Grant and Ignatieff
I wrote yesterday of the irony of George Grant being related to Michael Ignatieff. If Grant were still alive, he would certainly disapprove of the direction Ignatieff has taken in his adherence to liberalism.
On wednesday one of my colleagues suggested to me that the turning point in Ignatieff's thought may have come through his study of nationalism, particularly his Blood and Belonging: Journeys into the New Nationalism, which was both an award-winning book and a public television series. In coming to understand the dangers of nationalism, with its distorted notion of community, he took refuge in the individualism of liberalism, with its (over)emphasis on rights.
It is typical that, when one comes to understand the defects of one ideology, one tends to embrace an opposite distortion. The oppressions of nationalism cause its victims to flee into the waiting arms of liberalism. Similarly, the fragmenting effects of liberalism often prompt those bearing its brunt to seek shelter in the nationalist fold. It's a potentially endless cycle from which it is difficult to break out. I hope my book will help readers to see through this.
08 August 2003
A pastor's journey
At the weekend I picked up a wonderful book, Open Secrets: A Memoir of Faith and Discovery, by Richard Lischer. It is a beautifully written (though not always well edited) account of the author's growing up in the Lutheran Church - Missouri Synod, his call to the pastorate, and his first parish in rural southern Illinois. He details the (presumably heavily fictionalized) lives of his parishioners and his attempts to lead them and communicate to them something of God's grace in the midst of their all too human troubles. In the process he becomes aware of how his own pride is hindering his ministry and how God's grace cuts even through that.
His denomination has long operated schools in which boys are educated for the pastorate from an early age. Lischer tells of his experience at one of these in Milwaukee:
Open Secrets is definitely worth reading.
At the weekend I picked up a wonderful book, Open Secrets: A Memoir of Faith and Discovery, by Richard Lischer. It is a beautifully written (though not always well edited) account of the author's growing up in the Lutheran Church - Missouri Synod, his call to the pastorate, and his first parish in rural southern Illinois. He details the (presumably heavily fictionalized) lives of his parishioners and his attempts to lead them and communicate to them something of God's grace in the midst of their all too human troubles. In the process he becomes aware of how his own pride is hindering his ministry and how God's grace cuts even through that.
His denomination has long operated schools in which boys are educated for the pastorate from an early age. Lischer tells of his experience at one of these in Milwaukee:
The spirituality imparted to us was the safe spirituality of structure but not of passion or abandonment. The theological categories we memorized would either stifle true spirituality for the rest of our lives or provide the skeleton for a growing and adapting organism....
Likewise, the enforced chapel services into which we dutifully filed morning and evening could either kill you or make you well. If you paid too much attention to the sermons... you might die in the spirit. But we also sang Matins every morning, and four hundred male voices chanting the Te Deum couldn't be wrong:
To You all angels cry aloud,
The heavens and all the powers therein.
To you cherubim and seraphim continually do cry,
Holy, holy, holy, Lord God of Sabaoth!
Take that prescription five mornings a week for eight years, and it just might save your life.
Open Secrets is definitely worth reading.
07 August 2003
Cyprus solution possible
The American ambassador to Cyprus is optimistic that a solution can be found there before its entry into the European Union next year, as reported in China's People's Daily. All the same, Kofi Anan is sending his special envoy for Cyprus, Alvaro de Soto, to try to settle the longstanding dispute over the Western Sahara, apparently judging that there's nothing to be done at present in the troubled island.
The American ambassador to Cyprus is optimistic that a solution can be found there before its entry into the European Union next year, as reported in China's People's Daily. All the same, Kofi Anan is sending his special envoy for Cyprus, Alvaro de Soto, to try to settle the longstanding dispute over the Western Sahara, apparently judging that there's nothing to be done at present in the troubled island.
A Canadian conservative and nationalist
One of my favourite professed conservatives is George Parkin Grant (1918-1988), who during his lifetime became Canada's foremost philosopher.

He was born in Toronto in 1918 and was descended from two rather prominent families connected with the social élite of Ontario. He was related to Vincent Massey, the first Canadian Governor General, and by marriage to George Ignatieff, former provost of the University of Toronto and Canadian diplomat, and thus, ironically, to Michael Ignatieff.
He studied at Queen’s University and Oxford in England. From 1947 to 1961 he taught in the philosophy department at Dalhousie University in Nova Scotia. Between 1961 and 1980 he taught in the department of religion at McMaster. Then he returned to Dalhousie for his remaining years until retirement. He died in September 1988.
He is probably best known by the Canadian public for his Lament for a Nation (1965), which was written in the wake of John Diefenbaker’s defeat in 1963. He expressed the belief that the downfall of the Conservative Prime Minister was due, at least in part, to the combined efforts of the Liberal Party and the Americanized economic élite, who resented his hesitation to fall in step behind John F.Kennedy’s nuclear defence policy. Although the book was billed as a lament for Canada, it actually became something of a rallying cry for a new generation of Canadian nationalists, who sought to distance the country from American economic and political power.
Grant called himself a conservative in the old-fashioned British tory tradition. He is often referred to as a "red tory" because his particular brand of conservatism took him in directions that may seem strikingly socialist to the typical North American right-winger. For example, he opposed free trade with the US and rejected capitalism, but he was also very much opposed to legalized abortion.
