dijkema.
Clara DeSchiffart (née Reitsma) was born on February 10, 1905, in a small Frisian town called Schraad. Her father and mother were typical Frisians who worked a small dairy farm. The farm was typically Dutch in that it had the barn attached to the house, and it is to this that our family attributes the cleanliness of my great-grandparents' barn when they began farming in Canada. After all, if your barn is attached to your house, you better keep it neat! My great-grandmother was one of 13 siblings. Granny was alive when Abraham Kuyper was alive -- and yes, that does make her quite old! The fact that her family was Reformed, Frisian and farmers also makes it quite likely that they were readers of Kuyper's newspapers and without a doubt supporters of the Anti-Revolutionary Party. In fact, I know the latter to be true, because Granny said that she always voted for the Reformed parties. (No, not the distant seed of Preston Manning's brainchild.)
Granny married Gerrit DeSchiffart during a hailstorm in 1928. In fact, it was not the best of days for her because she was quite ill with malaria, and immediately after the wedding ceremony, she went back to her parents' house to sleep. There were no first-night fireworks for the DeSchiffarts! However, that is not to say that their relationship didn't bear fruit. Granny and Grandpa were happily married for over 65 years before he passed away. I still remember how affectionate they were with one another even after 65 years! Grandpa would never shy from giving Granny a kiss. They had four children, 23 grandchildren, 80 great-grandchildren, and just recently, Granny has been blessed with a great-great-grandchild. Every one of us loves her.
Praise God for the life and testimony of this devoted servant of his kingdom over the course of 100 years.
13 February 2005
Mid-February notes
Who was it that said that existentialism is yesterday's postmodernism?
Local rumours to the contrary notwithstanding, Hamilton Mountain is not an extinct volcano.
What would a Calvinistic ordinary of the mass look like? Would question and answer 80 of the Heidelberg Catechism necessarily preclude such a thing?
Taking the train between Toronto and Ottawa is a most pleasant way to travel. . . unless you are in the last car, whose movements are then likely to rival the effects of turbulence in the air.
Commonwealth countries do not send ambassadors to Canada; they send high commissioners. This is a vestige of the time when residents of Commonwealth countries enjoyed a single citizenship and were thus not technically foreign to each other.
Why did the Great Litany find its way into Roman, Orthodox, Lutheran and Anglican traditions, but not into the Reformed?
For the same reason that Commonwealth countries send high commissioners to each other, Canada's Department of Foreign Affairs was once known as the Department of External Affairs.
Does anyone ever really ask the questions contained in an FAQ page and, if so, how frequently?
Might congregational church polity simply be Lockean liberalism applied to the institutional church?
Camilla Parker Bowles is not only great-granddaughter of Alice Keppel, mistress to King Edward VII; she is also 3rd great-granddaughter of Sir Allan Napier MacNab, whose palatial home, Dundurn Castle, is one of the local landmarks here in Hamilton.
Today is the first sunday in Lent.
Two calendars, two Easters
When I was growing up we celebrated Easter twice, first western Easter, which is calculated according to the Gregorian calendar, and then "Greek Easter," which is calculated according to the Julian calendar. Greek Easter would see us celebrating with a large meal at my aunt and uncle's home. Usually the two days are a week or two apart. Last year they fell on the same date. This year there are fully five weeks separating the two holidays, as western Easter falls on 27 March and Orthodox Easter on 1 May. Here are two websites, the first listing the two dates for the years 1997 through 2205, and the second listing the dates for Orthodox Easter from 1875 to 2124, in Julian and Gregorian calendars.
When I was growing up we celebrated Easter twice, first western Easter, which is calculated according to the Gregorian calendar, and then "Greek Easter," which is calculated according to the Julian calendar. Greek Easter would see us celebrating with a large meal at my aunt and uncle's home. Usually the two days are a week or two apart. Last year they fell on the same date. This year there are fully five weeks separating the two holidays, as western Easter falls on 27 March and Orthodox Easter on 1 May. Here are two websites, the first listing the two dates for the years 1997 through 2205, and the second listing the dates for Orthodox Easter from 1875 to 2124, in Julian and Gregorian calendars.
