Who said this?
"The man who is not a socialist at 20 has no heart, but if he is still a socialist at 40 he has no head."
I recall reading this saying some three decades ago, and for a long time I had thought this was one of Winston Churchill's long list of quotable aphorisms. However, in this article on John Howard's appeal to Australian youth, Caroline Overington ascribes it to former French Prime Minister Aristide Briand, who had once been a socialist himself before being kicked out of the party. However, this website suggests that Briand may have borrowed the saying from an earlier French statesman, François Guizot, who had phrased it this way: "Not to be a republican at twenty is proof of want of heart; to be one at thirty is proof of want of head." I suppose it's still possible Churchill could have said some variant of this at some point, but this site indicates the lack of documented evidence for him having done so publicly.
27 February 2006
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Followers
Blog Archive
-
▼
2006
(281)
-
▼
February
(27)
- Who said this?"The man who is not a socialist at 2...
- Marriage as public goodHere is a book that looks t...
- Missed opportunitiesIt seems I'm not the only pers...
- Muzzling bizarre viewpointsRabbi Daniel Lapin, of ...
- A Hitchcock film 7 decades laterMark Steyn reflect...
- Catholics and the Democratic PartyGiven that I've ...
- Bush blunder beggars beliefCould it be possible th...
- Spec sceptical of Tory's ToriesJohn Tory's proposa...
- Reforming the judicial appointment processGiven th...
- Tory's Tories committed to justiceProvincial Tory ...
- Ottawa conferenceThis looks like a worthwhile even...
- Vale post to no availI seem inadvertently to have ...
- What’s five times nothing?Neither Australia nor Ne...
- Did you know . . .. . . that veteran actor Christo...
- Antipodean sojourn VI: tying up loose endsOne mont...
- Garbled lyricsOne evening last week I was putting ...
- We'll stick with gregorian chant, thank youIs this...
- Another Conservative misstep?Ted Menzies, the new ...
- Acton ad on targetAlthough I am not an uncritical ...
- Hail, Britannia?Mark Steyn lauds the largely salut...
- Antipodean sojourn V: politicsWhen my trip to Aust...
- Conservative misstep and Senate reformIt seems I'm...
- The new teamThe Right Honourable Stephen Joseph Ha...
- Will wonders never ceaseEven the most hardened sce...
- Antipodean sojourn IV: AustraliansI’ve discussed e...
- Leo Strauss in the True North?With the election of...
- Intelligent designGiven that I am not a biologist,...
-
▼
February
(27)
No comments:
Post a Comment