He was a devout Christian and a member of the Anglican Church. He converted to Christianity in England as a young man, but his brand of Christianity is heavily indebted to the tradition of Greek philosophy, especially that of Plato and the platonists. He acknowledges the influence on himself of Jacques Ellul, Leo Strauss, and Simone Weil. The latter was something of a personal model for Grant, and he regarded her as a modern christian saint.
I had the opportunity to meet Grant twice during my years living in Toronto. The first time was at a conference at York University. The second was at a famously liberal United Church congregation near the University of Toronto where he preached from the pulpit against abortion, thus rankling the sensibilities of the progressive parishioners, including one of the pastors. It was fun to watch. It was typical of Grant to do something like this.
I like Grant because he helps to shatter some of the popular stereotypes concerning liberalism and conservatism, left and right. Where I find him less persuasive is in his view that economics drives politics and that technology necessarily homogenizes local cultures. A reading of Samuel Huntington's Clash of Civilizations has laid this notion to rest, it seems to me.
Yet Grant is always rewarding reading. One need not always agree with him to enjoy his provocative style and his genuine insights.
One of my favourite professed conservatives is George Parkin Grant (1918-1988), who during his lifetime became Canada's foremost philosopher.

He was born in Toronto in 1918 and was descended from two rather prominent families connected with the social élite of Ontario. He was related to Vincent Massey, the first Canadian Governor General, and by marriage to George Ignatieff, former provost of the University of Toronto and Canadian diplomat, and thus, ironically, to Michael Ignatieff.
He studied at Queen’s University and Oxford in England. From 1947 to 1961 he taught in the philosophy department at Dalhousie University in Nova Scotia. Between 1961 and 1980 he taught in the department of religion at McMaster. Then he returned to Dalhousie for his remaining years until retirement. He died in September 1988.
He is probably best known by the Canadian public for his Lament for a Nation (1965), which was written in the wake of John Diefenbaker’s defeat in 1963. He expressed the belief that the downfall of the Conservative Prime Minister was due, at least in part, to the combined efforts of the Liberal Party and the Americanized economic élite, who resented his hesitation to fall in step behind John F.Kennedy’s nuclear defence policy. Although the book was billed as a lament for Canada, it actually became something of a rallying cry for a new generation of Canadian nationalists, who sought to distance the country from American economic and political power.
Grant called himself a conservative in the old-fashioned British tory tradition. He is often referred to as a "red tory" because his particular brand of conservatism took him in directions that may seem strikingly socialist to the typical North American right-winger. For example, he opposed free trade with the US and rejected capitalism, but he was also very much opposed to legalized abortion.
He was a devout Christian and a member of the Anglican Church. He converted to Christianity in England as a young man, but his brand of Christianity is heavily indebted to the tradition of Greek philosophy, especially that of Plato and the platonists. He acknowledges the influence on himself of Jacques Ellul, Leo Strauss, and Simone Weil. The latter was something of a personal model for Grant, and he regarded her as a modern christian saint.
I had the opportunity to meet Grant twice during my years living in Toronto. The first time was at a conference at York University. The second was at a famously liberal United Church congregation near the University of Toronto where he preached from the pulpit against abortion, thus rankling the sensibilities of the progressive parishioners, including one of the pastors. It was fun to watch. It was typical of Grant to do something like this.
I like Grant because he helps to shatter some of the popular stereotypes concerning liberalism and conservatism, left and right. Where I find him less persuasive is in his view that economics drives politics and that technology necessarily homogenizes local cultures. A reading of Samuel Huntington's Clash of Civilizations has laid this notion to rest, it seems to me.
Yet Grant is always rewarding reading. One need not always agree with him to enjoy his provocative style and his genuine insights.
06 August 2003
"Literal" used metaphorically
The other day I wrote of proportional representation:
After I wrote this I realized that I had meant the word "literally" to be taken metaphorically, if that makes any sense. The thought of people actually picking up the province, piece by piece, and running away with it brought to mind a series of rather humorous visual images which I had not, of course, intended.
One of my colleagues teaches an interdisciplinary course in metaphor. I'm not sure what she would make of my metaphorical misstep. She might use it as a bad example -- as something to warn her students not to do.
The other day I wrote of proportional representation:
It would dilute the impact of a single ideological vision and force its adherents to moderate its more extreme positions. This has implications for Quebec separatism, whose followers would not simply be able to run away -- both literally and metaphorically -- with the province.
After I wrote this I realized that I had meant the word "literally" to be taken metaphorically, if that makes any sense. The thought of people actually picking up the province, piece by piece, and running away with it brought to mind a series of rather humorous visual images which I had not, of course, intended.
One of my colleagues teaches an interdisciplinary course in metaphor. I'm not sure what she would make of my metaphorical misstep. She might use it as a bad example -- as something to warn her students not to do.
A magnificent eucharistic hymn
At the end of the sunday morning worship service at the ICS family conference we sang the beautiful eucharistic hymn, "This is the feast of victory for our God," easily the best of the recent Lutheran contributions to the liturgy of the church. The words are adapted from Revelation 5:12-13 by John W. Arthur (1922-1980), and the tune, Raymond, was composed by Peter R. Hallock (b. 1923). It is often sung in place of the Gloria in excelsis at the beginning of the service.