10 February 2005
Smallest premie released from hospital
This is the sort of story that easily resonates with Nancy and me, who are also parents of a premie: "'World's smallest baby' goes home." Like our Theresa, little Rumaisa was also born at 26 weeks. But whereas Theresa was 2 lb. 1 oz. at birth, Rumaisa was 8.6 oz. She is thus apparently the smallest surviving premature infant ever. Theresa was just over 10 weeks in hospital, while Rumaisa spent nearly six months there. May God grant her parents strength as they care for their child, who will still require "round-the-clock oxygen," among other things.
This is the sort of story that easily resonates with Nancy and me, who are also parents of a premie: "'World's smallest baby' goes home." Like our Theresa, little Rumaisa was also born at 26 weeks. But whereas Theresa was 2 lb. 1 oz. at birth, Rumaisa was 8.6 oz. She is thus apparently the smallest surviving premature infant ever. Theresa was just over 10 weeks in hospital, while Rumaisa spent nearly six months there. May God grant her parents strength as they care for their child, who will still require "round-the-clock oxygen," among other things.
09 February 2005
Ash Wednesday
St. George's-By-The-River
Today marks the beginning of Lent in the western church. Given the penitential character of the season, most lectionaries appoint Psalm 51 to be sung today. Here is my own versification of the psalm, set to be sung to the Genevan tune.
Text and arrangement copyright © 2001 by David T. Koyzis
St. George's-By-The-River
Today marks the beginning of Lent in the western church. Given the penitential character of the season, most lectionaries appoint Psalm 51 to be sung today. Here is my own versification of the psalm, set to be sung to the Genevan tune.
O gracious God, be merciful to me,
according to your love that lasts for ever.
In your compassion you have failed me never;
now blot out every foul iniquity.
For well aware am I of my great shame;
these evil deeds upon my heart are weighing.
Thus have I erred and now deserve your blame,
since your commands I have not been obeying.
Your righteous judgement I have surely earned,
nor could I hope to flee your harshest sentence.
Guilty from birth and needful of repentance,
I to my sins have constantly returned.
Yet you desire that I your truth should know;
teach me your wisdom that I may live rightly.
Make me as pure as freshly fallen snow,
cleanse me with hyssop that I may shine brightly.
Fill me with joy and gladness once again,
let all these bones sing forth in jubilation.
Look not upon the deeds of my transgression,
but rather cancel out my debt of sin.
Create in me a heart of purity,
breathe into me a new and constant spirit.
Do not deprive me of your company,
nor in your wrath withdraw your holy Spirit.
Restore to me salvation's joyfulness,
uphold in me a heart willing to serve you.
So shall I teach transgressors to revere you,
that they might once more know your faithfulness.
Save me from death, O God--this is my plea--
and in your goodness I shall be rejoicing.
Open my lips, O Lord, that thankfully
your godly praise my mouth may soon be voicing.
You do not ask for pointless sacrifice;
nor would you that I offer such a token.
My gift is this: a spirit that is broken.
The contrite heart, O God, you'll not despise.
Prosper your people with your bounteous grace,
rebuild the walls around your holy city,
that we may offer you before your face
right sacrifice, as is our proper duty.
Text and arrangement copyright © 2001 by David T. Koyzis
08 February 2005
Roemer drops out
The pro-life former Indiana congressman, Tim Roemer, has quit the race for the chair of the Democratic National Committee, which will almost certainly be led by past presidential aspirant Howard Dean. Says Roemer:
The Party is scheduled to reaffirm its minority status at the weekend by electing Dean, now unopposed, as its new chair.
The pro-life former Indiana congressman, Tim Roemer, has quit the race for the chair of the Democratic National Committee, which will almost certainly be led by past presidential aspirant Howard Dean. Says Roemer:
"First and foremost, Americans don't trust Democrats to keep them safe and secure," Roemer said. "I am also deeply concerned that our proud history as the party of inclusion is in jeopardy. We are losing ground with some of our core constituencies on values and faith issues. If we do not have a serious conversation within our party about how to reach out to those who are leaving us, we will be doomed to minority party status."
The Party is scheduled to reaffirm its minority status at the weekend by electing Dean, now unopposed, as its new chair.
