Graduation day
Today was the Eighteenth Convocation for the Conferring of Degrees, as the programme cover puts it, at Redeemer University College. It is sobering to think that I have missed only three graduation ceremonies at Redeemer. The first two, 1986 and 1987, occurred before I arrived. The third, 2001, occurred during my sabbatical. Because Redeemer is only twenty-one years old, the alumni will always be younger than I, which is another sobering thought. I understand that there were 133 graduates today, which I rather think is the largest class ever.
I suppose it is a cliché to observe that graduations are poignant occasions. As anyone who knows me will readily attest, I tend to become rather attached to my students, and, while I am happy for them and want to see them make their way "out in the world," there is always some heartache at their leaving. My prayer is that God will guide them as they embark on the next stage of their journey, knowing that they take with them, not only what I have been privileged to impart to them in the classroom, but something of my heart as well.
May God bless the graduating class of 2003.
24 May 2003
Differentiation and Robert Putnam's work
Dooyeweerd's understanding of the historical norm of differentiation has sometimes been criticized by those who would prefer to affirm a more traditional and less complex society. Darryl G. Hart appears to fall into the latter category, judging from his Recovering Mother Kirk. Indeed it is easy to fall into a certain nostalgia for premodern social patterns, especially when we are confronted with the ills of contemporary urban life.
However, it may be that Robert Putnam, a professor of government at Harvard, has provided needed empirical support for Dooyeweerd in his writings, particularly his Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1993).
Putnam's study of Italy is based on research taking place over the twenty years following the establishment of quasi-federal regional governments in that country in 1970. The new regional governments in the north, e.g., Emilia-Romagna, Toscana and Umbria proved to be most effective, while those in the south, e.g., Sicilia, Calabria and Campania were least effective.
Why? Well, not so coincidentally, the Italian north is the historic seat of the civic republics of the late middle ages, such as Florence, Genoa, Venice and Bologna. The south, on the other hand, was from Norman times ruled by various absolutist regimes well into the nineteenth century. Patterns of horizontal co-operation developed naturally in the former and not in the latter.
In the closing years of the twentieth century, northern Italians were still great joiners, joining everything from choral societies and amateur football clubs to charitable and civic organizations. The level of interpersonal trust is high in these regions. In the south, by contrast, the level of trust is low, and interpersonal relations tend to be governed by hierarchical and exploitative patron-client dynamics. Here the number of local newspapers and other civic formations is much lower than in the north.
Putnam concludes that centuries-old political cultures have contributed to the different performances of the regional governments and even to the economic gap between north and south. Social capital or its absence is all important to the vitality of a society. Writes Putnam:
If Putnam's findings are correct -- and they do seem highly persuasive -- then they shatter two enduring stereotypes:
1) Economics drives politics. To the contrary, already existing civic traditions were far more significant than economic resources in facilitating both good government and economic prosperity. This seems to refute the likes of Marx, Ellul, Canadian philosopher George Grant, and the functionalists who were the early proponents of the European Union.
2) Traditional feudal societies are more communally-oriented than advanced industrial societies which tend to atomize people. By contrast, the most industrial region of Italy is by far the north, and it is precisely here that people are most likely to join revolving credit associations, art clubs and mutual aid societies. Southern Italians are far less likely to join any type of organization and, while family ties are strong -- perhaps a little too strong, in the views of some observers -- the level of social connectedness outside families is relatively weak.
Here is where the connection may lie to Dooyeweerd's differentiated society.
Dooyeweerd argues that, as a society moves from its earlier undifferentiated status to greater differentiation, increasing numbers of social functions come to be dispersed in a larger number of communal settings. This is one of the foundations for his theory of soevereiniteit in eigen kring or "sphere sovereignty." A reactionary conservatism may attempt to reverse this process, and this in part explains the allure of German national socialism and the various European fascisms in the interwar period.
I wonder whether Putnam's findings might be seen to lend needed empirical support to Dooyeweerd in this respect: vibrant communities are associated with differentiated societies rather than with undifferentiated societies, where a single kind of hierarchical relationship dominates the multiplicity of human activities. Thus any attempt to reverse the historical process of differentiation is misguided and, quite simply, reactionary.
However, it may be that Robert Putnam, a professor of government at Harvard, has provided needed empirical support for Dooyeweerd in his writings, particularly his Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1993).
Putnam's study of Italy is based on research taking place over the twenty years following the establishment of quasi-federal regional governments in that country in 1970. The new regional governments in the north, e.g., Emilia-Romagna, Toscana and Umbria proved to be most effective, while those in the south, e.g., Sicilia, Calabria and Campania were least effective.
Why? Well, not so coincidentally, the Italian north is the historic seat of the civic republics of the late middle ages, such as Florence, Genoa, Venice and Bologna. The south, on the other hand, was from Norman times ruled by various absolutist regimes well into the nineteenth century. Patterns of horizontal co-operation developed naturally in the former and not in the latter.
In the closing years of the twentieth century, northern Italians were still great joiners, joining everything from choral societies and amateur football clubs to charitable and civic organizations. The level of interpersonal trust is high in these regions. In the south, by contrast, the level of trust is low, and interpersonal relations tend to be governed by hierarchical and exploitative patron-client dynamics. Here the number of local newspapers and other civic formations is much lower than in the north.
Putnam concludes that centuries-old political cultures have contributed to the different performances of the regional governments and even to the economic gap between north and south. Social capital or its absence is all important to the vitality of a society. Writes Putnam:
Trust lubricates cooperation. The greater the level of trust within a community, the greater the likelihood of cooperation. And cooperation itself breeds trust (p. 171).
If Putnam's findings are correct -- and they do seem highly persuasive -- then they shatter two enduring stereotypes:
1) Economics drives politics. To the contrary, already existing civic traditions were far more significant than economic resources in facilitating both good government and economic prosperity. This seems to refute the likes of Marx, Ellul, Canadian philosopher George Grant, and the functionalists who were the early proponents of the European Union.
2) Traditional feudal societies are more communally-oriented than advanced industrial societies which tend to atomize people. By contrast, the most industrial region of Italy is by far the north, and it is precisely here that people are most likely to join revolving credit associations, art clubs and mutual aid societies. Southern Italians are far less likely to join any type of organization and, while family ties are strong -- perhaps a little too strong, in the views of some observers -- the level of social connectedness outside families is relatively weak.
Here is where the connection may lie to Dooyeweerd's differentiated society.
Dooyeweerd argues that, as a society moves from its earlier undifferentiated status to greater differentiation, increasing numbers of social functions come to be dispersed in a larger number of communal settings. This is one of the foundations for his theory of soevereiniteit in eigen kring or "sphere sovereignty." A reactionary conservatism may attempt to reverse this process, and this in part explains the allure of German national socialism and the various European fascisms in the interwar period.
I wonder whether Putnam's findings might be seen to lend needed empirical support to Dooyeweerd in this respect: vibrant communities are associated with differentiated societies rather than with undifferentiated societies, where a single kind of hierarchical relationship dominates the multiplicity of human activities. Thus any attempt to reverse the historical process of differentiation is misguided and, quite simply, reactionary.
23 May 2003
Famagusta
Famagusta is located on the east coast of Cyprus. After the defeat of the Latin Christians in the Crusades, Cyprus become a kingdom ruled by the "Frankish" dynasty of Lusignan. This was in 1192, when Richard the Lion Heart turned the island over to Guy de Lusignan, who styled himself King of Jerusalem. In 1489 the Venetian Republic gained control of the island, until it was conquered by the Ottoman Turks in 1571.

Famagusta, looking south from the walled city towards Varosha
During the Frankish and Venetian eras Famagusta was at its height. Its walls were built by the Venetians, and one of its towers is known as Othello's Tower, after the character in Shakespeare's play, much of which was set here. At one point Famagusta was the richest city in Europe.

Othello's Tower
But it never recovered from the long Turkish siege of 1571, and one still hears of residents finding old canon balls dating from the events of that year.
When the Germans and Italians bombed Cyprus in 1940 and '41 my father's family would often hide within the thick walls of the old city for protection. For many years the old city has been inhabited by Turkish Cypriots. The Varosha district south of the old city was almost wholly Greek, and it was a vibrant holiday resort in the 1960s. This changed in 1974. Since then Varosha is uninhabited, although the Turkish Cypriot government has in principle conceded it to the Greek Cypriot government in the south. However, after three decades of decay, it is estimated that it would require more than one billion dollars (US) to bring it up to living standards.
Famagusta is located on the east coast of Cyprus. After the defeat of the Latin Christians in the Crusades, Cyprus become a kingdom ruled by the "Frankish" dynasty of Lusignan. This was in 1192, when Richard the Lion Heart turned the island over to Guy de Lusignan, who styled himself King of Jerusalem. In 1489 the Venetian Republic gained control of the island, until it was conquered by the Ottoman Turks in 1571.

During the Frankish and Venetian eras Famagusta was at its height. Its walls were built by the Venetians, and one of its towers is known as Othello's Tower, after the character in Shakespeare's play, much of which was set here. At one point Famagusta was the richest city in Europe.