At the end of the sunday morning worship service at the ICS family conference we sang the beautiful eucharistic hymn, "This is the feast of victory for our God," easily the best of the recent Lutheran contributions to the liturgy of the church. The words are adapted from Revelation 5:12-13 by John W. Arthur (1922-1980), and the tune, Raymond, was composed by Peter R. Hallock (b. 1923). It is often sung in place of the Gloria in excelsis at the beginning of the service.
This is the feast of victory for our God. Alleluia, alleluia, alleluia.
Worthy is Christ, the Lamb who was slain, whose blood set us free to be people of God.
This is the feast of victory for our God. Alleluia, alleluia, alleluia.
Power, riches, wisdom and strength, and honor, blessing, and glory are his.
This is the feast of victory for our God. Alleluia, alleluia, alleluia.
Sing with all the people of God, and join in the hymn of all creation: Blessing, honor, glory, and might be to God and the Lamb forever. Amen.
This is the feast of victory for our God. Alleluia, alleluia, alleluia.
For the Lamb who was slain has begun his reign. Alleluia
This is the feast of victory for our God. Alleluia, alleluia, alleluia.
05 August 2003
An unusual household rule?
When I was growing up our family had a rule that might be considered unusual in a less musical household: no singing at the table during meals. The fact that this rule had to be invented in the first place obviously indicates that there was a need for it. We all simply sang a lot -- around the house, outside doing chores, while playing, and so forth. We would have done so between mouthfuls had this rule not been promulgated by our parents.
This proscription has been carried down to my sister's household where her daughters have also had a tendency to display their musical proclivities at inappropriate times.
And now this evening, as Nancy, Theresa and I sat at the supper table, Theresa started to sing, caught herself, and then ended with "Don't sing at the table."
They say the movie "Chicago" may bring back the musical. I suppose I wasn't entirely aware that it had fallen out of fashion. It never seemed to me at all unusual that Julie Andrews would belt out a Rogers and Hammerstein song while on the bus to Captain von Trapp's palatial home. Or that Rex Harrison and Audrey Hepburn (neither of whom was exactly skilled at singing) would rhapsodize about the rain in Spain on the spur of the moment.
Even now I almost always have music running through my head. Most of the time I don't sing audibly, because I know that, unlike Andrews on the bus, I would catch the stares of curious strangers. However, I do whistle a fair bit, something marginally more acceptable than singing outright in a public place.
But -- never at the dinner table.
When I was growing up our family had a rule that might be considered unusual in a less musical household: no singing at the table during meals. The fact that this rule had to be invented in the first place obviously indicates that there was a need for it. We all simply sang a lot -- around the house, outside doing chores, while playing, and so forth. We would have done so between mouthfuls had this rule not been promulgated by our parents.
This proscription has been carried down to my sister's household where her daughters have also had a tendency to display their musical proclivities at inappropriate times.
And now this evening, as Nancy, Theresa and I sat at the supper table, Theresa started to sing, caught herself, and then ended with "Don't sing at the table."
They say the movie "Chicago" may bring back the musical. I suppose I wasn't entirely aware that it had fallen out of fashion. It never seemed to me at all unusual that Julie Andrews would belt out a Rogers and Hammerstein song while on the bus to Captain von Trapp's palatial home. Or that Rex Harrison and Audrey Hepburn (neither of whom was exactly skilled at singing) would rhapsodize about the rain in Spain on the spur of the moment.
Even now I almost always have music running through my head. Most of the time I don't sing audibly, because I know that, unlike Andrews on the bus, I would catch the stares of curious strangers. However, I do whistle a fair bit, something marginally more acceptable than singing outright in a public place.
But -- never at the dinner table.
Long weekend in Alberta
This past weekend I spent at the Deer Valley Meadows camp ground, east of Red Deer, Alberta, speaking at the ICS Family Conference on the topic of "War and Peace: Understanding the Conflicting Spirits." It was quite an enjoyable experience. It was the first event at which I was the principal -- nay, only! -- speaker.
This was only the second time I had visited the province of Alberta, the first being ten years ago. I was pleased to renew some old friendships and to get to know some new friends as well. The Albertan landscape is quite different from what I am used to here. The soil is dusty and the flat prairie is broken up by rivers which form deep gullies, almost canyons. We even saw pelicans flying near the Red Deer River, something one doesn't see in southern Ontario, needless to say.
This past weekend I spent at the Deer Valley Meadows camp ground, east of Red Deer, Alberta, speaking at the ICS Family Conference on the topic of "War and Peace: Understanding the Conflicting Spirits." It was quite an enjoyable experience. It was the first event at which I was the principal -- nay, only! -- speaker.
This was only the second time I had visited the province of Alberta, the first being ten years ago. I was pleased to renew some old friendships and to get to know some new friends as well. The Albertan landscape is quite different from what I am used to here. The soil is dusty and the flat prairie is broken up by rivers which form deep gullies, almost canyons. We even saw pelicans flying near the Red Deer River, something one doesn't see in southern Ontario, needless to say.
01 August 2003
The benefits of PR
I have written before on this weblog and elsewhere in favour of adopting some form of proportional representation (PR), which would ensure that the proportion of popular support for a political party translates fairly accurately into the proportion of seats in parliament. Thus if the Liberals receive 38 percent of the popular vote, they should receive approximately 38 percent of the seats in the Commons, and no more.