07 February 2005
Dispensationalism and the Left Behind books
Thus far I believe I have written about dispensationalism only once in this blog. It's not something I spend a lot of time thinking or talking about, except very occasionally to indicate that I myself am not an adherent. However, as the Texas überblogger, Joe Carter, has recently mentioned the Left Behind phenomenon, I will take another opportunity to comment on it.
First, during my youthful sojourn amongst the Baptists (mentioned immediately below), one of the authors, Jerry B. Jenkins, was apparently a member of the same congregation that our family was attending in Wheaton, Illinois. I myself do not remember him, but my mother insists that he taught sunday school to my brother. I'll take her word for it.
Second, Hal Lindsey's Late Great Planet Earth was published in 1970, when I was 15 years old. I read the book and was mesmerized by its predictions for the future, finding it at least temporarily persuasive. I began to consume similar books, including, as I recall, one by Tim LaHaye, who has obviously been around for a long time. I noticed immediately that LaHaye's and Lindsey's apocalyptic scenarios did not quite mesh, though both claimed to be taking the Bible literally. My own efforts to reconcile them didn't work either, however hard I tried.
The following year Ken Taylor's Living Bible came out, and I read it from cover to cover. I have reason to think that Taylor himself, who once visited our family home when I was in high school, is a dispensationalist. All the same, as I read his paraphrase of scripture, I failed to see what Lindsey and LaHaye claimed to find. At that point I abandoned my youthful flirtation with this somewhat eccentric, but immensely popular, system of biblical interpretation.
As for the Left Behind books themselves, I freely admit that I have not read them, so I will not comment on them directly, except to say that, from what I do know of them, they sound like a bad idea all round. Perhaps someone needs to write apocalyptic novels from an amillennial perspective, but my guess is that they are likely to be far less exciting and thus less lucrative for the authors. Moving beyond the novel genre, I myself will recommend an old classic, Augustine's City of God, whose vision of history and its ultimate consummation has stood the test of time and is still being read after a millennium and a half.
Thus far I believe I have written about dispensationalism only once in this blog. It's not something I spend a lot of time thinking or talking about, except very occasionally to indicate that I myself am not an adherent. However, as the Texas überblogger, Joe Carter, has recently mentioned the Left Behind phenomenon, I will take another opportunity to comment on it.
First, during my youthful sojourn amongst the Baptists (mentioned immediately below), one of the authors, Jerry B. Jenkins, was apparently a member of the same congregation that our family was attending in Wheaton, Illinois. I myself do not remember him, but my mother insists that he taught sunday school to my brother. I'll take her word for it.
Second, Hal Lindsey's Late Great Planet Earth was published in 1970, when I was 15 years old. I read the book and was mesmerized by its predictions for the future, finding it at least temporarily persuasive. I began to consume similar books, including, as I recall, one by Tim LaHaye, who has obviously been around for a long time. I noticed immediately that LaHaye's and Lindsey's apocalyptic scenarios did not quite mesh, though both claimed to be taking the Bible literally. My own efforts to reconcile them didn't work either, however hard I tried.
The following year Ken Taylor's Living Bible came out, and I read it from cover to cover. I have reason to think that Taylor himself, who once visited our family home when I was in high school, is a dispensationalist. All the same, as I read his paraphrase of scripture, I failed to see what Lindsey and LaHaye claimed to find. At that point I abandoned my youthful flirtation with this somewhat eccentric, but immensely popular, system of biblical interpretation.
As for the Left Behind books themselves, I freely admit that I have not read them, so I will not comment on them directly, except to say that, from what I do know of them, they sound like a bad idea all round. Perhaps someone needs to write apocalyptic novels from an amillennial perspective, but my guess is that they are likely to be far less exciting and thus less lucrative for the authors. Moving beyond the novel genre, I myself will recommend an old classic, Augustine's City of God, whose vision of history and its ultimate consummation has stood the test of time and is still being read after a millennium and a half.
The Baptists and soul competency
Although I was raised Presbyterian, I spent my youth worshipping with the Baptists. During that time I don't recall ever coming into contact with the notion of soul competency, a doctrine which appears to be one of the Baptist distinctives. Here is how the Southern Baptist Convention's website defines it:
There is a more in-depth explanation of soul competency in C. B. Hastings' Introducing the Southern Baptists. This somewhat exaggerated emphasis on the individual's relationship to God seems to me to have two significant negative implications.