But it never recovered from the long Turkish siege of 1571, and one still hears of residents finding old canon balls dating from the events of that year.
When the Germans and Italians bombed Cyprus in 1940 and '41 my father's family would often hide within the thick walls of the old city for protection. For many years the old city has been inhabited by Turkish Cypriots. The Varosha district south of the old city was almost wholly Greek, and it was a vibrant holiday resort in the 1960s. This changed in 1974. Since then Varosha is uninhabited, although the Turkish Cypriot government has in principle conceded it to the Greek Cypriot government in the south. However, after three decades of decay, it is estimated that it would require more than one billion dollars (US) to bring it up to living standards.
Wolterstorff visits Redeemer
This morning we Redeemer faculty were privileged to have Nicholas Wolterstorff speak to us. Wolterstorff is professor emeritus at Yale Divinity School, taught for thirty years at Calvin College, and has written far too many books and articles to list here, including Until Justice and Peace Embrace (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1983) and Divine Discourse (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995). He spoke to us on why the notion of integrating faith and learning is not a good model for a christian academic institution. The following is based on my (admittedly fallible) recollection of his remarks.
In laying out his argument he described two prevalent models and argued for a third alternative.
1) Competence plus theology and apologetics. Up until two or three decades ago this was the dominant model at many christian institutions. Faculty were encouraged to develop a competence in their respective fields that would gain them respect among their colleagues elsewhere. Typically the president of the university would teach a capstone course in the curriculum that would draw on the various disciplines for purposes of christian apologetics. However, there was no expectation of an intrinsic connection between one’s faith and one’s academic discipline.
2) Integration of faith and learning. This model presupposes two distinct things needing to be bound together, as if by twine. A variation of this model has people undertaking the “theology of” this and that. Even here there is no inner connection between one’s religious worldview and the field of study. Christian colleges and universities, particularly in the States, adopted this around a generation ago, mostly under Reformed influence.
3) Academic disciplines as social practices. This is Wolterstorff’s favoured model. It assumes that the various disciplines are on-going enterprises within which the individual scholar takes up his or her place. The fields of study are hardly neutral but presuppose the presence and activity of religious worldviews affecting their development over time. Christians should have no illusions about remaking the disciplines from scratch, but should be engaging these worldviews in the course of their work. The implications of this engagement are that Christians need to keep alive a rich christian intellectual heritage and to tell the stories of the disciplines rightly. The real test of christian learning is fidelity, and not difference as such. Sometimes the results of christian scholarship will be different, but often they will be the same. When they are the same, we properly thank God that unbelievers are doing something right.
Wolterstorff will be speaking at our graduation ceremony tomorrow afternoon.
This morning we Redeemer faculty were privileged to have Nicholas Wolterstorff speak to us. Wolterstorff is professor emeritus at Yale Divinity School, taught for thirty years at Calvin College, and has written far too many books and articles to list here, including Until Justice and Peace Embrace (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1983) and Divine Discourse (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995). He spoke to us on why the notion of integrating faith and learning is not a good model for a christian academic institution. The following is based on my (admittedly fallible) recollection of his remarks.
In laying out his argument he described two prevalent models and argued for a third alternative.
1) Competence plus theology and apologetics. Up until two or three decades ago this was the dominant model at many christian institutions. Faculty were encouraged to develop a competence in their respective fields that would gain them respect among their colleagues elsewhere. Typically the president of the university would teach a capstone course in the curriculum that would draw on the various disciplines for purposes of christian apologetics. However, there was no expectation of an intrinsic connection between one’s faith and one’s academic discipline.
2) Integration of faith and learning. This model presupposes two distinct things needing to be bound together, as if by twine. A variation of this model has people undertaking the “theology of” this and that. Even here there is no inner connection between one’s religious worldview and the field of study. Christian colleges and universities, particularly in the States, adopted this around a generation ago, mostly under Reformed influence.
3) Academic disciplines as social practices. This is Wolterstorff’s favoured model. It assumes that the various disciplines are on-going enterprises within which the individual scholar takes up his or her place. The fields of study are hardly neutral but presuppose the presence and activity of religious worldviews affecting their development over time. Christians should have no illusions about remaking the disciplines from scratch, but should be engaging these worldviews in the course of their work. The implications of this engagement are that Christians need to keep alive a rich christian intellectual heritage and to tell the stories of the disciplines rightly. The real test of christian learning is fidelity, and not difference as such. Sometimes the results of christian scholarship will be different, but often they will be the same. When they are the same, we properly thank God that unbelievers are doing something right.
Wolterstorff will be speaking at our graduation ceremony tomorrow afternoon.
22 May 2003
A Kuyperian Catholic?
Several years ago I came into contact with the writings of David L. Schindler, editor of the English-language edition of the journal Communio and Gagnon Professor of Fundamental Theology at the John Paul II Institute. Schindler is a traditional Roman Catholic in the Augustinian (as opposed to the Thomistic) tradition whose life work has been to familiarize Anglo-American Christians with the theology of Hans Urs von Balthasar.
What I find intriguing about Schindler’s work is that he sounds many of the same notes as Kuyper and Dooyeweerd and their followers. For example, in his magnificent Heart of the World, Center of the Church (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, and Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1996), he affirms that “giving glory to God is a comprehensive task for Christians, occupying not only all of their time but also all of their faculties, their mind as well as their will” (p. 205). We find what Dooyeweerd describes as the biblical groundmotive of creation, fall and redemption clearly stated in its pages. Most inspiring of all, Schindler repeatedly emphasizes that all of life – and not just the so-called donum superadditum of supernatural virtue – is a gift of God’s grace and that human receptivity to this grace is antecedent to any creativity or activity on our part:
Above all, Schindler’s book is an eloquent and spiritually-discerning critique of liberalism, particularly as championed by such “Catholic whigs” as Michael Novak, Fr. Richard John Neuhaus and George Weigel, whose efforts are in turn rooted in the Americanizing enterprise of the late Fr. John Courtney Murray. Against their efforts to expand economic freedom within a liberal framework Schindler writes:
Schindler believes that the achievements of liberalism can be salvaged, but only by “discernment of the spirits” (p. 177). This entails a reordering of the foundational understanding of life at its spiritual sources. Someone in the Kuyperian tradition would describe what he’s getting at as a recognition of God’s common grace in the midst of an effort to reorient one’s worldview at a religious root level.
Moreover, we find in Schindler a recognition of the validity of historical development which echoes something found in Albert M. Wolters’ Creation Regained, and which keeps him from being a conservative pure and simple:
This is very different from traditional scholastic dualism. It is perhaps unsurprising that, given Schindler’s approach, he can so readily cite Reformed Christian philosopher Alvin Plantinga against Fr. Theodore Hesburgh, long-time former president of the University of Notre Dame. All in all, Schindler’s is an exhilarating book. Some reviewers claimed to find it a tough slog, shall we say. But anyone familiar with Kuyperian/Dooyeweerdian categories will likely have a quite different experience reading it.
As a traditional Catholic, Schindler is careful to demonstrate the conformity of his ideas with church teachings, and especially those of the present Pope. Yet after reading the encyclical Fides et Ratio, which came out two years later (1998), I found myself wondering how credible an enterprise this really could be. Schindler’s loyalty to his church’s magisterium would likely make him uncomfortable with my saying this, but I far prefer his Heart of the World to Fides et Ratio.
Several years ago I came into contact with the writings of David L. Schindler, editor of the English-language edition of the journal Communio and Gagnon Professor of Fundamental Theology at the John Paul II Institute. Schindler is a traditional Roman Catholic in the Augustinian (as opposed to the Thomistic) tradition whose life work has been to familiarize Anglo-American Christians with the theology of Hans Urs von Balthasar.
What I find intriguing about Schindler’s work is that he sounds many of the same notes as Kuyper and Dooyeweerd and their followers. For example, in his magnificent Heart of the World, Center of the Church (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, and Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1996), he affirms that “giving glory to God is a comprehensive task for Christians, occupying not only all of their time but also all of their faculties, their mind as well as their will” (p. 205). We find what Dooyeweerd describes as the biblical groundmotive of creation, fall and redemption clearly stated in its pages. Most inspiring of all, Schindler repeatedly emphasizes that all of life – and not just the so-called donum superadditum of supernatural virtue – is a gift of God’s grace and that human receptivity to this grace is antecedent to any creativity or activity on our part:
All that is, is gift. All that we are and do and make and produce must therefore emerge from a sense of gift: I gratefully receive from God... and this provides both the warrant for and the deepest meaning of my giving to others... (p. 119).
Above all, Schindler’s book is an eloquent and spiritually-discerning critique of liberalism, particularly as championed by such “Catholic whigs” as Michael Novak, Fr. Richard John Neuhaus and George Weigel, whose efforts are in turn rooted in the Americanizing enterprise of the late Fr. John Courtney Murray. Against their efforts to expand economic freedom within a liberal framework Schindler writes:
A freedom whose nature is wrongly understood does not become good simply because it is widely distributed rather than restricted to a few. I am proposing that liberalism of any stripe – including the liberalism of “open” capitalism – remains unacceptable insofar as its freedom remains conceived as primarily creative – or rather, insofar as its creativity is not conceived as anteriorly receptive. Indeed, here we discover the basic definition of a liberalism which, at its deepest level, threatens the integrity of Christianity, because it poisons at its source the meaning of autonomy. In overlooking receptivity in favor of creativity as primary in the basic human act, such a liberalism overlooks the implications of the relation that is constitutive of the human being as creature (pp. 119-121).
Schindler believes that the achievements of liberalism can be salvaged, but only by “discernment of the spirits” (p. 177). This entails a reordering of the foundational understanding of life at its spiritual sources. Someone in the Kuyperian tradition would describe what he’s getting at as a recognition of God’s common grace in the midst of an effort to reorient one’s worldview at a religious root level.
Moreover, we find in Schindler a recognition of the validity of historical development which echoes something found in Albert M. Wolters’ Creation Regained, and which keeps him from being a conservative pure and simple:
[W]e must reject all attempts at “restoration” or “repristination.” Modernity has thematized freedom and subjectivity in a way that has forever changed our experience of the world; and this change represents a significant gain in the human condition. This initially simple acknowledgement, nonetheless, becomes complicated as soon as we attach the crucially important qualifier: there has never been an actual historical moment when modernity’s freedom or subjectivity was empty – which is to say, unencumbered by a definite worldview inclusive... of an ontology, an anthropology, and a theology....
The burden of my criticism, therefore, is not that we should refuse to endorse modern freedom, but only that our endorsement should coincide with an awareness that freedom, even modern freedom, presupposes, willy-nilly, some anthropology (ontology, theology). Any endorsement of modern freedom must therefore coincide with an evaluation of the anthropology which has always-already given that freedom its meaning (pp. 181-182).
This is very different from traditional scholastic dualism. It is perhaps unsurprising that, given Schindler’s approach, he can so readily cite Reformed Christian philosopher Alvin Plantinga against Fr. Theodore Hesburgh, long-time former president of the University of Notre Dame. All in all, Schindler’s is an exhilarating book. Some reviewers claimed to find it a tough slog, shall we say. But anyone familiar with Kuyperian/Dooyeweerdian categories will likely have a quite different experience reading it.
As a traditional Catholic, Schindler is careful to demonstrate the conformity of his ideas with church teachings, and especially those of the present Pope. Yet after reading the encyclical Fides et Ratio, which came out two years later (1998), I found myself wondering how credible an enterprise this really could be. Schindler’s loyalty to his church’s magisterium would likely make him uncomfortable with my saying this, but I far prefer his Heart of the World to Fides et Ratio.
There seemed to be server troubles yesterday, and the following post inexplicably vanished. So I'm reposting it:
Cypriot peasant cuisine: Moujendra
When I was growing up in my ethnically mixed family, we ate quite a number of foods native to Cyprus and the eastern Mediterranean region. One of these I especially came to like and we still eat it in our home. It is called moujendra (or "moukentra" -- transliterations differ) and it primarily consists of lentils and rice. Take the following ingredients:
Place lentils in a pan of boiling water and cook until tender. About a teaspoon of salt should be added to water. This should take between 30 to 40 minutes. About ten minutes or so into the cooking of the lentils, add the rice. If using brown rice, start it first and then add the lentils later. Longer cooking time will lead to a porridge-like mixture. Shorter cooking time will keep ingredients more al dente.
Chop onions and celery. In a separate shallow pan cover the bottom with the pomace olive oil and turn on heat. Add chopped onions and celery and sauté. Add pepper and coriander. Once this mixture has been sautéed sufficiently, add it to the lentils and rice. Mix and then add the wine vinegar and extra virgin oil to taste.
Other ingredients can be added as well at various stages in the process, including chopped carrots, sliced kalamata olives, sun dried tomatoes or roma tomatoes. Feel free to experiment. That's what peasant cuisine is all about.
Extra virgin olive oil comes from the first pressing of the olives. Thus it is the richest grade of oil and the deepest in colour. Pomace oil comes from the later pressings and is quite adequate for cooking.
Incidentally lentils contain tryptophan, an amino acid that boosts serotonin levels in the brain. Low levels of serotonin accompany clinical depression. That means lentils are a great mood booster -- even better than caffeine, whose side effects include heightened anxiety. When I'm feeling down, there's nothing like moujendra and a green salad to pick me up again. I call it the "lentil buzz."
Legumes and grains together contain a complete protein and can thus be used as a meat substitute.
Cypriot peasant cuisine: Moujendra
When I was growing up in my ethnically mixed family, we ate quite a number of foods native to Cyprus and the eastern Mediterranean region. One of these I especially came to like and we still eat it in our home. It is called moujendra (or "moukentra" -- transliterations differ) and it primarily consists of lentils and rice. Take the following ingredients:
1 cup dried green lentils
1 cup rice
2 to 3 bulb onions, depending on size
2 celery stalks
salt
pepper
coriander
olive oil (both pomace and extra virgin)
1 tbsp red wine vinegar
Place lentils in a pan of boiling water and cook until tender. About a teaspoon of salt should be added to water. This should take between 30 to 40 minutes. About ten minutes or so into the cooking of the lentils, add the rice. If using brown rice, start it first and then add the lentils later. Longer cooking time will lead to a porridge-like mixture. Shorter cooking time will keep ingredients more al dente.
Chop onions and celery. In a separate shallow pan cover the bottom with the pomace olive oil and turn on heat. Add chopped onions and celery and sauté. Add pepper and coriander. Once this mixture has been sautéed sufficiently, add it to the lentils and rice. Mix and then add the wine vinegar and extra virgin oil to taste.
Other ingredients can be added as well at various stages in the process, including chopped carrots, sliced kalamata olives, sun dried tomatoes or roma tomatoes. Feel free to experiment. That's what peasant cuisine is all about.
Extra virgin olive oil comes from the first pressing of the olives. Thus it is the richest grade of oil and the deepest in colour. Pomace oil comes from the later pressings and is quite adequate for cooking.
Incidentally lentils contain tryptophan, an amino acid that boosts serotonin levels in the brain. Low levels of serotonin accompany clinical depression. That means lentils are a great mood booster -- even better than caffeine, whose side effects include heightened anxiety. When I'm feeling down, there's nothing like moujendra and a green salad to pick me up again. I call it the "lentil buzz."
Legumes and grains together contain a complete protein and can thus be used as a meat substitute.
21 May 2003
Book copy received
Yesterday I received the first copy of my book, Political Visions and Illusions, which was sent by courier from InterVarsity Press. It looks good. The Redeemer Campus Bookstore says it has upped its initial order to ten copies.
Yesterday I received the first copy of my book, Political Visions and Illusions, which was sent by courier from InterVarsity Press. It looks good. The Redeemer Campus Bookstore says it has upped its initial order to ten copies.
20 May 2003
Chimps reclassified as us
I have usually considered myself to be somewhat agnostic concerning the processes whereby God brought human beings into existence. But the following report seems to illustrate rather well a form of biological reduction that would ignore the obvious with respect to the differences between the great apes and human beings: "Study: Chimps Belong In Human Genus." From the article:
On reading this I cannot help but wonder whether any chimpanzees have undertaken a similar study to determine the classification of human beings. If our two species are really so close, then I should think the possibility of this happening would be nearly as likely as the other way round.
I have usually considered myself to be somewhat agnostic concerning the processes whereby God brought human beings into existence. But the following report seems to illustrate rather well a form of biological reduction that would ignore the obvious with respect to the differences between the great apes and human beings: "Study: Chimps Belong In Human Genus." From the article:
Chimpanzees share 99.4 percent of functionally important DNA with humans and belong in our genus, Homo, according to a recent genetic study.
Previous studies put the genetic similarity between humans and chimps at 95 to 99 percent, so the new figure suggests chimps and humans are even more closely related than previously thought.
On reading this I cannot help but wonder whether any chimpanzees have undertaken a similar study to determine the classification of human beings. If our two species are really so close, then I should think the possibility of this happening would be nearly as likely as the other way round.
Children's television
In addition to familiarizing us with the Peter Rabbit stories, having a four-year-old daughter has also given us a more than passing acquaintance with children's television. Surely we're not the only parents who think that Jay Jay the Jet Plane looks like a vile genetic experiment gone horribly awry?
In addition to familiarizing us with the Peter Rabbit stories, having a four-year-old daughter has also given us a more than passing acquaintance with children's television. Surely we're not the only parents who think that Jay Jay the Jet Plane looks like a vile genetic experiment gone horribly awry?
19 May 2003
Victoria Day
Happy Victoria Day, everyone!