I do not believe that instituting PR will lead to the arrival of the kingdom of God. I want to be careful not to attach overly rosy expectations to what I believe to be a necessary reform. However, here are some of the benefits likely to come from PR:
1. It would put an end to the farce whereby a party receiving only a plurality of the popular vote receives the majority of the seats and all of the political power.
2. It would force the plurality party to negotiate with other parties rather than to depend on its monopoly of party discipline over its own parliamentary caucus.
3. It would dilute the impact of a single ideological vision and force its adherents to moderate its more extreme positions. This has implications for Quebec separatism, whose followers would not simply be able to run away -- both literally and metaphorically -- with the province.
4. It would better represent the true preferences of citizens expressed at the polls.
5. It would encourage higher voter turnout, because voters would no longer fear that their votes would be wasted.
6. It would rein in the considerable powers of the prime minister, on whom there are insufficient checks in our system.
Other reforms, particularly of the Senate, are needed as well, but the institution of PR would be a major step in making our political actors more accountable to the citizens.
I have written before on this weblog and elsewhere in favour of adopting some form of proportional representation (PR), which would ensure that the proportion of popular support for a political party translates fairly accurately into the proportion of seats in parliament. Thus if the Liberals receive 38 percent of the popular vote, they should receive approximately 38 percent of the seats in the Commons, and no more.
I do not believe that instituting PR will lead to the arrival of the kingdom of God. I want to be careful not to attach overly rosy expectations to what I believe to be a necessary reform. However, here are some of the benefits likely to come from PR:
1. It would put an end to the farce whereby a party receiving only a plurality of the popular vote receives the majority of the seats and all of the political power.
2. It would force the plurality party to negotiate with other parties rather than to depend on its monopoly of party discipline over its own parliamentary caucus.
3. It would dilute the impact of a single ideological vision and force its adherents to moderate its more extreme positions. This has implications for Quebec separatism, whose followers would not simply be able to run away -- both literally and metaphorically -- with the province.
4. It would better represent the true preferences of citizens expressed at the polls.
5. It would encourage higher voter turnout, because voters would no longer fear that their votes would be wasted.
6. It would rein in the considerable powers of the prime minister, on whom there are insufficient checks in our system.
Other reforms, particularly of the Senate, are needed as well, but the institution of PR would be a major step in making our political actors more accountable to the citizens.
31 July 2003
Just borders
How does one justly draw boundaries between two states? How does one justly partition a formerly powerful but now fractious empire? Wherever one places the boundary, people will inevitably believe they are on the wrong side and feel hard done by. Worse, they may suffer persecution and outright death. This happened in India in 1947 when the British territory was divided into muslim and hindu states. It happened at the breakup of Yugoslavia and the Soviet Union in 1991. Then, of course, there is the forced partition of Cyprus in 1974. Now Ethiopia and Eritrea face a similar dilemma, as reported in this CNN report: "UN warns of 'another Cyprus' over Eritrea-Ethiopia."
There is a burgeoning subfield within political science dealing with the problems of secession, and the Beiner volume I mentioned some days ago carries some essays on this subject. Suffice it to say that virtually all boundaries, particularly when they are first demarcated, cause problems and result in injustices. I would love to see an effort by reformational scholars of politics to address this issue in systematic fashion.
How does one justly draw boundaries between two states? How does one justly partition a formerly powerful but now fractious empire? Wherever one places the boundary, people will inevitably believe they are on the wrong side and feel hard done by. Worse, they may suffer persecution and outright death. This happened in India in 1947 when the British territory was divided into muslim and hindu states. It happened at the breakup of Yugoslavia and the Soviet Union in 1991. Then, of course, there is the forced partition of Cyprus in 1974. Now Ethiopia and Eritrea face a similar dilemma, as reported in this CNN report: "UN warns of 'another Cyprus' over Eritrea-Ethiopia."
There is a burgeoning subfield within political science dealing with the problems of secession, and the Beiner volume I mentioned some days ago carries some essays on this subject. Suffice it to say that virtually all boundaries, particularly when they are first demarcated, cause problems and result in injustices. I would love to see an effort by reformational scholars of politics to address this issue in systematic fashion.
PR in Quebec at last
Here's an encouraging report from Fair Vote Canada:
I wouldn't wish to attach utopian expectations to this development, but many of the flaws in our political system are more likely to be rectified under proportional representation than under our current first-past-the-post system. Let's hope the rest of the country will catch up to la belle province.
Here's an encouraging report from Fair Vote Canada:
NEXT QUEBEC ELECTION WILL BE PROPORTIONAL
Quebec will abolish the current voting system in favour of proportional elections in time for the next provincial election. Minister responsible for Reform of Democratic Institutions, Jacques Dupuis, said on July 9, "There is a big enough consensus in our society for us to go ahead. That is the mandate I have received from the Premier."
Prior to last spring's provincial election, the Parti Quebecois government announced its intention of adopting a proportional voting system. The project has been taken up by the new Liberal government. The third party in the National Assembly, Action Démocratique du Québec, also favours the move.
At the Estates-General, held in February, 90 per cent of the participants – over 800 Quebecers from across the province – voted in support of proportional representation.