First, if something like soul competency had been present in the early centuries of the church, it would have made it impossible for the church as a corporate institution, among other things, to recognize authoritatively the canon of scripture, to address the Arian and other heresies, and to pronounce on the christological doctrines that we have come to accept as part of the legacy of the early ecumenical councils. Baptists, in so far as they are orthodox Christians, appear to accept this larger legacy, but not the institutional means by which it was achieved. Yet it is difficult to envision the Apostle Paul refraining from exhorting the Corinthians, Ephesians, Galatians, &c., on the grounds that he was interfering with their soul competency. Similarly, it is not difficult to imagine the response of the bearers of the decision of the Jerusalem council (Acts 15) if their hearers had had the temerity to claim exemption based on soul competency.
Second, it would seem to make the institutional church into a mere voluntary association of like-minded believers whose individual consciences have led them to similar conclusions. The pain of schism and of churches out of communion with each other is played down as nothing more offensive than the tendency of fallible human beings to disagree with each other. (There is some of this reasoning in the Reformed theologian Herman Bavinck, who should have known better.) Moreover, the institutional church, rather than teaching authoritatively and disciplining its members in true faith, takes its place alongside "sports clubs, friendly societies, colleges, symphony subscription-guilds, political parties and so on," as one more voluntary association from which withdrawal poses no "grave or irremediable loss," as Oliver O'Donovan puts it.
At the same time, there is much to like about Baptists. In my experience, Baptists have a genuine zeal for the scriptures and for evangelization that puts other Christians to shame. Here in Hamilton, the Baptist churches appear to be bursting at the seams. The same can hardly be said of the Anglican, United and Presbyterian churches. (It can be said of the Catholics, however.) The very emphasis on the individual believer's status before God encourages in Baptists a holy concern to exert themselves in the cultivation of personal piety and the spread of the gospel. Would that other Christians with more corporate ecclesiologies might learn from their Baptist brethren in this.
Although I was raised Presbyterian, I spent my youth worshipping with the Baptists. During that time I don't recall ever coming into contact with the notion of soul competency, a doctrine which appears to be one of the Baptist distinctives. Here is how the Southern Baptist Convention's website defines it:
We affirm soul competency, the accountability of each person before God. Your family cannot save you. Neither can your church. It comes down to you and God. Authorities can't force belief or unbelief. They shouldn't try.
There is a more in-depth explanation of soul competency in C. B. Hastings' Introducing the Southern Baptists. This somewhat exaggerated emphasis on the individual's relationship to God seems to me to have two significant negative implications.
First, if something like soul competency had been present in the early centuries of the church, it would have made it impossible for the church as a corporate institution, among other things, to recognize authoritatively the canon of scripture, to address the Arian and other heresies, and to pronounce on the christological doctrines that we have come to accept as part of the legacy of the early ecumenical councils. Baptists, in so far as they are orthodox Christians, appear to accept this larger legacy, but not the institutional means by which it was achieved. Yet it is difficult to envision the Apostle Paul refraining from exhorting the Corinthians, Ephesians, Galatians, &c., on the grounds that he was interfering with their soul competency. Similarly, it is not difficult to imagine the response of the bearers of the decision of the Jerusalem council (Acts 15) if their hearers had had the temerity to claim exemption based on soul competency.
Second, it would seem to make the institutional church into a mere voluntary association of like-minded believers whose individual consciences have led them to similar conclusions. The pain of schism and of churches out of communion with each other is played down as nothing more offensive than the tendency of fallible human beings to disagree with each other. (There is some of this reasoning in the Reformed theologian Herman Bavinck, who should have known better.) Moreover, the institutional church, rather than teaching authoritatively and disciplining its members in true faith, takes its place alongside "sports clubs, friendly societies, colleges, symphony subscription-guilds, political parties and so on," as one more voluntary association from which withdrawal poses no "grave or irremediable loss," as Oliver O'Donovan puts it.