I don't know whether this day is celebrated in other Comonwealth countries, but here in Canada it seems to be the one holiday devoted to gardening pursuits. Most of the stores are closed, except for the gardening centres. Just this morning we ourselves purchased several flats of annuals to put in our beds. We had to battle the crowds to do so. We were not amused!
Happy Victoria Day, everyone!

I don't know whether this day is celebrated in other Comonwealth countries, but here in Canada it seems to be the one holiday devoted to gardening pursuits. Most of the stores are closed, except for the gardening centres. Just this morning we ourselves purchased several flats of annuals to put in our beds. We had to battle the crowds to do so. We were not amused!
I owe a debt of gratitude to Emeth Hesed Smith for accomplishing the impossible (for me at any rate) and installing comments on this blog. I see them on the page, but I cannot say whether or not they are yet operational.
18 May 2003
Strauss' influence in Georgetown
Many thanks to Gideon Strauss for his gracious hospitality on saturday evening. A good time was had by all. My question is: Could he be trying to form a new group of "Straussians" here in southern Ontario?
Many thanks to Gideon Strauss for his gracious hospitality on saturday evening. A good time was had by all. My question is: Could he be trying to form a new group of "Straussians" here in southern Ontario?
Leo Strauss' influence in Washington
Here is an article from saturday's National Post: "Philosopher King," Jeet Heer's account of the impact the disciples of the late Leo Strauss are having on particularly the Bush administration in the US. His influence is felt here in Canada as well:
What Heer does not mention is that the late George Parkin Grant (1918-1988) counted Strauss as an influence as well, along with Jacques Ellul and Simone Weil.
Here is an article from saturday's National Post: "Philosopher King," Jeet Heer's account of the impact the disciples of the late Leo Strauss are having on particularly the Bush administration in the US. His influence is felt here in Canada as well:
As David Frum has noted in National Review Online, Strauss's student Allan Bloom led a large-scale migration to Canada. After facing machine-gun-carrying Black Panthers at Cornell, in 1970 Bloom headed for the University of Toronto. He was soon followed by such Straussians as Walter Berns, Clifford Orwin, Thomas Pangle and even George F. Will. While Bloom returned to the United States in 1979, he left behind a network of Straussians that is now ensconced at every major university in Canada. Intellectuals influenced by Strauss, notably Ted Morton of the University of Calgary, have been a formative influence on the Canadian Alliance party.
What Heer does not mention is that the late George Parkin Grant (1918-1988) counted Strauss as an influence as well, along with Jacques Ellul and Simone Weil.
Kazantzakis and The Greek Passion
Nowadays the novelist Nikos Kazantzakis (1883-1957) is probably best known in the west for his book, The Last Temptation of Christ, which was made into a controversial film some years ago. Probably less known is another of his books on a similar theme, The Greek Passion (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1954), whose original Greek title is Christ Is Recrucified.
It is set in the little village of Lycovrissi, a predominantly Greek village in Turkish Asia Minor, right before the “Catastrophe,” that is, the expulsion of Greeks in 1922. The village priest is responsible for casting a passion play periodically performed by the villagers. As the plot unfolds, Manolios, a “strong and humble shepherd lad,” is chosen to play the Christ; Yannakos, the “sturdy merchant-pedlar,” is Peter; Widow Katerina, the village prostitute, is Mary Magdalen, and so forth. Although the play itself is never performed, Christ’s passion is nevertheless played out in real life, as each of the actors ends up living up to his role. This is culminated in the violent death of Manolios at the hands of his fellow villagers. All of this occurs under the watchful eyes of the Turkish lord, or agha, and his corrupt court.
Kazantzakis was by no means an orthodox (or Orthodox) Christian believer, and he seems to have flirted with more than one religion, including Marxism and Buddhism. Yet he was hardly a Bultmannian demythologizer either. Genuine miracles occur in his stories, as in, for example, the cure of Manolios from leprosy. God is indeed present. Yet the end of the novel is disturbing in the extreme. Manolios has indeed died, but apparently in vain, for Mustafa Kemal’s Turkish army is approaching and the villagers prepare to leave Lycovrissi for good, lest they be destroyed. The Catastrophe is at hand.
The issue for Kazantzakis is obviously not whether God exists, but whether he is who Scripture reveals him to be. For the Cretan-born novelist, God seems to be either arbitrary, making sport of his creatures and allowing them a bad end, or else powerless against the forces of evil. His acts in this world, even his miracles, are ultimately without purpose.
On Easter the Greeks greet each other with “Christ is risen,” to which the response is “He is risen indeed.” In Kazantzakis’ dark worldview there is no resurrection, only the oblivion of death. History is but “one damn thing after another,” and certainly not the story of redemption.
The Greek Passion was made into a 1957 film, titled “Celui qui doit mourir” (“He Who Must Die”), which I’ve not seen but would like to one day.
Nowadays the novelist Nikos Kazantzakis (1883-1957) is probably best known in the west for his book, The Last Temptation of Christ, which was made into a controversial film some years ago. Probably less known is another of his books on a similar theme, The Greek Passion (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1954), whose original Greek title is Christ Is Recrucified.
It is set in the little village of Lycovrissi, a predominantly Greek village in Turkish Asia Minor, right before the “Catastrophe,” that is, the expulsion of Greeks in 1922. The village priest is responsible for casting a passion play periodically performed by the villagers. As the plot unfolds, Manolios, a “strong and humble shepherd lad,” is chosen to play the Christ; Yannakos, the “sturdy merchant-pedlar,” is Peter; Widow Katerina, the village prostitute, is Mary Magdalen, and so forth. Although the play itself is never performed, Christ’s passion is nevertheless played out in real life, as each of the actors ends up living up to his role. This is culminated in the violent death of Manolios at the hands of his fellow villagers. All of this occurs under the watchful eyes of the Turkish lord, or agha, and his corrupt court.
Kazantzakis was by no means an orthodox (or Orthodox) Christian believer, and he seems to have flirted with more than one religion, including Marxism and Buddhism. Yet he was hardly a Bultmannian demythologizer either. Genuine miracles occur in his stories, as in, for example, the cure of Manolios from leprosy. God is indeed present. Yet the end of the novel is disturbing in the extreme. Manolios has indeed died, but apparently in vain, for Mustafa Kemal’s Turkish army is approaching and the villagers prepare to leave Lycovrissi for good, lest they be destroyed. The Catastrophe is at hand.
The issue for Kazantzakis is obviously not whether God exists, but whether he is who Scripture reveals him to be. For the Cretan-born novelist, God seems to be either arbitrary, making sport of his creatures and allowing them a bad end, or else powerless against the forces of evil. His acts in this world, even his miracles, are ultimately without purpose.
On Easter the Greeks greet each other with “Christ is risen,” to which the response is “He is risen indeed.” In Kazantzakis’ dark worldview there is no resurrection, only the oblivion of death. History is but “one damn thing after another,” and certainly not the story of redemption.
The Greek Passion was made into a 1957 film, titled “Celui qui doit mourir” (“He Who Must Die”), which I’ve not seen but would like to one day.
The hymns of the mass
Despite my regret at the loss to the Reformed churches of the ordinary of the mass, I must acknowledge that some of its components do occur in our hymnals in metrical form at least. For example, the Christian Reformed Church's Psalter Hymnal contains a metrical Gloria familiar to everyone, "All Glory Be to God on High"; Reginald Heber's "Holy, Holy, Holy" (Sanctus); and "O Christ, Thou Lamb of God" (Agnus Dei). However, these are not sung as often as they should be in our liturgies.
Despite my regret at the loss to the Reformed churches of the ordinary of the mass, I must acknowledge that some of its components do occur in our hymnals in metrical form at least. For example, the Christian Reformed Church's Psalter Hymnal contains a metrical Gloria familiar to everyone, "All Glory Be to God on High"; Reginald Heber's "Holy, Holy, Holy" (Sanctus); and "O Christ, Thou Lamb of God" (Agnus Dei). However, these are not sung as often as they should be in our liturgies.
16 May 2003
Book now available
I've just received word from my publisher: Political Visions and Illusions has arrived at the warehouse of InterVarsity Press and is finally available for order. The release date is still officially set for June, but it should be arriving in the bookstores shortly, a bit later in Canada and elsewhere.

The Redeemer Campus Bookstore has informed me that they expect to receive a limited number of copies for sale to the public.
On a related note, Nancy just learned yesterday that her own monograph, Paul, Power, and Monotheism, has been accepted for publication by Sheffield Academic Press. This means that Theresa is the only one in our immediate family not to have published a book. Give her time.
I've just received word from my publisher: Political Visions and Illusions has arrived at the warehouse of InterVarsity Press and is finally available for order. The release date is still officially set for June, but it should be arriving in the bookstores shortly, a bit later in Canada and elsewhere.