I wouldn't wish to attach utopian expectations to this development, but many of the flaws in our political system are more likely to be rectified under proportional representation than under our current first-past-the-post system. Let's hope the rest of the country will catch up to la belle province.
Mine's just right for me?
Theresa has a number of Barney videos in her collection, although she hasn't watched them recently. Barney is, of course, the purple dinosaur who appears on the American PBS television network, captivating toddlers and preschoolers alike, while less evidently appealing to their parents. Most of what is on this programme is innocuous, and much of it actually has some value, teaching the undoubted virtues of co-operation and tolerance, if not of courage and fidelity.
But there is one song which I fast-forward through when it comes on. Its refrain goes like this:
The song proceeds to describe some of these kinds, including this one:
To be sure, there are children watching the programme whose parents are divorced, and they need to be assured that they are still loved by them. But conspicuous by its absence from this song is any recognition of the tragedy of the broken home and its devastating impact on children. By repeating the upbeat refrain after this stanza, the authors of the song fail to acknowledge the hurt that divorce brings to children. "Dry your eyes, and keep singing; everything's fine," the lyrics seem to say.
I cannot help concluding that the lyrics are aimed more at assuaging the guilt of the parents than at reassuring the children. When parents hear the obviously happy youngsters on television singing "mine's just right for me," they can heave a sigh of relief and pretend that the pain is not there. Yet I imagine that there are small children now hearing that song who, as they grow to maturity, will come to hate it because it minimized the genuine anguish they felt at their parents' shattered marriage.
Theresa has a number of Barney videos in her collection, although she hasn't watched them recently. Barney is, of course, the purple dinosaur who appears on the American PBS television network, captivating toddlers and preschoolers alike, while less evidently appealing to their parents. Most of what is on this programme is innocuous, and much of it actually has some value, teaching the undoubted virtues of co-operation and tolerance, if not of courage and fidelity.
But there is one song which I fast-forward through when it comes on. Its refrain goes like this:
O, a family is people, and a family is love; that’s a family. They come in all different sizes, shapes and kinds, and mine’s just right for me; O mine’s just right for me.
The song proceeds to describe some of these kinds, including this one:
A girl I know lives with her mom; her dad lives far away. Though she sees her parents just one at a time, they both love her every day.
To be sure, there are children watching the programme whose parents are divorced, and they need to be assured that they are still loved by them. But conspicuous by its absence from this song is any recognition of the tragedy of the broken home and its devastating impact on children. By repeating the upbeat refrain after this stanza, the authors of the song fail to acknowledge the hurt that divorce brings to children. "Dry your eyes, and keep singing; everything's fine," the lyrics seem to say.
I cannot help concluding that the lyrics are aimed more at assuaging the guilt of the parents than at reassuring the children. When parents hear the obviously happy youngsters on television singing "mine's just right for me," they can heave a sigh of relief and pretend that the pain is not there. Yet I imagine that there are small children now hearing that song who, as they grow to maturity, will come to hate it because it minimized the genuine anguish they felt at their parents' shattered marriage.
30 July 2003
Orthodox Christianity and democracy
This article appears in the March 2003 (vol. 71, no. 1) issue of the Journal of the American Academy of Religion: "Byzantium, Orthodoxy, and Democracy," by Aristotle Papanikolaou. I may write further about this, as it has a theme similar to that of an article published in the Review of Politics ten years ago and written by an obscure political scientist at a small Canadian undergraduate university.
This article appears in the March 2003 (vol. 71, no. 1) issue of the Journal of the American Academy of Religion: "Byzantium, Orthodoxy, and Democracy," by Aristotle Papanikolaou. I may write further about this, as it has a theme similar to that of an article published in the Review of Politics ten years ago and written by an obscure political scientist at a small Canadian undergraduate university.
Althusius, Montesquieu and the future of federalism
The Canadian Journal of Political Science (CJPS) is the journal received by all members of the Canadian Political Science Association. The CJPS is far superior to its US counterpart, the American Political Science Review (CPSR), which is narrowly quantitative in orientation and parochially American. Its superiority is manifested in that it actually publishes articles of interest to scholars for whom the study of politics is irreducible to a positivistic understanding of science.
A particularly noteworthy article appears in the new issue of CJPS (June 2003, vol. 36, no. 2): "Federalism at the Crossroads: Old Meanings, New Significance," by Thomas Hueglin of Wilfrid Laurier University. Here is the abstract in English:
This suggests that something like asymmetrical and nonterritorial federalisms, which would have been understood by Althusius and Montesquieu, not to mention by the electors of the Holy Roman Empire, may be the wave of the future, particularly here in Canada and in an integrating European Union.
The Canadian Journal of Political Science (CJPS) is the journal received by all members of the Canadian Political Science Association. The CJPS is far superior to its US counterpart, the American Political Science Review (CPSR), which is narrowly quantitative in orientation and parochially American. Its superiority is manifested in that it actually publishes articles of interest to scholars for whom the study of politics is irreducible to a positivistic understanding of science.