At the same time, there is much to like about Baptists. In my experience, Baptists have a genuine zeal for the scriptures and for evangelization that puts other Christians to shame. Here in Hamilton, the Baptist churches appear to be bursting at the seams. The same can hardly be said of the Anglican, United and Presbyterian churches. (It can be said of the Catholics, however.) The very emphasis on the individual believer's status before God encourages in Baptists a holy concern to exert themselves in the cultivation of personal piety and the spread of the gospel. Would that other Christians with more corporate ecclesiologies might learn from their Baptist brethren in this.
06 February 2005
Evans on Kierkegaard
Does God command us to do good works because they are good? Or does he command them because he decrees them to be good? If the former is true, then the good would seem to be antecedent to and independent of God, who thus becomes less than God. If the latter is true, he would seem to be arbitrary. This is the dilemma which Baylor University's C. Stephen Evans brought before a faculty and student audience late friday afternoon and into the evening. Evans has recently written a book, Kierkegaard's Ethic of Love: Divine Commands and Moral Obligations, published last year by Oxford. Drawing on this book, Evans lucidly explicated the thought of Danish philosopher Søren Kierkegaard, as found primarily in his Works of Love.
Kierkegaard follows a divine command ethic which sees God's command to love our neighbours standing at the origin of our activities as human beings created in his image. This is in contrast to the likes of Reinhold Niebuhr, who sees love and justice standing in dialectical relationship to each other. It is also in contrast to John Rawls, who anchors ethics in the flimsy foundation of mutual contract.
But can love be commanded? Contemporary opinion says no, as love is considered not genuine if forced. Isn't love spontaneous? This is perhaps true of the preferential love which spawns friendship and erotic attraction. But neighbour love is something different and stands at the origin of all good works. Jesus himself invokes the great commandment calling for love of God and neighbour. Our modern world, whether it comes in the guise of a prechristian paganism, a postchristian secularism or a complacent Christendom, has great difficulty with this notion.
Somewhat surprisingly, Evans identifies this neighbour love as an emotion. Can a mere emotion be an adequate foundation for ethics? Evans says yes. I disagree. One need hardly follow the Greeks in vilifying the emotions to recognize that neighbour love is much more than this. Love partakes of all the aspects of reality, not only the emotional. In short, love includes the emotions but is not to be identified with them.
Now I am interested in reading Kierkegaard, whose divine command ethic has obvious relevance for my own work on authority.
Does God command us to do good works because they are good? Or does he command them because he decrees them to be good? If the former is true, then the good would seem to be antecedent to and independent of God, who thus becomes less than God. If the latter is true, he would seem to be arbitrary. This is the dilemma which Baylor University's C. Stephen Evans brought before a faculty and student audience late friday afternoon and into the evening. Evans has recently written a book, Kierkegaard's Ethic of Love: Divine Commands and Moral Obligations, published last year by Oxford. Drawing on this book, Evans lucidly explicated the thought of Danish philosopher Søren Kierkegaard, as found primarily in his Works of Love.
Kierkegaard follows a divine command ethic which sees God's command to love our neighbours standing at the origin of our activities as human beings created in his image. This is in contrast to the likes of Reinhold Niebuhr, who sees love and justice standing in dialectical relationship to each other. It is also in contrast to John Rawls, who anchors ethics in the flimsy foundation of mutual contract.
But can love be commanded? Contemporary opinion says no, as love is considered not genuine if forced. Isn't love spontaneous? This is perhaps true of the preferential love which spawns friendship and erotic attraction. But neighbour love is something different and stands at the origin of all good works. Jesus himself invokes the great commandment calling for love of God and neighbour. Our modern world, whether it comes in the guise of a prechristian paganism, a postchristian secularism or a complacent Christendom, has great difficulty with this notion.
Somewhat surprisingly, Evans identifies this neighbour love as an emotion. Can a mere emotion be an adequate foundation for ethics? Evans says yes. I disagree. One need hardly follow the Greeks in vilifying the emotions to recognize that neighbour love is much more than this. Love partakes of all the aspects of reality, not only the emotional. In short, love includes the emotions but is not to be identified with them.
Now I am interested in reading Kierkegaard, whose divine command ethic has obvious relevance for my own work on authority.
05 February 2005
04 February 2005
Children of Abraham?