The Redeemer Campus Bookstore has informed me that they expect to receive a limited number of copies for sale to the public.
On a related note, Nancy just learned yesterday that her own monograph, Paul, Power, and Monotheism, has been accepted for publication by Sheffield Academic Press. This means that Theresa is the only one in our immediate family not to have published a book. Give her time.
The fate of the first Christendom
One of the more significant books to come out last year was Philip Jenkins’ The Next Christendom: The Coming of Global Christianity (New York: Oxford University Press, 2002). Jenkins’ prediction of a dynamic christian future in Africa and Asia is impressive enough, but I was particularly intrigued by his history, especially the tragic fate of what might be called the “first Christendom” in the old eastern Roman world. Here is Jenkins himself:
I have recently read Bat Ye’or’s The Decline of Eastern Christianity Under Islam: From Jihad to Dhimmitude (Cranbury, New Jersey: Associated University Presses, 1996), whose interpretation of history is similar to Jenkins’. She goes to great lengths to demonstrate that for nearly fourteen centuries the huge numbers of Christians and Jews in the Middle East and north Africa were subjected by their conquerors to systematic pressure to convert to the conquering religion. The first generations held out, but eventually such policies had their inevitable effect, leading to the long term decline of the first Christendom and its replacement by muslim majorities within the dar al-Islam, i.e., the territory under muslim rule.
In one of my classes this past year I had a student who is an Assyrian Christian born in Iraq. The numbers of such Christians are uncertain, but estimates range from 1 to 2.5 million in Iraq, with two to four times that many living in an Assyrian diaspora in Europe, North America and Australia. Their native language is Aramaic or Syriac, once the lingua franca of the old fertile crescent.
Middle Eastern Christians tend not to receive a very good press in the west, despite their status as the aboriginal inhabitants of the region. But I myself have come to have a great deal of admiration for them. After all, these are believers who have held firm against formidable odds for more than fifty generations, when most of their co-religionists did not. In the latter half of the twentieth century, by contrast, western churches emptied within a very few years, and for less significant reasons.
The Copts, the Maronites, the Assyrians, and others are the first Christendom. The west is the second Christendom. The next Christendom, if Jenkins is correct, will be centred in Africa, but also in Korea and China. Yet I wonder whether, in the providence of God, there might not be a significant future role to be played by the descendants of the original Syriac-speaking followers of Jesus Christ – if not in the Middle East, then perhaps in the diaspora.
One of the more significant books to come out last year was Philip Jenkins’ The Next Christendom: The Coming of Global Christianity (New York: Oxford University Press, 2002). Jenkins’ prediction of a dynamic christian future in Africa and Asia is impressive enough, but I was particularly intrigued by his history, especially the tragic fate of what might be called the “first Christendom” in the old eastern Roman world. Here is Jenkins himself:
As late as the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, Christians still made up a large proportion of most former Roman territories that had fallen under Muslim rule, in societies like Syria, Mesopotamia, and Egypt, and it is not easy to tell when Muslims actually gained majority status in these communities. A reasonable guess would place the transition around the time of the Crusades, about 1100 or 1200 (p. 22).
The size of the Christian communities in the East is significant because in the Middle Ages, the Eastern lands were more densely populated than those of Europe. Medieval England and France were Christian states, while the regimes of Egypt and Syria were solidly Muslim, but there may have been more Christians all told in the Eastern states than the Western.... In the thirteenth century, the height of medieval Christian civilization in Europe, there may have been more Christian believers on the continent of Asia than in Europe, while Africa still had populous Christian communities... (p. 23).
On balance, I would argue that at the time of the Magna Carta or the Crusades, if we imagine a typical Christian, we should still be thinking not of a French artisan, but of a Syrian peasant or Mesopotamian towndweller, an Asian not a European (p. 24).
I have recently read Bat Ye’or’s The Decline of Eastern Christianity Under Islam: From Jihad to Dhimmitude (Cranbury, New Jersey: Associated University Presses, 1996), whose interpretation of history is similar to Jenkins’. She goes to great lengths to demonstrate that for nearly fourteen centuries the huge numbers of Christians and Jews in the Middle East and north Africa were subjected by their conquerors to systematic pressure to convert to the conquering religion. The first generations held out, but eventually such policies had their inevitable effect, leading to the long term decline of the first Christendom and its replacement by muslim majorities within the dar al-Islam, i.e., the territory under muslim rule.
In one of my classes this past year I had a student who is an Assyrian Christian born in Iraq. The numbers of such Christians are uncertain, but estimates range from 1 to 2.5 million in Iraq, with two to four times that many living in an Assyrian diaspora in Europe, North America and Australia. Their native language is Aramaic or Syriac, once the lingua franca of the old fertile crescent.
Middle Eastern Christians tend not to receive a very good press in the west, despite their status as the aboriginal inhabitants of the region. But I myself have come to have a great deal of admiration for them. After all, these are believers who have held firm against formidable odds for more than fifty generations, when most of their co-religionists did not. In the latter half of the twentieth century, by contrast, western churches emptied within a very few years, and for less significant reasons.
The Copts, the Maronites, the Assyrians, and others are the first Christendom. The west is the second Christendom. The next Christendom, if Jenkins is correct, will be centred in Africa, but also in Korea and China. Yet I wonder whether, in the providence of God, there might not be a significant future role to be played by the descendants of the original Syriac-speaking followers of Jesus Christ – if not in the Middle East, then perhaps in the diaspora.
15 May 2003
The ordinary of the mass
In the western church for well over a thousand years, the historic shape of the liturgy has encompassed a number of elements deemed essential to its proper celebration. Together these have formed what is known as the ordinary of the mass, including in outline form:
The Church of England's Book of Common Prayer retained much of this shape of the liturgy; however, under the influence of the continental reformers, it moved a reading of the Decalogue to the beginning of the liturgy and moved the Gloria in Excelsis to the end, where it became a post-communion thanksgiving hymn. The Lutheran churches retained this structure as well, although, with the elimination of a weekly observance of the Lord's Supper, only the ante-communion segment was retained on most sundays.
The Reformed and Presbyterian churches undertook a more radical reform, virtually eliminating the ordinary of the mass and substituting for it the basic structure that Old and Hart describe in their books. It has long seemed to me that, in so doing, the non-Lutheran reformers were doing more than just to reform; they came close to creating a new liturgy -- one that would inevitably seal the 16th century breach within western Christendom. Had they taken a more measured approach, namely, to remedy the defects while preserving what was right and good, they might have seen fit to keep much of what we know as the ordinary of the mass.
Imagine, if you will, an alternative history in which Reformed Christians have grown up singing and loving the Gloria in Excelsis, knowing the Sanctus by heart, praying with heartfelt passion the Agnus Dei, and seeing in these hymns a liturgical treasure shared with all other Christians in the western tradition. There would be one less cause of division among these traditions, even where genuine confessional differences remained, because we would all hold in common something very beautiful and ancient -- a way of worshipping God in spirit and truth.
In the western church for well over a thousand years, the historic shape of the liturgy has encompassed a number of elements deemed essential to its proper celebration. Together these have formed what is known as the ordinary of the mass, including in outline form:
The Confiteor
The Kyrie
The Gloria in Excelsis
The Scripture Lessons
The Sermon
The Credo
The Offertory
The Sursum Corda
The Eucharistic Prayer
The Sanctus
The Agnus Dei
The Post-Communion
The Church of England's Book of Common Prayer retained much of this shape of the liturgy; however, under the influence of the continental reformers, it moved a reading of the Decalogue to the beginning of the liturgy and moved the Gloria in Excelsis to the end, where it became a post-communion thanksgiving hymn. The Lutheran churches retained this structure as well, although, with the elimination of a weekly observance of the Lord's Supper, only the ante-communion segment was retained on most sundays.
The Reformed and Presbyterian churches undertook a more radical reform, virtually eliminating the ordinary of the mass and substituting for it the basic structure that Old and Hart describe in their books. It has long seemed to me that, in so doing, the non-Lutheran reformers were doing more than just to reform; they came close to creating a new liturgy -- one that would inevitably seal the 16th century breach within western Christendom. Had they taken a more measured approach, namely, to remedy the defects while preserving what was right and good, they might have seen fit to keep much of what we know as the ordinary of the mass.
Imagine, if you will, an alternative history in which Reformed Christians have grown up singing and loving the Gloria in Excelsis, knowing the Sanctus by heart, praying with heartfelt passion the Agnus Dei, and seeing in these hymns a liturgical treasure shared with all other Christians in the western tradition. There would be one less cause of division among these traditions, even where genuine confessional differences remained, because we would all hold in common something very beautiful and ancient -- a way of worshipping God in spirit and truth.
Labels:
Anglican,
Catholicism,
liturgy,
Lutheran,
Reformed
Old and Hart on the church year
Having recently read Darryl G. Hart's Recovering Mother Kirk (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2003), I pulled off my shelf Hughes Oliphant Old's excellent Worship that Is Reformed According to Scripture (Atlanta: John Knox Press, 1984), which I seem to have read a dozen or so years ago. Hart teaches at Westminster Seminary's California branch, while Old teaches at Princeton Seminary. Both sound similar themes in their books, expressing a concern for recovering the full integrity of Reformed worship, including something I've always favoured: a weekly celebration of the Lord's Supper.
Among other things, both are sceptical about the value of the church year, fearing that it will detract from sabbath observance. They also cast doubt on the use of particularly the visual arts in worship, on the grounds that this violates the second commandment. Writes Old:
While much of the current struggle over contemporary worship revolves around style, Old and Hart are correct to note that any effort to renew worship must focus on the substance of worship itself. The historic liturgies of the churches of the Reformation reflect an integrity that has often been lost in the battle over style. Worship, according to Old, must embrace the ministry of praise, the ministry of the word, the ministry of prayer, the sacraments, and alms-giving. Hart points to the Genevan order of worship, which includes the following essential components:
Given that I've occasionally worshipped in a church that had so many songs followed by a sermon with only a single brief prayer in the entire service, it is definitely in order to emphasize that liturgical integrity is not simply a matter of opinion. There are definite biblical patterns that must be followed.
However, I would not agree with them on the church year, which is entirely compatible with an emphasis on ordinary sunday worship. The traditional seasons of the church calendar -- Advent, Christmas, Epiphany, Lent, Easter and Pentecost -- rehearse the history of redemption over the course of a year. In that respect, they are not much different from catechism preaching, which is to take place during the afternoon service in the Reformed churches. Moreover, our Jewish forebears followed a similar liturgical calendar marked by significant feasts celebrating God's mighty acts of redemption. Celebration of Passover or Purim or Hannukah has never obscured the sabbath for observant Jews. It seems ironic that Reformed Christians, who are more aware than other believers of their Hebraic roots, would repudiate a pattern that finds clear precedent in the Old Covenant.
I am inclined to believe that there is something very nearly structural, even creational, in the human need to mark such occasions on an annual basis. Every religion has these. Yes, Christmas and Easter, for example, are subject to considerable deformations in the larger culture. But reforming means precisely that: to reform, not to abolish entirely.
Having recently read Darryl G. Hart's Recovering Mother Kirk (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2003), I pulled off my shelf Hughes Oliphant Old's excellent Worship that Is Reformed According to Scripture (Atlanta: John Knox Press, 1984), which I seem to have read a dozen or so years ago. Hart teaches at Westminster Seminary's California branch, while Old teaches at Princeton Seminary. Both sound similar themes in their books, expressing a concern for recovering the full integrity of Reformed worship, including something I've always favoured: a weekly celebration of the Lord's Supper.
Among other things, both are sceptical about the value of the church year, fearing that it will detract from sabbath observance. They also cast doubt on the use of particularly the visual arts in worship, on the grounds that this violates the second commandment. Writes Old:
If God has commanded us not to worship him by creating images of our own art and imagination it is because he wants us to be his image. Worship is the workshop where we are transformed into his image. When we are thus transformed into his image, we then reflect his glory. It is then through the ministry of praise and prayer, the ministry of word and sacrament that we are transformed to offer that spiritual worship which the Apostle Paul tells us is acceptable to God (Rom. 12:1-2).
While much of the current struggle over contemporary worship revolves around style, Old and Hart are correct to note that any effort to renew worship must focus on the substance of worship itself. The historic liturgies of the churches of the Reformation reflect an integrity that has often been lost in the battle over style. Worship, according to Old, must embrace the ministry of praise, the ministry of the word, the ministry of prayer, the sacraments, and alms-giving. Hart points to the Genevan order of worship, which includes the following essential components:
Invocation
Confession of sins
Prayer for pardon
Singing of a psalm
Prayer for illumination
Scripture lesson(s)
Sermon
Collection of offerings
Prayers of intercession
Apostles' Creed
Words of institution of the Lord's Supper
Instruction and exhortation
Reception of the elements
Prayer of thanksgiving (e.g., Psalm 103 or 113)
Benediction
Given that I've occasionally worshipped in a church that had so many songs followed by a sermon with only a single brief prayer in the entire service, it is definitely in order to emphasize that liturgical integrity is not simply a matter of opinion. There are definite biblical patterns that must be followed.
However, I would not agree with them on the church year, which is entirely compatible with an emphasis on ordinary sunday worship. The traditional seasons of the church calendar -- Advent, Christmas, Epiphany, Lent, Easter and Pentecost -- rehearse the history of redemption over the course of a year. In that respect, they are not much different from catechism preaching, which is to take place during the afternoon service in the Reformed churches. Moreover, our Jewish forebears followed a similar liturgical calendar marked by significant feasts celebrating God's mighty acts of redemption. Celebration of Passover or Purim or Hannukah has never obscured the sabbath for observant Jews. It seems ironic that Reformed Christians, who are more aware than other believers of their Hebraic roots, would repudiate a pattern that finds clear precedent in the Old Covenant.
I am inclined to believe that there is something very nearly structural, even creational, in the human need to mark such occasions on an annual basis. Every religion has these. Yes, Christmas and Easter, for example, are subject to considerable deformations in the larger culture. But reforming means precisely that: to reform, not to abolish entirely.
Another poignant return in Cyprus
This is another of those stories that brings tears to my eyes as I read it: "Greek family has bittersweet return to Cyprus home now inhabited by Turks." I am still finding it amazing that there has been so little rancour and so much good will in these encounters. This confirms what my father had told me for so many decades about the normal relationships between the two communities in his youth. One cannot help thinking that all this has to have some political effect. If the leaders of the two sides do not come together soon, the popular momentum will have passed them by.
I have a recurring dream in which my wife and I have bought the little three-bedroom house in Wheaton, Illinois, where I lived and grew up between 1958 and 1968. The inside seems larger than it actually was, and the basement is a huge cavernous expanse beneath the house with room after room, sometimes still containing the toys I played with as a child.
In recent years, during visits to my hometown, we've driven by the house, and I've been sorely tempted to knock on the door and ask to go in. Whether we would be greeted as courteously as Turkish Cypriots have greeted inquiring Greek Cypriots I don't know. My guess is that no one would be home, as virtually everyone now works during the day.
But at least I am able to get near this house, to go to the old neighbourhood, to see the elementary school I attended, to see the creek running behind the house, and the old vacant lot in back which is now occupied by two newer houses.
Yet I find myself wondering whether the 800 kilometres that separates me from my hometown is not, after all, that much different from a barbed-wire fence. The effect is the same: I am here, the old neighbourhood is there. Is modern North American mobility itself tantamount to a kind of repeated exile, where people are forced to uproot themselves every few years for the sake of the market, thus abandoning homes, family and friends?
Cyprus is a small island. North America is a huge expanse of territory. In some respects I wish we lived in a smaller country.
This is another of those stories that brings tears to my eyes as I read it: "Greek family has bittersweet return to Cyprus home now inhabited by Turks." I am still finding it amazing that there has been so little rancour and so much good will in these encounters. This confirms what my father had told me for so many decades about the normal relationships between the two communities in his youth. One cannot help thinking that all this has to have some political effect. If the leaders of the two sides do not come together soon, the popular momentum will have passed them by.
I have a recurring dream in which my wife and I have bought the little three-bedroom house in Wheaton, Illinois, where I lived and grew up between 1958 and 1968. The inside seems larger than it actually was, and the basement is a huge cavernous expanse beneath the house with room after room, sometimes still containing the toys I played with as a child.
In recent years, during visits to my hometown, we've driven by the house, and I've been sorely tempted to knock on the door and ask to go in. Whether we would be greeted as courteously as Turkish Cypriots have greeted inquiring Greek Cypriots I don't know. My guess is that no one would be home, as virtually everyone now works during the day.
But at least I am able to get near this house, to go to the old neighbourhood, to see the elementary school I attended, to see the creek running behind the house, and the old vacant lot in back which is now occupied by two newer houses.
Yet I find myself wondering whether the 800 kilometres that separates me from my hometown is not, after all, that much different from a barbed-wire fence. The effect is the same: I am here, the old neighbourhood is there. Is modern North American mobility itself tantamount to a kind of repeated exile, where people are forced to uproot themselves every few years for the sake of the market, thus abandoning homes, family and friends?
Cyprus is a small island. North America is a huge expanse of territory. In some respects I wish we lived in a smaller country.
14 May 2003
Leo Strauss' influence
Eddie Thomas writes:
Some of my own professors at Notre Dame were what one might call "soft Straussians," and I believe they actually studied under Leo Strauss at the University of Chicago in the 1950s and early '60s. I suppose the principal way in which I've been influenced by Strauss is in having my students read primary texts in my history of political theory courses. There's no substitute for grappling with what Plato or Aristotle or Hobbes or Rousseau actually wrote. There is also much to appreciate in Strauss' trenchant criticism of positivistic approaches to the study of politics, anchored as they are in the peculiarly modern fact/value dichotomy. In my Recent Political Theory class my students read his essay, "What Is Political Philosophy?"
However, I've never found terribly convincing some of the esoteric readings attached to these primary texts. For example, in his interpretive essay on Plato's Republic, Allan Bloom argues that Socrates' advocacy of the communal ownership of property and the community of wives and children is meant tongue-in-cheek, almost as humour. One of my Notre Dame professors concurred in this interpretation.
However, if this were indeed so, why would Aristotle expend so much energy in book II of the Politics arguing against this proposal? Given that he was a student of Plato, I should think he would have been in a pretty good position to know whether or not his mentor's proposal was or was not meant in jest.
Perhaps I've missed something in the corpus of the writings of Strauss and his disciples where this difficulty is dealt with. If so, I'd love for someone to bring it to my attention.
Eddie Thomas writes:
Of the charges against the Straussians, the most common perhaps is their belief that many of the classical texts of the Western tradition have two readings: the surface (exoteric) reading and the hidden (esoteric) reading.
Some of my own professors at Notre Dame were what one might call "soft Straussians," and I believe they actually studied under Leo Strauss at the University of Chicago in the 1950s and early '60s. I suppose the principal way in which I've been influenced by Strauss is in having my students read primary texts in my history of political theory courses. There's no substitute for grappling with what Plato or Aristotle or Hobbes or Rousseau actually wrote. There is also much to appreciate in Strauss' trenchant criticism of positivistic approaches to the study of politics, anchored as they are in the peculiarly modern fact/value dichotomy. In my Recent Political Theory class my students read his essay, "What Is Political Philosophy?"
However, I've never found terribly convincing some of the esoteric readings attached to these primary texts. For example, in his interpretive essay on Plato's Republic, Allan Bloom argues that Socrates' advocacy of the communal ownership of property and the community of wives and children is meant tongue-in-cheek, almost as humour. One of my Notre Dame professors concurred in this interpretation.
However, if this were indeed so, why would Aristotle expend so much energy in book II of the Politics arguing against this proposal? Given that he was a student of Plato, I should think he would have been in a pretty good position to know whether or not his mentor's proposal was or was not meant in jest.
Perhaps I've missed something in the corpus of the writings of Strauss and his disciples where this difficulty is dealt with. If so, I'd love for someone to bring it to my attention.
The Genevan Psalter
Christians have been singing the Psalms for two millennia, following the example of their Jewish forebears. There have been many ways to sing the Psalms, including byzantine, ambrosian and gregorian chant. In the 16th century the Reformers composed metrical psalms which could be sung more easily by entire congregations. Thus the liturgy was put back in the hands (or lips) of the people, who could now join their voices in songs of praise, thanksgiving, lamentation and imprecation. One of the most enduring of the 16th century psalters is the Genevan Psalter, which was compiled over a period of decades and finally completed in 1562.