A particularly noteworthy article appears in the new issue of CJPS (June 2003, vol. 36, no. 2): "Federalism at the Crossroads: Old Meanings, New Significance," by Thomas Hueglin of Wilfrid Laurier University. Here is the abstract in English:
Federalism has remained a contested concept. The constitutional certainties of the modern federal state are under attack from confederal practices of negotiated agreement. such practices have their traditional roots in the political theories of Althusius and Montesquieu. The central argument of this article is that the American Federalists broke with that older tradition and deliberately misinterpreted Montesquieu along the way. Consequently, the predominant reading of federalism emphasizes federal supremacy over the idea of a social compact among equal partners, territorial representation dominates over the recognition of social community, and the allocation of divided powers is guided by national prerogatives rather than regionally differentiated policy needs. Recent trends towards a more collaborative form of federalism indicate that the old model of constitutional federalism may be replaced by new practices of treaty federalism.
This suggests that something like asymmetrical and nonterritorial federalisms, which would have been understood by Althusius and Montesquieu, not to mention by the electors of the Holy Roman Empire, may be the wave of the future, particularly here in Canada and in an integrating European Union.
The future of Russia
Here is some good news at last out of Russia, whose population rate is well below replacement level: "Russian Abortion Rate Finally Declines." This report is from LifeNews.com:
I have long been an admirer of the Russians and their rich cultural contribution in the arts and literature. The possibility of there being fewer Russians in the future can only be lamented. Thus any good news, however modest, is to be welcomed.
Here is some good news at last out of Russia, whose population rate is well below replacement level: "Russian Abortion Rate Finally Declines." This report is from LifeNews.com:
Part of the blame for the high abortion rate lies at the feet of a horrible Russian economy. Following the collapse of communism, it took years for the economy to stabilize.
Now, following four years of better economic times, the Russian birth rate is finally back on the rise. Last year, there were 9.8 births for every 1,000 people compared to 9.1 the year before.
However, population experts still predict Russia, during the middle of the century, will be the largest country in the world but only have one-quarter of the population of the United States.
I have long been an admirer of the Russians and their rich cultural contribution in the arts and literature. The possibility of there being fewer Russians in the future can only be lamented. Thus any good news, however modest, is to be welcomed.
Review in Public Justice Report
The new issue of the Public Justice Report, of the Center for Public Justice, carries a review of my Political Visions and Illusions. As there is no name affixed to the review, I have to assume that it was written by Center president James W. Skillen.
The new issue of the Public Justice Report, of the Center for Public Justice, carries a review of my Political Visions and Illusions. As there is no name affixed to the review, I have to assume that it was written by Center president James W. Skillen.
29 July 2003
Settlers in north Cyprus could bloc settlement
Cyprus has ratified its forthcoming membership in the European Union, but the benefits will not apply to the breakaway north, as indicated in this Associated Press report. Although Turkish Cypriots overwhelmingly favour the island's reunification, their leader Rauf Denktash does not and may have a way to stay in power despite their contrary wishes.
The continued presence of these illegal settlers from Anatolia could obstruct unification. On the other hand, it is well known that Turkish Cypriots are not famously fond of their mainland counterparts, whose unwanted presence could conceivably be a catalyst for their coming to terms with Greek Cypriots.
Cyprus has ratified its forthcoming membership in the European Union, but the benefits will not apply to the breakaway north, as indicated in this Associated Press report. Although Turkish Cypriots overwhelmingly favour the island's reunification, their leader Rauf Denktash does not and may have a way to stay in power despite their contrary wishes.
Turkish Cypriots staged mass demonstrations earlier this year demanding the resignation of Turkish Cypriot leader Rauf Denktash for rejecting a United Nations reunification plan that would enable a unified Cyprus to join the EU next May.
Turkish Cypriot opposition parties saw the demonstrations as a sign they may defeat the hardliner Denktash in December's presidential election.
But they fear their victory may be blocked by the increasing influx to the north of thousands of impoverished settlers from mainland Turkey who are granted voting rights on arrival.
The continued presence of these illegal settlers from Anatolia could obstruct unification. On the other hand, it is well known that Turkish Cypriots are not famously fond of their mainland counterparts, whose unwanted presence could conceivably be a catalyst for their coming to terms with Greek Cypriots.
A child's understanding of death
We have been reading Bible stories to Theresa since she was quite small, and gradually we have been expanding the repertoire to encompass the ones dealing with death. I'm not sure whether she understands what it means that David killed Goliath or that Daniel's enemies tried to have him killed or that the Three Holy Children might have died in the fiery furnace. Yesterday she was pretending that a monster was eating her dolls, her stuffed animals, &c. But this was all fun and games.
While we were at my sister-in-law's home near Chicago two weeks ago, we came upon a newly hatched baby bird lying in a neighbour's gravel driveway, not too far from the tires of their car. The tiny bird seemed to have fallen out of its nest, or was possibly even abandoned by its mother. We were not certain which. In any event, there was only one nest nearby and that was above the kitchen window of my sister-in-law's house. There was an attempt to place the baby bird in that nest, but this proved impossible as the nest was inaccessibly lodged in a small vent.
Theresa was concerned for the baby bird, and she kept saying anxiously, "Oh no, it's going to die again," obviously unaware of death's irreversibility. I don't know what happened to the small helpless creature, but I rather imagine it did not survive beyond a few hours at most.