Abraham is big these days. My wife recently published a scholarly monograph on Abraham traditions in early Judaism. The three monotheistic religions of Judaism, Christianity and Islam are often referred to collectively as the Abrahamic religions, since their adherents count Abraham as their spiritual forebear. But what if there is more to this connection than is currently supposed? Fr. Richard John Neuhaus, responding to David Klinghoffer’s Why the Jews Rejected Jesus, raises an intriguing possibility:
If Neuhaus is correct, and given the apparent implications of statistical genealogy, there would seem to be a good possibility that most Christians -- at least those in the middle east and in the west with longstanding christian roots -- are, quite literally and biologically, children of Abraham. One can only imagine what impact this knowledge might have on Jewish-Christian relations.

Mother of God Church
Later: Here are population statistics from Jeff Malka's Sephardic Genealogical Resources:
Malka's total population figures differ with Neuhaus' sources by one million, but both appear to agree that Jews constituted one-tenth of the Roman Empire's population, which I admit comes as a surprise to me. That Jews made up fully one-quarter of the population in the eastern Empire is even more remarkable. Of course, Iran, Yemen and Ethiopia were not part of the Empire, and "Babylon" (Mesopotamia) was only briefly within its boundaries.
Abraham is big these days. My wife recently published a scholarly monograph on Abraham traditions in early Judaism. The three monotheistic religions of Judaism, Christianity and Islam are often referred to collectively as the Abrahamic religions, since their adherents count Abraham as their spiritual forebear. But what if there is more to this connection than is currently supposed? Fr. Richard John Neuhaus, responding to David Klinghoffer’s Why the Jews Rejected Jesus, raises an intriguing possibility:
Scholars generally agree that in the first century there were approximately six million Jews in the Roman Empire (for some reason, Klinghoffer says five million). That was about one tenth of the entire population. About one million were in Palestine, including today’s State of Israel, while those in the diaspora were very much part of the establishment in cities such as Alexandria and Constantinople. At one point Klinghoffer acknowledges that, during the life of Jesus, only a minuscule minority of Jews either accepted or rejected Jesus, for the simple reason that most Jews had not heard of him. Some scholars have noted that, by the fourth or fifth century, there were only a few hundred thousand, at most a million, people who identified themselves as Jews. What happened to the millions of others? The most likely answer, it is suggested, is that they became Christians.
If Neuhaus is correct, and given the apparent implications of statistical genealogy, there would seem to be a good possibility that most Christians -- at least those in the middle east and in the west with longstanding christian roots -- are, quite literally and biologically, children of Abraham. One can only imagine what impact this knowledge might have on Jewish-Christian relations.
Mother of God Church
Later: Here are population statistics from Jeff Malka's Sephardic Genealogical Resources:
Jews in Roman Empire:
Malka's total population figures differ with Neuhaus' sources by one million, but both appear to agree that Jews constituted one-tenth of the Roman Empire's population, which I admit comes as a surprise to me. That Jews made up fully one-quarter of the population in the eastern Empire is even more remarkable. Of course, Iran, Yemen and Ethiopia were not part of the Empire, and "Babylon" (Mesopotamia) was only briefly within its boundaries.
03 February 2005
Ted Kennedy pro-life?
The following would appear to be a statement written by a typical pro-lifer:
Could Senator Edward M. Kennedy really have written these words to a constituent some three decades ago? So reports William McGurn. One wonders what would happen if a pro-life Republican president were to put this quote in his state of the union address.
The following would appear to be a statement written by a typical pro-lifer:
While the deep concern of a woman bearing an unwanted child merits consideration and sympathy, it is my personal feeling that the legalization of abortion on demand is not in accordance with the value which our civilization places on human life. Wanted or unwanted, I believe that human life, even at its earliest stages, has certain rights which must be recognized—the right to be born, the right to love, the right to grow old.
Could Senator Edward M. Kennedy really have written these words to a constituent some three decades ago? So reports William McGurn. One wonders what would happen if a pro-life Republican president were to put this quote in his state of the union address.
Turkish model for Palestine?
Visiting Ankara, the new Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas states that his people see Turkey "as a model on the way to democracy." Well, I suppose if you're in Iqaluit, Toronto must look like the tropics.