When Theresa was born at only 26 weeks, she rather resembled a small featherless bird with precious little flesh to fill out her bones. She had no bum to speak of, and the contours of her ribs were much too visible. Seeing that little bird brought back memories of this for me. At the very outset of Theresa's life, it was not clear that she would survive, a fate too painful for her parents to contemplate. However, medical science, a sturdy constitution, sheer determination, and the prayers of huge numbers of God's people brought her through the ordeal with remarkably few after effects.
We have told her that she was smaller than most babies when she was born. Naturally she does not yet understand the significance of this. Whether that will come in another year or two -- or maybe even longer -- I cannot say. But I do know that if God cares for the fallen sparrow and numbers the very hairs on our head, he surely loves the child born into the world too soon.
We have been reading Bible stories to Theresa since she was quite small, and gradually we have been expanding the repertoire to encompass the ones dealing with death. I'm not sure whether she understands what it means that David killed Goliath or that Daniel's enemies tried to have him killed or that the Three Holy Children might have died in the fiery furnace. Yesterday she was pretending that a monster was eating her dolls, her stuffed animals, &c. But this was all fun and games.
While we were at my sister-in-law's home near Chicago two weeks ago, we came upon a newly hatched baby bird lying in a neighbour's gravel driveway, not too far from the tires of their car. The tiny bird seemed to have fallen out of its nest, or was possibly even abandoned by its mother. We were not certain which. In any event, there was only one nest nearby and that was above the kitchen window of my sister-in-law's house. There was an attempt to place the baby bird in that nest, but this proved impossible as the nest was inaccessibly lodged in a small vent.
Theresa was concerned for the baby bird, and she kept saying anxiously, "Oh no, it's going to die again," obviously unaware of death's irreversibility. I don't know what happened to the small helpless creature, but I rather imagine it did not survive beyond a few hours at most.
When Theresa was born at only 26 weeks, she rather resembled a small featherless bird with precious little flesh to fill out her bones. She had no bum to speak of, and the contours of her ribs were much too visible. Seeing that little bird brought back memories of this for me. At the very outset of Theresa's life, it was not clear that she would survive, a fate too painful for her parents to contemplate. However, medical science, a sturdy constitution, sheer determination, and the prayers of huge numbers of God's people brought her through the ordeal with remarkably few after effects.
We have told her that she was smaller than most babies when she was born. Naturally she does not yet understand the significance of this. Whether that will come in another year or two -- or maybe even longer -- I cannot say. But I do know that if God cares for the fallen sparrow and numbers the very hairs on our head, he surely loves the child born into the world too soon.
28 July 2003
Children at the Lord's Table
I was once at a church service in which the children were called up to the front of the sanctuary before being dismissed to sunday school. It was a communion sunday, so the table at front was spread with a white cloth, on top of which were placed the bread and wine to be distributed later in the service. The children were shown the elements and told in effect, "This is what all the grown-ups are going to have after you leave, but you can't have it until you're older." I was disturbed by what was being communicated to these youngsters: "The body and blood of Christ shed for our salvation lies here before you, but it's not for you."
I have often thought that many of the Reformed churches have an inconsistent approach to the sacraments. Since the time of the Reformation, we have affirmed with the historic church that baptism is a sign of the covenant and is thus properly administered to infants. Because we believe God's grace in Jesus Christ comes to us before we are conscious of our salvation in him, we pour the cleansing waters of baptism on our newborn children, trusting that his grace will eventually work to bring them to repentance and the living of the new life. This practice flows out of our strong view of election and our belief that God's saving power is not limited to those able to express an adult faith.
But when it comes to the Lord's Supper, we suddenly find ourselves abandoning this high view of God's grace. In the Christian Reformed Church young people must first make public profession of faith before being admitted to the Lord's Table. Since this usually does not occur before the age of seventeen or eighteen, this means that they will probably not have been nourished by Christ's body and blood until they are nearly out of the parental home. Admission to the Table thus becomes a rite of passage similar to the first date, the driver's licence, going off to university and voting in an election.
Remarkably the Orthodox commune the child immediately after baptism, thereby manifesting -- at least on this issue -- a more vivid sense of God's grace than the typically Reformed Christian. I strongly suspect that this Orthodox practice is a very ancient one -- nearly 2 millennia old, in fact. Its roots are almost certainly in the Jewish passover meal, in which adults and children alike partake.
I am delighted that our family is now attending a church where children are brought up from sunday school to receive communion along with their parents. There is something incalculably rich and meaningful in having my wife and daughter accompany me to the front of the sanctuary to be nourished by the body and blood of Jesus Christ for our salvation. God's grace is for the entire family, not only for those able to theologize about it.
"Let the children come to me, do not hinder them; for to such belongs the kingdom of God" (Mark 10:14).
I was once at a church service in which the children were called up to the front of the sanctuary before being dismissed to sunday school. It was a communion sunday, so the table at front was spread with a white cloth, on top of which were placed the bread and wine to be distributed later in the service. The children were shown the elements and told in effect, "This is what all the grown-ups are going to have after you leave, but you can't have it until you're older." I was disturbed by what was being communicated to these youngsters: "The body and blood of Christ shed for our salvation lies here before you, but it's not for you."
I have often thought that many of the Reformed churches have an inconsistent approach to the sacraments. Since the time of the Reformation, we have affirmed with the historic church that baptism is a sign of the covenant and is thus properly administered to infants. Because we believe God's grace in Jesus Christ comes to us before we are conscious of our salvation in him, we pour the cleansing waters of baptism on our newborn children, trusting that his grace will eventually work to bring them to repentance and the living of the new life. This practice flows out of our strong view of election and our belief that God's saving power is not limited to those able to express an adult faith.
But when it comes to the Lord's Supper, we suddenly find ourselves abandoning this high view of God's grace. In the Christian Reformed Church young people must first make public profession of faith before being admitted to the Lord's Table. Since this usually does not occur before the age of seventeen or eighteen, this means that they will probably not have been nourished by Christ's body and blood until they are nearly out of the parental home. Admission to the Table thus becomes a rite of passage similar to the first date, the driver's licence, going off to university and voting in an election.
Remarkably the Orthodox commune the child immediately after baptism, thereby manifesting -- at least on this issue -- a more vivid sense of God's grace than the typically Reformed Christian. I strongly suspect that this Orthodox practice is a very ancient one -- nearly 2 millennia old, in fact. Its roots are almost certainly in the Jewish passover meal, in which adults and children alike partake.
I am delighted that our family is now attending a church where children are brought up from sunday school to receive communion along with their parents. There is something incalculably rich and meaningful in having my wife and daughter accompany me to the front of the sanctuary to be nourished by the body and blood of Jesus Christ for our salvation. God's grace is for the entire family, not only for those able to theologize about it.
"Let the children come to me, do not hinder them; for to such belongs the kingdom of God" (Mark 10:14).
Statistical genealogy: everyone's related to everyone else
Last year I discovered that I (and of course other members of my immediate family) are descended from Alexios I Comnenos, one of the greatest of Byzantine emperors, who reigned from 1081 until his death in 1118. He is variously my 25th through 29th great grandfather.

Alexios I Comnenos
How unusual is it to have aristocratic and royal ancestors? Not at all. If we go back 20 generations, multiplying each successive generation by 2, each of us supposedly has 2,097,152 ancestors of that generation alone. After 30 generations each of us apparently has 2,147,483,648 ancestors of that generation. After 40 generations we each have 2,199,023,255,552. These numbers are clearly fantastic, because the numbers of human beings that have ever lived on earth are far, far short of 2 trillion! This means that if we go far enough back we are descended from the same fairly small number of people many times over, particularly if our origins are in the same part of the world.
For example, each of us in my line of the family is descended from Charlemagne in more than 100 different ways through at least three of his offspring. Thus anyone claiming special status for being descended from royalty is making an exceedingly insignificant claim. It certainly will not put one in line for any thrones! The real pleasure in researching genealogy comes to those already possessing a love of history in general.
Coincidentally, shortly after I came to the above conclusions, confirmation appeared in an article by Steve Olson, "The Royal We", The Atlantic Monthly, vol. 289, no. 5 (May 2002), pp. 62-64. Citing Mark Humphrys, who maintains a website titled "Royal Descents of Famous People", Olson argues that "everyone in the world is descended from Nefertiti and Confucius, and everyone of European ancestry is descended from Muhammad and Charlemagne."
Before the fall of his regime, Saddam Hussein had employed professional genealogists to demonstrate his descent from the prophet Muhammad, obviously to enhance his legitimacy among traditional Muslims. As it turns out, virtually any westerner he would chance to meet (not to mention his fellow Arabs) is also descended from Muhammad. It's simply not a statistically significant claim.
Last year I discovered that I (and of course other members of my immediate family) are descended from Alexios I Comnenos, one of the greatest of Byzantine emperors, who reigned from 1081 until his death in 1118. He is variously my 25th through 29th great grandfather.

How unusual is it to have aristocratic and royal ancestors? Not at all. If we go back 20 generations, multiplying each successive generation by 2, each of us supposedly has 2,097,152 ancestors of that generation alone. After 30 generations each of us apparently has 2,147,483,648 ancestors of that generation. After 40 generations we each have 2,199,023,255,552. These numbers are clearly fantastic, because the numbers of human beings that have ever lived on earth are far, far short of 2 trillion! This means that if we go far enough back we are descended from the same fairly small number of people many times over, particularly if our origins are in the same part of the world.
For example, each of us in my line of the family is descended from Charlemagne in more than 100 different ways through at least three of his offspring. Thus anyone claiming special status for being descended from royalty is making an exceedingly insignificant claim. It certainly will not put one in line for any thrones! The real pleasure in researching genealogy comes to those already possessing a love of history in general.
Coincidentally, shortly after I came to the above conclusions, confirmation appeared in an article by Steve Olson, "The Royal We", The Atlantic Monthly, vol. 289, no. 5 (May 2002), pp. 62-64. Citing Mark Humphrys, who maintains a website titled "Royal Descents of Famous People", Olson argues that "everyone in the world is descended from Nefertiti and Confucius, and everyone of European ancestry is descended from Muhammad and Charlemagne."
Before the fall of his regime, Saddam Hussein had employed professional genealogists to demonstrate his descent from the prophet Muhammad, obviously to enhance his legitimacy among traditional Muslims. As it turns out, virtually any westerner he would chance to meet (not to mention his fellow Arabs) is also descended from Muhammad. It's simply not a statistically significant claim.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