Visiting Ankara, the new Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas states that his people see Turkey "as a model on the way to democracy." Well, I suppose if you're in Iqaluit, Toronto must look like the tropics.
01 February 2005
Homeschooling, parenthood and differentiated responsibilities
Prison Fellowship President Mark Earley writes of one of the advantages of homeschooling, which is a growing phenomenon south of the border:
To which I say, yes, but. . . .
Where do the fathers fit in? It is certainly true that motherhood requires more hands-on care of children, especially in the early years. Yet fatherhood is also a calling which needs to be cultivated in deliberate fashion. Fathers need to be involved in their children's, and especially their sons', education. To be sure, it may not be possible, because of work responsibilities, for fathers to play as large a role as mothers in this, but they should be involved somehow and to as great an extent as possible.
Furthermore, one ought not assume that being a wife and mother exhaustively defines a woman's responsibilities in God's world. Here is James W. Skillen from his recent In Pursuit of Justice:
If Earley were to recognize this, he might take a somewhat different approach to the larger issue of women's roles in and out of the home.
Prison Fellowship President Mark Earley writes of one of the advantages of homeschooling, which is a growing phenomenon south of the border:
Activities like homeschooling can help us to see being a wife and mother as what is: a calling, not a dead end. Our efforts yield tangible, as well as intangible, results. This is part of the reason that, as of 2003, more than 1.1 million children were being educated at home—an increase of 30 percent in only four years. Homeschoolers score higher on tests, and they take academic honors—like the Patrick Henry College students, all homeschooled, who recently beat a team from Oxford University in an international debate competition.
To which I say, yes, but. . . .
Where do the fathers fit in? It is certainly true that motherhood requires more hands-on care of children, especially in the early years. Yet fatherhood is also a calling which needs to be cultivated in deliberate fashion. Fathers need to be involved in their children's, and especially their sons', education. To be sure, it may not be possible, because of work responsibilities, for fathers to play as large a role as mothers in this, but they should be involved somehow and to as great an extent as possible.
Furthermore, one ought not assume that being a wife and mother exhaustively defines a woman's responsibilities in God's world. Here is James W. Skillen from his recent In Pursuit of Justice:
One of the important fruits of social differentiation and public-legal integration is that people can exercise many different resonsibilities all at the same time. Less differentiated societies often have fixed and relatively few roles for individuals. It has been possible in different societies at different points in history to think in terms of permanent classes and gender roles. Yet even with a high view of marriage as a life-long, intimate bond and of family as the most fundamental of social relationships, one can see that the marital and family roles do not exhaustively define women any more than they exhaustively define men. With changes in employment patterns, social attitudes, and public laws, it becomes possible within relatively well-balanced, differentiated societies for women as well as men to enter into marriage and build strong families while also developing a diverse range of talents and fulfilling diverse responsibilities outside the home (pp. 39-40).
If Earley were to recognize this, he might take a somewhat different approach to the larger issue of women's roles in and out of the home.
Roman and Greek numerals
Those who have difficulty reading Roman numerals will likely appreciate Bob Baird on "Countdown to XXXIX," in which he discusses the big change forthcoming in the numbering of Superbowl football games after this year. (Hint: an "L" is coming to join all the Vs, Is and Xs.) If people have trouble with Roman numerals, virtually everyone -- even a Byzantine-rite Calvinist -- finds it difficult to make sense of Greek numerals, which are used rarely in the west and even in the Greek-speaking world. I have several Greek Bibles in my personal library using this numbering system, but, apart from these, its use is obviously not widespread nowadays.
Those who have difficulty reading Roman numerals will likely appreciate Bob Baird on "Countdown to XXXIX," in which he discusses the big change forthcoming in the numbering of Superbowl football games after this year. (Hint: an "L" is coming to join all the Vs, Is and Xs.) If people have trouble with Roman numerals, virtually everyone -- even a Byzantine-rite Calvinist -- finds it difficult to make sense of Greek numerals, which are used rarely in the west and even in the Greek-speaking world. I have several Greek Bibles in my personal library using this numbering system, but, apart from these, its use is obviously not widespread nowadays.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