I myself became fascinated by this Psalter in the mid-1980s, undertaking to versify as many as possible of the biblical Psalms so they could be sung to the Genevan tunes. Psalm-singing went into eclipse in most protestant churches during the 18th century, but it is making a comeback at the beginning of a new century.
Christians have been singing the Psalms for two millennia, following the example of their Jewish forebears. There have been many ways to sing the Psalms, including byzantine, ambrosian and gregorian chant. In the 16th century the Reformers composed metrical psalms which could be sung more easily by entire congregations. Thus the liturgy was put back in the hands (or lips) of the people, who could now join their voices in songs of praise, thanksgiving, lamentation and imprecation. One of the most enduring of the 16th century psalters is the Genevan Psalter, which was compiled over a period of decades and finally completed in 1562.

I myself became fascinated by this Psalter in the mid-1980s, undertaking to versify as many as possible of the biblical Psalms so they could be sung to the Genevan tunes. Psalm-singing went into eclipse in most protestant churches during the 18th century, but it is making a comeback at the beginning of a new century.
Our anniversary
Seven years ago today Nancy and I were married. It was a simple church ceremony on a tuesday evening at the First Presbyterian Church in Glen Ellyn, Illinois, with only immediate family present, including my sister, Dawn, who had introduced us four years earlier. When I think of what Nancy has meant to me these years, I should be able to manage a few eloquent phrases, but only clichés come to mind: "love of my life," "one in a million," "my heart's desire." Trouble is, all the clichés are accurate.
Congratulations may be sent here.
Seven years ago today Nancy and I were married. It was a simple church ceremony on a tuesday evening at the First Presbyterian Church in Glen Ellyn, Illinois, with only immediate family present, including my sister, Dawn, who had introduced us four years earlier. When I think of what Nancy has meant to me these years, I should be able to manage a few eloquent phrases, but only clichés come to mind: "love of my life," "one in a million," "my heart's desire." Trouble is, all the clichés are accurate.
Congratulations may be sent here.
13 May 2003
My wife and I often watch ABC World News Tonight at 6.30 pm, particularly since the beginning of the war in Iraq. We've noticed that this programme has an uncommon number of advertisements for medicinal aids of various sorts -- but none for curing acne! This suggest that the age demographic for the television news audience is, shall we say, on the higher end of the scale. I am not sure what this says about the interest of young people in world events. I guess that's part of my job -- to get them interested in what's going on "out there."
Other minorities in Cyprus
In addition to the majority Greek and minority Turkish population in the island, Cyprus is also home to three other, quite small ethnic minorities, the Armenians, the Maronites and the Latins. The word "ethnicity" is, of course, pretty slippery. In fact, all five communities in Cyprus are distinguished by religion, though this is commonly forgotten. The majority Greek community is made up of members of the Orthodox Church of Cyprus. The Turkish community is Sunni Muslim. The Armenians are monophysite Christians, whose ancestors dissented from the Council of Chalcedon in 451. They are members of the Armenian Apostolic Church. The Maronites have their origins in the Levant and are in communion with Rome.
As for the Latins, this is a catch-all term to cover virtually anyone of Roman Catholic faith, going back to the Frankish Lusignan and Venetian rule and extending up to contemporary Filipino domestics. I am particularly interested in this group, since there is a possibility that our own family has roots there. The surname Koyzis may once have been something like Coisy, Coizy or Coizie, and the origins may have been in France.
According to Dr Nicholas Coureas of the Cyprus Research Centre,
This could have something to do with how my own ancestors came to Cyprus and why they stayed on. But, given that I've seen no records to this effect, this is pure speculation.
In addition to the majority Greek and minority Turkish population in the island, Cyprus is also home to three other, quite small ethnic minorities, the Armenians, the Maronites and the Latins. The word "ethnicity" is, of course, pretty slippery. In fact, all five communities in Cyprus are distinguished by religion, though this is commonly forgotten. The majority Greek community is made up of members of the Orthodox Church of Cyprus. The Turkish community is Sunni Muslim. The Armenians are monophysite Christians, whose ancestors dissented from the Council of Chalcedon in 451. They are members of the Armenian Apostolic Church. The Maronites have their origins in the Levant and are in communion with Rome.
As for the Latins, this is a catch-all term to cover virtually anyone of Roman Catholic faith, going back to the Frankish Lusignan and Venetian rule and extending up to contemporary Filipino domestics. I am particularly interested in this group, since there is a possibility that our own family has roots there. The surname Koyzis may once have been something like Coisy, Coizy or Coizie, and the origins may have been in France.
According to Dr Nicholas Coureas of the Cyprus Research Centre,
According to the testimony of Malcolm Laing Meason, a fair number of Frenchmen and Italians settling in Cyprus took Cypriot wives and busied themselves with commerce or various other professions. He describes them as well-off and with money in the bank, but not wealthy, adding that they were extremely careful with their money. He makes particular mention of a Frenchman and his compatriots, who having served at the French consulate decided to remain in Cyprus on account of the lower cost of living on the island.
This could have something to do with how my own ancestors came to Cyprus and why they stayed on. But, given that I've seen no records to this effect, this is pure speculation.
The eastern cross
I notice that the Rev. Fred Herwaldt, of First Reformed Church, Lincoln Park, New Jersey, uses the sign of the cross according to the usage in the eastern churches, that is, from the right shoulder to the left. Perhaps he too is a Byzantine-rite Calvinist.
I notice that the Rev. Fred Herwaldt, of First Reformed Church, Lincoln Park, New Jersey, uses the sign of the cross according to the usage in the eastern churches, that is, from the right shoulder to the left. Perhaps he too is a Byzantine-rite Calvinist.
Another classic book from 1951
H. Richard Niebuhr’s Christ and Culture (New York: Harper and Row) is one that I’ve read several times since first encountering it as an undergraduate. The author is rather less famous than his brother Reinhold, probably the premier American protestant theologian and public philosopher of the middle 20th century. Tellingly, the Niebuhr family was nurtured spiritually in the German Evangelical Synod, which has its origins in the Prussian union church of 1817, when the Prussian king forcibly united his Reformed (Calvinist) and Evangelical (i.e., Lutheran) subjects into a single communion. Not surprisingly, perhaps, Reinhold’s writings tend to read in a Lutheran way, while Richard seems to draw more on the Calvinist side of his family’s heritage.
Richard’s five categories have become familiar – indeed almost cliché – by now. Yet even those disagreeing with his approach tend to use them: (1) Christ against culture; (2) Christ of culture; (3) Christ above culture; (4) Christ and culture in paradox; and (5) Christ transforming culture.
Virtually everyone wants to be in this last transformationist camp. Yet in recent years I’ve become aware of the fact that a desire to transform the culture is hardly sufficient, unless one is clear what the basis is for such transformative activity. Transformation can easily describe the imposition of a foreign, extraneous design onto human culture and society. Since transformationists are many and various, each has his own vision of where culture ought to be moving and what it ought to look like when it gets there. Not only are these visions obviously incompatible; many are also impracticable and utopian. The liberation theologian and the follower of the Christian Coalition both seek to transform culture, but each is dragging the world in a different direction.
This has prompted me to wonder whether it might not be better to speak of Christ restoring culture. Such restorative activity would be undertaken on the understanding that there are norms for everything in God’s world and that we must follow these. If we seek to transform culture without a sufficient grounding in God’s word and world, then we are likely to fall prey to the same sorts of distortions as the followers of the ideologies.
In the absence of a comment system yet, I can be reached here.
H. Richard Niebuhr’s Christ and Culture (New York: Harper and Row) is one that I’ve read several times since first encountering it as an undergraduate. The author is rather less famous than his brother Reinhold, probably the premier American protestant theologian and public philosopher of the middle 20th century. Tellingly, the Niebuhr family was nurtured spiritually in the German Evangelical Synod, which has its origins in the Prussian union church of 1817, when the Prussian king forcibly united his Reformed (Calvinist) and Evangelical (i.e., Lutheran) subjects into a single communion. Not surprisingly, perhaps, Reinhold’s writings tend to read in a Lutheran way, while Richard seems to draw more on the Calvinist side of his family’s heritage.
Richard’s five categories have become familiar – indeed almost cliché – by now. Yet even those disagreeing with his approach tend to use them: (1) Christ against culture; (2) Christ of culture; (3) Christ above culture; (4) Christ and culture in paradox; and (5) Christ transforming culture.
Virtually everyone wants to be in this last transformationist camp. Yet in recent years I’ve become aware of the fact that a desire to transform the culture is hardly sufficient, unless one is clear what the basis is for such transformative activity. Transformation can easily describe the imposition of a foreign, extraneous design onto human culture and society. Since transformationists are many and various, each has his own vision of where culture ought to be moving and what it ought to look like when it gets there. Not only are these visions obviously incompatible; many are also impracticable and utopian. The liberation theologian and the follower of the Christian Coalition both seek to transform culture, but each is dragging the world in a different direction.
This has prompted me to wonder whether it might not be better to speak of Christ restoring culture. Such restorative activity would be undertaken on the understanding that there are norms for everything in God’s world and that we must follow these. If we seek to transform culture without a sufficient grounding in God’s word and world, then we are likely to fall prey to the same sorts of distortions as the followers of the ideologies.
In the absence of a comment system yet, I can be reached here.
12 May 2003
Every Orthodox church building carries an icon of Christ the Pantocrator, that is, the Lord of All or Almighty, in the top of the dome. My favourite icon of Christ has to be the following:

This particular icon is found in the mother church of Orthodox Christianity, Aghia Sophia, the Church of the Holy Wisdom, in Constantinople. Unlike many such icons, which have a deliberately flat quality about them, this one has not only visual but emotional depth. There is a look of compassion in the eyes that vividly communicates the character of Christ. Some icons of the Pantocrator have him distant or even severe. But not this one.
This Pantocrator was not in the dome of Aghia Sophia; it was part of the great deisis in the south gallery, portraying Mary (the Theotokos, or Mother of God) and John the Baptist (or Forerunner) at either side interceding or praying to him. Most scholars believe that it was a late addition to the church, being added shortly after the Byzantine Greeks (who called themselves simply “Romans”) had reconquered the City from the crusading Latins in 1261. If so, then it remained visible for less than two centuries, because the Ottoman Turks conquered the City in 1453 and covered up the christian mosaics in the church, which was converted into a mosque. This particular icon thus spent the next five centuries covered up until around half a century ago by which time Aghia Sophia had become a museum.
When I was 22 years of age, I painted an oil copy of this icon which hangs on the wall of my campus office. Although it’s artistically passable, I am quite certain I failed to capture the haunting beauty of the original. It would be difficult for anyone to do, I should think.

This particular icon is found in the mother church of Orthodox Christianity, Aghia Sophia, the Church of the Holy Wisdom, in Constantinople. Unlike many such icons, which have a deliberately flat quality about them, this one has not only visual but emotional depth. There is a look of compassion in the eyes that vividly communicates the character of Christ. Some icons of the Pantocrator have him distant or even severe. But not this one.
This Pantocrator was not in the dome of Aghia Sophia; it was part of the great deisis in the south gallery, portraying Mary (the Theotokos, or Mother of God) and John the Baptist (or Forerunner) at either side interceding or praying to him. Most scholars believe that it was a late addition to the church, being added shortly after the Byzantine Greeks (who called themselves simply “Romans”) had reconquered the City from the crusading Latins in 1261. If so, then it remained visible for less than two centuries, because the Ottoman Turks conquered the City in 1453 and covered up the christian mosaics in the church, which was converted into a mosque. This particular icon thus spent the next five centuries covered up until around half a century ago by which time Aghia Sophia had become a museum.
When I was 22 years of age, I painted an oil copy of this icon which hangs on the wall of my campus office. Although it’s artistically passable, I am quite certain I failed to capture the haunting beauty of the original. It would be difficult for anyone to do, I should think.
Homage à Brubeck
Last year I composed a piece inspired by Brubeck’s work which I have called (tongue in cheek) “Rondo rouge a la Grec” (© David T. Koyzis 2002). It’s not exactly jazz, but it does share the same time signature with “Blue Rondo a la Turk.”
Last year I composed a piece inspired by Brubeck’s work which I have called (tongue in cheek) “Rondo rouge a la Grec” (© David T. Koyzis 2002). It’s not exactly jazz, but it does share the same time signature with “Blue Rondo a la Turk.”
11 May 2003
Our own Berlin Wall in Hamilton?
On friday I wrote:
When I first moved to Hamilton in 1987 from exceedingly flat South Bend, Indiana, I tried to acclimate myself to my new surroundings by familiarizing myself with a map of the city. But something was puzzling me. All of the north-south streets seemed to come to an end at a meandering line running in a generally east-west direction. Why, I asked myself, did they not simply put these streets through so people could more easily travel from one part of the city to the next? Was there something like a Berlin Wall in Hamilton?
It didn't take me that long to figure out that this "meandering line" on the map was the Niagara Escarpment, a lengthy cliff-like geological phenemenon that runs from Niagara Falls all the way to the Bruce Peninsula on Lake Huron. It makes for an almost spectacular visual beauty in this part of the province--at least as compared to South Bend, Indiana.
On friday I wrote:
It's difficult to imagine what it might be like to have one's own city bisected in such a way. I live in Hamilton, Ontario. Imagine a wall topped with barbed wire extending down the middle of, say, James Street, with the city's population forced to remain within their respective zones.
When I first moved to Hamilton in 1987 from exceedingly flat South Bend, Indiana, I tried to acclimate myself to my new surroundings by familiarizing myself with a map of the city. But something was puzzling me. All of the north-south streets seemed to come to an end at a meandering line running in a generally east-west direction. Why, I asked myself, did they not simply put these streets through so people could more easily travel from one part of the city to the next? Was there something like a Berlin Wall in Hamilton?
It didn't take me that long to figure out that this "meandering line" on the map was the Niagara Escarpment, a lengthy cliff-like geological phenemenon that runs from Niagara Falls all the way to the Bruce Peninsula on Lake Huron. It makes for an almost spectacular visual beauty in this part of the province--at least as compared to South Bend, Indiana.
Growing up too quickly?
Within the past week or so Theresa has suddenly started calling us "Mom" and "Dad" rather than "Mommy" and "Daddy." We're not sure why, except that she's been playing a lot with her LeapFrog Phonics and Writing Desk, which can handle only three-letter words.
Within the past week or so Theresa has suddenly started calling us "Mom" and "Dad" rather than "Mommy" and "Daddy." We're not sure why, except that she's been playing a lot with her LeapFrog Phonics and Writing Desk, which can handle only three-letter words.
The sign of the cross
Is there something to be said for recovering the ancient sign of the cross in the Reformed churches? The pastor of the First Reformed Church of Lincoln Park, New Jersey, thinks so.
Is there something to be said for recovering the ancient sign of the cross in the Reformed churches? The pastor of the First Reformed Church of Lincoln Park, New Jersey, thinks so.
10 May 2003
Dave Brubeck's odd time signatures
I cannot exactly call myself an expert in jazz music, and I must admit that my first love is what is somewhat misleadingly called classical music. (I say misleadingly, because my favourite periods are Renaissance and, skipping over the classical era, early twentieth century.) But I’ve always had something of a penchant for the Dave Brubeck Quartet, whose heyday was in the 1950s and ’60s. In some respects Brubeck (b. 1920) can be said to bridge the gap between jazz and classical music.
What I like about him is his use of unconventional – or perhaps I should say nonwestern – time signatures, such as 5/4 and 9/8. These metres are quite familiar in Greek, Balkan and Turkish music, and they do not sound in the least unusual to my ears. But they would to most people in Brubeck’s North American audience of jazz aficionados. The most successful of these are his “Take Five,” written in 5/4 time, and “Blue Rondo a la Turk,” written in 9/8. These pieces were part of his album, “Time Out,” which was released in 1959. The first jazz instrumental to sell more than a million copies, “Take Five” was composed by his saxophonist, Paul Desmond, whose distinctive solo performance makes for a brilliant counterpoise to the otherwise asymmetrical rhythm.
Some years ago I was singing in an Episcopal church choir in the States during the Advent season, and I was delighted that the choirmaster had us sing Dave and Iola Brubeck’s “God’s Love Made Visible,” also in 5/4 time.
I cannot exactly call myself an expert in jazz music, and I must admit that my first love is what is somewhat misleadingly called classical music. (I say misleadingly, because my favourite periods are Renaissance and, skipping over the classical era, early twentieth century.) But I’ve always had something of a penchant for the Dave Brubeck Quartet, whose heyday was in the 1950s and ’60s. In some respects Brubeck (b. 1920) can be said to bridge the gap between jazz and classical music.
What I like about him is his use of unconventional – or perhaps I should say nonwestern – time signatures, such as 5/4 and 9/8. These metres are quite familiar in Greek, Balkan and Turkish music, and they do not sound in the least unusual to my ears. But they would to most people in Brubeck’s North American audience of jazz aficionados. The most successful of these are his “Take Five,” written in 5/4 time, and “Blue Rondo a la Turk,” written in 9/8. These pieces were part of his album, “Time Out,” which was released in 1959. The first jazz instrumental to sell more than a million copies, “Take Five” was composed by his saxophonist, Paul Desmond, whose distinctive solo performance makes for a brilliant counterpoise to the otherwise asymmetrical rhythm.
Some years ago I was singing in an Episcopal church choir in the States during the Advent season, and I was delighted that the choirmaster had us sing Dave and Iola Brubeck’s “God’s Love Made Visible,” also in 5/4 time.
Political message in a classic film
This evening my wife and I watched Robert Wise's science fiction classic, "The Day the Earth Stood Still" (1951) on TVO. By today's standards, of course, it's all pretty low tech. But it's considered a classic because of its antinuclear message coming during the early and most frightening years of the Cold War. And the dated special effects are more than made up for by the wonderfully ethereal score composed by the incomparable Bernard Herrmann.
I've seen this film more than once before, but what stood out for me this time were the political subtexts. Without giving too much away, I can say two things:
(1) Klaatu, the extraterrestrial visitor, brings a message from an interplanetary confederation that sounds uncannily like the Bush Doctrine, including the right of pre-emption to eliminate even the whisper of a threat.
(2) The interplanetary confederation sounds uncomfortably like the Hobbesian commonwealth, with a cosmic leviathan ready to lower the boom if anyone gets out of line. This effectively ends the interstellar state of nature and frees everyone from the threat of war.
Perhaps I should propose to teach a course on the political message of films.
This evening my wife and I watched Robert Wise's science fiction classic, "The Day the Earth Stood Still" (1951) on TVO. By today's standards, of course, it's all pretty low tech. But it's considered a classic because of its antinuclear message coming during the early and most frightening years of the Cold War. And the dated special effects are more than made up for by the wonderfully ethereal score composed by the incomparable Bernard Herrmann.
I've seen this film more than once before, but what stood out for me this time were the political subtexts. Without giving too much away, I can say two things:
(1) Klaatu, the extraterrestrial visitor, brings a message from an interplanetary confederation that sounds uncannily like the Bush Doctrine, including the right of pre-emption to eliminate even the whisper of a threat.
(2) The interplanetary confederation sounds uncomfortably like the Hobbesian commonwealth, with a cosmic leviathan ready to lower the boom if anyone gets out of line. This effectively ends the interstellar state of nature and frees everyone from the threat of war.
Perhaps I should propose to teach a course on the political message of films.
Differentiation and historical development
The Dutch philosopher Herman Dooyeweerd is one of the few Christians to take seriously the structural, creational component of historical development. There seems to be a pronounced tendency amongst many believers to assume that the movement of history in itself constitutes a kind of falling away from a perfectly good social order of a static sort. Accordingly some conservative believers tend to idealize or romanticize a particular moment in history when society was less complex than it is now.
According to Dooyeweerd, however, there are norms for historical development. History is not just a haphazard process. One of these norms in differentiation, which means that, as human beings discover what God would have them do in his creation, there is a tendency for these activities to spread themselves out into distinct communities, such as schools, labour unions, business enterprises, artistic co-operatives, &c.
However, some confuse this normative process of differentiation with an antinormative fragmentation. Darryl G. Hart appears to be one of these, as indicated in his recent Recovering Mother Kirk (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2003). Here are some representative passages, written within the context of the changing place of women in society:
As for the institutional church:
There's more:
There is much to like in what Hart is doing in his book. He even in places comes close to acknowledging what Abraham Kuyper calls sphere sovereignty. But he seems to dislike the process of differentiation that is its foundation. A reading of Dooyeweerd would help him to distinguish better between legitimate societal differentiation and the social fragmentation that he rightly decries.
The Dutch philosopher Herman Dooyeweerd is one of the few Christians to take seriously the structural, creational component of historical development. There seems to be a pronounced tendency amongst many believers to assume that the movement of history in itself constitutes a kind of falling away from a perfectly good social order of a static sort. Accordingly some conservative believers tend to idealize or romanticize a particular moment in history when society was less complex than it is now.
According to Dooyeweerd, however, there are norms for historical development. History is not just a haphazard process. One of these norms in differentiation, which means that, as human beings discover what God would have them do in his creation, there is a tendency for these activities to spread themselves out into distinct communities, such as schools, labour unions, business enterprises, artistic co-operatives, &c.
However, some confuse this normative process of differentiation with an antinormative fragmentation. Darryl G. Hart appears to be one of these, as indicated in his recent Recovering Mother Kirk (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2003). Here are some representative passages, written within the context of the changing place of women in society:
The modern political economy weakens the family by giving to large impersonal institutions such as schools, hospitals, businesses, and governments the tasks formerly performed by the family.
As for the institutional church:
The church was closely tied and responsive to the Christian families and communities in which it existed. The heads of the church functioned in a way similar to fathers in a family. They governed their people, taught them and watched over them, and when they were in need responded to that need. The church, in other words, was more like a people or a family than an impersonal institution.
There's more:
[P]remodern society supported the idea that God deals with his people primarily in groups or communities, not as individuals. The church, accordingly, constitutes a people or a community, not a collection of autonomous selves.... Individuals in community do not choose who they are; rather, their identities arise from being born into and being members of the community (pp. 130-131).
There is much to like in what Hart is doing in his book. He even in places comes close to acknowledging what Abraham Kuyper calls sphere sovereignty. But he seems to dislike the process of differentiation that is its foundation. A reading of Dooyeweerd would help him to distinguish better between legitimate societal differentiation and the social fragmentation that he rightly decries.
09 May 2003
Another Berlin Wall is opened
It's been nearly fourteen years since the opening of Berlin Wall, an event that led with astonishing rapidity to the end of communism in most places where it had once seemed secure and impregnable. It's difficult to imagine what it might be like to have one's own city bisected in such a way. I live in Hamilton, Ontario. Imagine a wall topped with barbed wire extending down the middle of, say, James Street, with the city's population forced to remain within their respective zones.
Here is an article from The International Herald Tribune about two families in Nicosia, Cyprus, living on the same street but on different sides of the Green Line: "Cypriots finally see what lay behind wall." And here is what the Green Line looked like eight years ago in another bisected street, Ledra Street, in Nicosia:

It's been nearly fourteen years since the opening of Berlin Wall, an event that led with astonishing rapidity to the end of communism in most places where it had once seemed secure and impregnable. It's difficult to imagine what it might be like to have one's own city bisected in such a way. I live in Hamilton, Ontario. Imagine a wall topped with barbed wire extending down the middle of, say, James Street, with the city's population forced to remain within their respective zones.
Here is an article from The International Herald Tribune about two families in Nicosia, Cyprus, living on the same street but on different sides of the Green Line: "Cypriots finally see what lay behind wall." And here is what the Green Line looked like eight years ago in another bisected street, Ledra Street, in Nicosia:

More from Cyprus
The Turkish Prime Minister is scheduled to visit Cyprus tomorrow, and his country's attitude towards the longstanding stalemate in the island will be crucial to any solution. Here is an opinion piece by Martin Woollacott in today's The Guardian: "Free movement may still heal the division of Cyprus." Woollacott describes some of the cordial, if somewhat wary, encounters between Greek and Turkish Cypriots separated from each other for more than a generation:
But it seems that one of the obstacles to a genuine settlement is the turbulence in current politics in Turkey itself, the secular character of whose government is guaranteed by the military. Prime Minister Erdogan's AKP, or Justice and Development Party, is more islamic in orientation. To be sure, it is a democratically elected government, but in a country where the military is the guardian of the constitution, there are continuing tensions between the armed forces and the civilian authorities. This is complicating matters with respect to a number of issues, of which Cyprus is only one.
In Cyprus itself meanwhile, the peaceful popular uprising continues, fuelled by dreams of return to the places of the past, where distance is measured not so much in miles as in memories--memories of nearly three decades separating people from their villages, which lie just on the other side of a barbed wire fence. Woollacott puts it in this way:
The Turkish Prime Minister is scheduled to visit Cyprus tomorrow, and his country's attitude towards the longstanding stalemate in the island will be crucial to any solution. Here is an opinion piece by Martin Woollacott in today's The Guardian: "Free movement may still heal the division of Cyprus." Woollacott describes some of the cordial, if somewhat wary, encounters between Greek and Turkish Cypriots separated from each other for more than a generation:
A touching politeness has marked some of these encounters. Greek Cypriots call out greetings to Turks as they drive through southern villages. A Turkish Cypriot dentist leaves a message on the front door that if any members of the Greek family who had once lived in the house should visit during working hours they are to come to his surgery to get the key. There are people on the Greek side who cannot bring themselves to show their passports to a Turkish Cypriot official or sign a register because, as one said: "I should be free to go anywhere in my own island."
But it seems that one of the obstacles to a genuine settlement is the turbulence in current politics in Turkey itself, the secular character of whose government is guaranteed by the military. Prime Minister Erdogan's AKP, or Justice and Development Party, is more islamic in orientation. To be sure, it is a democratically elected government, but in a country where the military is the guardian of the constitution, there are continuing tensions between the armed forces and the civilian authorities. This is complicating matters with respect to a number of issues, of which Cyprus is only one.
In Cyprus itself meanwhile, the peaceful popular uprising continues, fuelled by dreams of return to the places of the past, where distance is measured not so much in miles as in memories--memories of nearly three decades separating people from their villages, which lie just on the other side of a barbed wire fence. Woollacott puts it in this way:
Yet there are people in Cyprus who have dreamed almost every night for years of the village or neighbourhood they left long ago. They remember, as the anthropologist Peter Loizos has recorded, loading their furniture on carts at night "as if we were thieving from out of our own houses", or, in other cases, leaving "as if we were going out for a stroll". Now, in the shape of visits to the loved places, at last some balm has been spread on the wounds .... That must surely work through in time, even if the phenomenon of popular reconciliation visible today in Cyprus does not have an immediate or dramatic effect on the prospects for a settlement.
Gideon again:
I believe there is a relationship, but only in the sense that one must have Christianity in the first place for dechristianization to occur at all. What happened in the Netherlands was by no means restricted to the Gerformeerde Kerken, but has also affected the Nederlandse Hervormde Kerk and, perhaps even more dramatically, the Roman Catholic Church. In other words, the empty pew has been a more general phenomenon and has not been limited to a particular ecclesial communion. More significantly, it has not even been limited to the Netherlands.
Kuyper and other European Christians did their best to maintain the integrity of the faith and the community of faith against immense odds. But the church is by no means immune to trends in the larger culture, sad to say. How the smaller churches in the Netherlands, such as the Vrijgemaakt and the Christelijke Gereformeerde Kerken, fared I do not know. Again my colleague Harry Van Dyke would know this better than I.
One of the reasons I wrote my book is to alert Christians to the dangers of accepting too easily the various ideological visions that have plagued our society in recent centuries. This has implications for the health of church institutions, along with other communities.
This is important stuff, because as North Americans begin to pay more attention to Abraham Kuyper, the question will inevitably arise if there is a relationship between neocalvinism and the apparent dechristianization of the Netherlands today.
I believe there is a relationship, but only in the sense that one must have Christianity in the first place for dechristianization to occur at all. What happened in the Netherlands was by no means restricted to the Gerformeerde Kerken, but has also affected the Nederlandse Hervormde Kerk and, perhaps even more dramatically, the Roman Catholic Church. In other words, the empty pew has been a more general phenomenon and has not been limited to a particular ecclesial communion. More significantly, it has not even been limited to the Netherlands.
Kuyper and other European Christians did their best to maintain the integrity of the faith and the community of faith against immense odds. But the church is by no means immune to trends in the larger culture, sad to say. How the smaller churches in the Netherlands, such as the Vrijgemaakt and the Christelijke Gereformeerde Kerken, fared I do not know. Again my colleague Harry Van Dyke would know this better than I.
One of the reasons I wrote my book is to alert Christians to the dangers of accepting too easily the various ideological visions that have plagued our society in recent centuries. This has implications for the health of church institutions, along with other communities.
08 May 2003
Gideon Strauss writes:
Of the three of us, I am quite certain that John knows the most, since he's written on the topic of the impact of the Dutch confessional system on broadcasting, which would bring him into this era. But my colleague Harry Van Dyke probably knows more than anyone else, since he lived through the collapse of this "regime" in the mid-1960s.
I will do no more than to venture an educated guess as to what happened in the Netherlands. I suppose I would say that, if a particular confessional community loses the will to maintain itself, no amount of consociational politics will serve to preserve it.
Lijphart and other scholars note that consociationalism tends to be a temporary phenomenon, existing in the Netherlands between 1917 and 1966, in Austria from 1946 to 1966, and in Lebanon from 1943 to 1975. While the French polity was too highly centralized to be anything close to consociational, it is interesting to note that stability came to that country only with the institution of the Fifth Republic in 1958, i.e., at the very moment when the traditional Catholic subculture ceased to be much of a force. (The christian democratic Popular Republican Movement did not survive the end of the Fourth Republic.) Post-war secularization in western Europe made redundant such power-sharing arrangements as had been embodied in consociationalism, sad to say.
In short, I think one would have to look within the Dutch confessional communities themselves for an answer to Gideon's query. There are lessons for such organizations as the Christian Labour Association of Canada, for which Gideon works.
I would love to hear a conversation between Koyzis, Jonathan Chaplin, and John Hiemstra on the political-historical development of Dutch neocalvinism between the death of Kuyper (1920) and the end of verzuiling (in the early 1970s) -- and on what that history has to teach us.
Of the three of us, I am quite certain that John knows the most, since he's written on the topic of the impact of the Dutch confessional system on broadcasting, which would bring him into this era. But my colleague Harry Van Dyke probably knows more than anyone else, since he lived through the collapse of this "regime" in the mid-1960s.
I will do no more than to venture an educated guess as to what happened in the Netherlands. I suppose I would say that, if a particular confessional community loses the will to maintain itself, no amount of consociational politics will serve to preserve it.
Lijphart and other scholars note that consociationalism tends to be a temporary phenomenon, existing in the Netherlands between 1917 and 1966, in Austria from 1946 to 1966, and in Lebanon from 1943 to 1975. While the French polity was too highly centralized to be anything close to consociational, it is interesting to note that stability came to that country only with the institution of the Fifth Republic in 1958, i.e., at the very moment when the traditional Catholic subculture ceased to be much of a force. (The christian democratic Popular Republican Movement did not survive the end of the Fourth Republic.) Post-war secularization in western Europe made redundant such power-sharing arrangements as had been embodied in consociationalism, sad to say.
In short, I think one would have to look within the Dutch confessional communities themselves for an answer to Gideon's query. There are lessons for such organizations as the Christian Labour Association of Canada, for which Gideon works.
One of the things that being a father to a four-year-old has facilitated is an increasing acquaintance with the corpus of children’s literature, including the works of Beatrix Potter, best known for her “Tale of Peter Rabbit.” In recent evenings I’ve been reading to Theresa from a volume containing fourteen of her stories, Peter Rabbit’s Storytime Collection. All but two are unfamiliar to me. I recall “The Tale of Peter Rabbit” itself and “The Tale of Benjamin Bunny,” the former far better than the latter.

As I’ve read through these stories, it’s become painfully evident to me that most of them have weak plot lines. But people read them because of the beautiful ink and watercolour illustrations, lovingly executed by the author herself. These are what make the series such a classic of children’s literature.
Incidentally, I understand that it’s unusual nowadays for a children’s book to have the same author and illustrator. There are exceptions, but most of these are from a previous generation, such as Doctor Seuss and Virginia Lee Burton, famous for Mike Mulligan and his Steam Shovel and, my personal favourite, The Little House.
Theresa likes these stories well enough. But the only one she asked to hear again was "The Tale of Samuel Whiskers, Or, The Roly-poly Pudding,” in which little Tom Kitten is kidnapped by two exceedingly argumentative rats who wrap him in pastry dough, intending to bake and eat him–the feline equivalent, I suppose, of a corn dog! I had thought this story would scare my daughter, but, no, she wanted to hear it again. I’ve given up trying to predict her likes and dislikes.

As I’ve read through these stories, it’s become painfully evident to me that most of them have weak plot lines. But people read them because of the beautiful ink and watercolour illustrations, lovingly executed by the author herself. These are what make the series such a classic of children’s literature.
Incidentally, I understand that it’s unusual nowadays for a children’s book to have the same author and illustrator. There are exceptions, but most of these are from a previous generation, such as Doctor Seuss and Virginia Lee Burton, famous for Mike Mulligan and his Steam Shovel and, my personal favourite, The Little House.
Theresa likes these stories well enough. But the only one she asked to hear again was "The Tale of Samuel Whiskers, Or, The Roly-poly Pudding,” in which little Tom Kitten is kidnapped by two exceedingly argumentative rats who wrap him in pastry dough, intending to bake and eat him–the feline equivalent, I suppose, of a corn dog! I had thought this story would scare my daughter, but, no, she wanted to hear it again. I’ve given up trying to predict her likes and dislikes.
07 May 2003
One of the political phenomena that has long fascinated me is what some observers call consociationalism, or consociational democracy. Sometimes it is also labelled "elite accommodation." Arend Lijphart is one of the principal scholarly observers of this, while other names, e.g., Hans Daalder and Kenneth MacRae, have also devoted their attentions to it.
There is no single form of consociational polity, but it consists of any of a number of mechanisms intended to make it possible for citizens in a sharply divided political community to co-operate for common purposes, even when there is potential antagonism among the component communities. Such communities may be divided along ethnic, linguistic, religious or ideological lines. Rather than simply living by majority rule, particularly when there is a substantial minority which fears having its own interests constantly overlooked, a consociational polity places a premium on seeking as wide a consensus as possible in the interest of keeping domestic peace. It may do so by requiring qualified majority voting on significant issues affecting intercommunal relations, allowing for minority vetoes, power sharing within the executive body (as in Lebanon's National Pact from 1943 to 1975), and permitting substantial autonomy within the separate communities themselves over their own affairs.
There was an attempt to implement such a constitution in Cyprus when the island gained its independence from Britain in 1960. But it failed after only three years, leading to the present, longstanding stalemate that is only now easing.
However, the interesting thing about Cyprus is that, whereas in a conventional consociational polity, the elites co-operate to bridge a divide existing at the grassroots level (as in, e.g., Hugh MacLennan's Two Solitudes metaphor concerning francophones and anglophones in Montreal), in Cyprus the elites of the two communities, i.e., Greek and Turkish, only served to pull the communities farther apart when in fact they related quite well with each other on the ground. It was the ethnic nationalists in the two communities that attempted to persuade their respective constituents that they had more in common with their ethnic counterparts in Greece and Turkey than with each other. For a long time it looked as though they had succeeded in creating animosities where they had not existed before.
I myself am usually somewhat sceptical about claims of people power overturning unjust abusers of political authority. The notion that somehow the general will of the people is pure and righteous while government officials are venal and corrupt seems like a piece of Rousseauan wishful thinking. (This form of populism is at the base of the Canadian Alliance Party in this country.) But in Cyprus there certainly seems to be something to this. My father tells of growing up with Turkish Cypriot friends, with whom he still communicates quite amicably. Furthermore, the amazing stories coming out of Cyprus over the past two weeks are further evidence of the spontaneous good will that appears to be propelling recalcitrant elites towards a solution to that island's travails.
Half a century ago it was ethnic Greek nationalists who were the primary problem. More recently it has been the obstinacy of one man, Rauf Denktash, the 78-year-old Turkish Cypriot leader. Here is Gwynne Dyer writing on the "Old man and the siege mentality." And then there's the following: "Open border may seal Turkish Cyprus fate." Perhaps I've been too hard on populism.
There is no single form of consociational polity, but it consists of any of a number of mechanisms intended to make it possible for citizens in a sharply divided political community to co-operate for common purposes, even when there is potential antagonism among the component communities. Such communities may be divided along ethnic, linguistic, religious or ideological lines. Rather than simply living by majority rule, particularly when there is a substantial minority which fears having its own interests constantly overlooked, a consociational polity places a premium on seeking as wide a consensus as possible in the interest of keeping domestic peace. It may do so by requiring qualified majority voting on significant issues affecting intercommunal relations, allowing for minority vetoes, power sharing within the executive body (as in Lebanon's National Pact from 1943 to 1975), and permitting substantial autonomy within the separate communities themselves over their own affairs.
There was an attempt to implement such a constitution in Cyprus when the island gained its independence from Britain in 1960. But it failed after only three years, leading to the present, longstanding stalemate that is only now easing.
However, the interesting thing about Cyprus is that, whereas in a conventional consociational polity, the elites co-operate to bridge a divide existing at the grassroots level (as in, e.g., Hugh MacLennan's Two Solitudes metaphor concerning francophones and anglophones in Montreal), in Cyprus the elites of the two communities, i.e., Greek and Turkish, only served to pull the communities farther apart when in fact they related quite well with each other on the ground. It was the ethnic nationalists in the two communities that attempted to persuade their respective constituents that they had more in common with their ethnic counterparts in Greece and Turkey than with each other. For a long time it looked as though they had succeeded in creating animosities where they had not existed before.
I myself am usually somewhat sceptical about claims of people power overturning unjust abusers of political authority. The notion that somehow the general will of the people is pure and righteous while government officials are venal and corrupt seems like a piece of Rousseauan wishful thinking. (This form of populism is at the base of the Canadian Alliance Party in this country.) But in Cyprus there certainly seems to be something to this. My father tells of growing up with Turkish Cypriot friends, with whom he still communicates quite amicably. Furthermore, the amazing stories coming out of Cyprus over the past two weeks are further evidence of the spontaneous good will that appears to be propelling recalcitrant elites towards a solution to that island's travails.
Half a century ago it was ethnic Greek nationalists who were the primary problem. More recently it has been the obstinacy of one man, Rauf Denktash, the 78-year-old Turkish Cypriot leader. Here is Gwynne Dyer writing on the "Old man and the siege mentality." And then there's the following: "Open border may seal Turkish Cyprus fate." Perhaps I've been too hard on populism.
We were back down to McMaster University Medical Centre yesterday, where my wife submitted to long-awaited elective surgery, which had been delayed due to the SARS outbreak. Precautions are still in place, and all persons entering the hospital are being routed through a single entrance once again. Visitors are prohibited, except for those immediately responsible for a patient.
As we sat in the various waiting rooms, we peppered our conversations with nervous humour, something that often occurs when people are trying to ward off an apprehensive mood. I observed that she was about to have her sinuses "deconstructed," and we wondered aloud what a post-modern, Derridean approach to the surgical art would look like. We speculated on this for a few minutes, and then quickly decided we would rather not find out.
Surgery was successful. Please pray for a speedy recovery. Thanks.
As we sat in the various waiting rooms, we peppered our conversations with nervous humour, something that often occurs when people are trying to ward off an apprehensive mood. I observed that she was about to have her sinuses "deconstructed," and we wondered aloud what a post-modern, Derridean approach to the surgical art would look like. We speculated on this for a few minutes, and then quickly decided we would rather not find out.
Surgery was successful. Please pray for a speedy recovery. Thanks.
06 May 2003
I recently discovered that, up until about a century and a half ago, no one really knew what the island of Cyprus was shaped like. Maps had been made for centuries, of course, but no one had really undertaken a scientific survey of the island until 1851. Most of these maps showed it looking something like the following Venetian map printed in 1570, just prior to its conquest by the Ottoman Turks:

More accurate maps would come only in the middle of the nineteenth century, and the first really accurate one was produced by Lord Kitchener after the British acquired Cyprus in 1878. (Yes, this is the same Lord Kitchener after whom Berlin, Ontario, was renamed during the Great War.) Kitchener undertook the first triangulated survey of the island, an event recounted in the following article: “Kitchener’s Survey of Cyprus 1878-1883." Now, of course, we know that the island looks like this:

After reading this article, I became aware that I have long had a map on my home office wall of “The Turkish Empire in Europe and Asia, with the Kingdom of Greece,” published in London and “Corrected to 1st June 1845.” Sure enough, the shape of Cyprus on this map is distorted, more resembling the 16th century Venetian map than the contemporary one immediately above. I suppose I had originally attributed this distortion to the lack of artistic skill in the cartographer. But it seems no one at that time understood what the island really looked like.

More accurate maps would come only in the middle of the nineteenth century, and the first really accurate one was produced by Lord Kitchener after the British acquired Cyprus in 1878. (Yes, this is the same Lord Kitchener after whom Berlin, Ontario, was renamed during the Great War.) Kitchener undertook the first triangulated survey of the island, an event recounted in the following article: “Kitchener’s Survey of Cyprus 1878-1883." Now, of course, we know that the island looks like this:
After reading this article, I became aware that I have long had a map on my home office wall of “The Turkish Empire in Europe and Asia, with the Kingdom of Greece,” published in London and “Corrected to 1st June 1845.” Sure enough, the shape of Cyprus on this map is distorted, more resembling the 16th century Venetian map than the contemporary one immediately above. I suppose I had originally attributed this distortion to the lack of artistic skill in the cartographer. But it seems no one at that time understood what the island really looked like.
05 May 2003
The year 1951 was a banner year for the publication of several classic books in the areas of politics, philosophy and religion. For example, Hannah Arendt published her Origins of Totalitarianism (New York: Harcourt Brace), which brought together a number of previously published essays on the subjects of imperialism, antisemitism and totalitarianism. In this book Arendt is better at painting a chilling portrait of the totalitarian regime, particularly that of nazi Germany, than of actually accounting for its origins. Yet, coming as it did so soon after the end of Hitler's rule and in the midst of the worst of the Cold War, this book helped to set the tone for much of the subsequent reflection on the nature of totalitarian rule. Many observers were not even sure that totalitarianism was all that distinctive. Perhaps it was simply a modern form of tyranny. But reading Arendt's account left little doubt. Something different was at work in Hitler's Germany, Stalin's Soviet Union and Mao's China.
Are there still totalitarian regimes in the world today? China seems no longer to be such, even if the same party is in power. The Soviet Union passed into history nearly a dozen years ago. It's possible that Saddam Hussein's Iraq could be classified as totalitarian. In any event, it was certainly based on widespread terror. Perhaps it's the terror that most marks such a regime: the general feeling that nothing can be allowed to stay put, to settle into a status quo, that no one can be allowed to be at ease even in their own homes. Totalitarianism blurs the boundary between public and private by making everything public, by deprecating everything that does not quite fit into the official ideology. It is pure movement fighting against every perceived staticity.
I will be posting notices about other books published in that important year just after the middle of the last century.
Are there still totalitarian regimes in the world today? China seems no longer to be such, even if the same party is in power. The Soviet Union passed into history nearly a dozen years ago. It's possible that Saddam Hussein's Iraq could be classified as totalitarian. In any event, it was certainly based on widespread terror. Perhaps it's the terror that most marks such a regime: the general feeling that nothing can be allowed to stay put, to settle into a status quo, that no one can be allowed to be at ease even in their own homes. Totalitarianism blurs the boundary between public and private by making everything public, by deprecating everything that does not quite fit into the official ideology. It is pure movement fighting against every perceived staticity.
I will be posting notices about other books published in that important year just after the middle of the last century.
04 May 2003
There is an interesting tradition about this church, St. Lazarus, in Larnaca:

The tradition holds that, after he was raised from the dead by Jesus Christ, Lazarus went to Cyprus, where he became Bishop of Kition. Here he died a second time and is buried in this church. There is a skull beneath glass that reputedly belonged to Lazarus.

The tradition holds that, after he was raised from the dead by Jesus Christ, Lazarus went to Cyprus, where he became Bishop of Kition. Here he died a second time and is buried in this church. There is a skull beneath glass that reputedly belonged to Lazarus.
One of the more interesting features of Cyprus is that it has experienced a variety of cultural influences, including Byzantine, mediaeval western and Islamic. Here is a typical example, the St. Nicholas Cathedral, built during the Frankish and Venetian eras in the fourteenth century. After the Ottoman conquest in 1571, it became a mosque, complete with minaret.

This is located in the old walled city of Famagusta, which up to now has been inaccessible from the south.

This is located in the old walled city of Famagusta, which up to now has been inaccessible from the south.
Here is the poem I mentioned earlier:
ODE TO A TROUBLED ISLE
O troubled isle of Aphrodite,
Thy verdant beauty has become
For others a supreme delight,
But not for thee, for enmity
Has come between surrounding lands
That vie each with the other one
For favour from thy bounteous hands.
O fabled isle of goddess' birth,
Where classic temples proudly stand
And mythic heroes walk the earth;
'Tis from the sea she came to be,
As told with all the poet's charm,
To bring the joys of love that man
Might live in peace and do no harm.
O ancient isle of copper's fame,
How much of history hast thou seen:
Of foreign kings who often came
To taste thy fruit but stayed to root
Their restless hearts within thy soil
And give their children what has been
A legacy of tears and toil.
O blessed isle of Barnabas,
Apostles trod upon thy shores,
Which saw the martyrs' blood, alas,
That spilt with pain, but not in vain,
To keep the faith delivered once
From persecution's cruel force
And fast against its bold affronts.
O lovely isle of fruitful vine,
Would that thou wert elsewhere placed:
A thousand miles away would thine
Abundant fields their produce yield
To satisfy thy people's want,
Who never more would have to taste
The turmoil of the old Levant.
O thou, my father's native isle,
Thy very heart is rent in twain
And subject to severest trial,
For on this day are cast away
Thy people from their pastures green
And left to gather what remain
Of brighter days that once have been.
O troubled isle of Aphrodite,
Thy verdant beauty has become
For others a supreme delight,
But not for thee; for Amity,
Who once among thy people dwelt,
Has fled before the tyrants' gun
But yet shall make her presence felt.
David T. Koyzis
Perhaps the last three and a half lines will prove to be prophetic. The poem can also be found here.
O troubled isle of Aphrodite,
Thy verdant beauty has become
For others a supreme delight,
But not for thee, for enmity
Has come between surrounding lands
That vie each with the other one
For favour from thy bounteous hands.
O fabled isle of goddess' birth,
Where classic temples proudly stand
And mythic heroes walk the earth;
'Tis from the sea she came to be,
As told with all the poet's charm,
To bring the joys of love that man
Might live in peace and do no harm.
O ancient isle of copper's fame,
How much of history hast thou seen:
Of foreign kings who often came
To taste thy fruit but stayed to root
Their restless hearts within thy soil
And give their children what has been
A legacy of tears and toil.
O blessed isle of Barnabas,
Apostles trod upon thy shores,
Which saw the martyrs' blood, alas,
That spilt with pain, but not in vain,
To keep the faith delivered once
From persecution's cruel force
And fast against its bold affronts.
O lovely isle of fruitful vine,
Would that thou wert elsewhere placed:
A thousand miles away would thine
Abundant fields their produce yield
To satisfy thy people's want,
Who never more would have to taste
The turmoil of the old Levant.
O thou, my father's native isle,
Thy very heart is rent in twain
And subject to severest trial,
For on this day are cast away
Thy people from their pastures green
And left to gather what remain
Of brighter days that once have been.
O troubled isle of Aphrodite,
Thy verdant beauty has become
For others a supreme delight,
But not for thee; for Amity,
Who once among thy people dwelt,
Has fled before the tyrants' gun
But yet shall make her presence felt.
David T. Koyzis
Perhaps the last three and a half lines will prove to be prophetic. The poem can also be found here.
Kolossi Castle
This is Kolossi Castle in Limassol. It was built by the Knights of the Hospital of St. John of Jerusalem.

The Knights of St. John would eventually move to the Aegean island of Rhodes, over which they would exercise sovereignty until they were defeated by the Ottoman Turks in the sixteenth century. A few years later they were given Malta, which they held until expelled by Napoleon at the end of the eighteenth century. They are still known as the Knights of Malta and are based in Rome.
In Cyprus, on the grounds of the castle, they produced a famous dessert wine called Commandaria, which my father loves but which is far too sweet for most western tastes--even for a Byzantine-rite Calvinist! If the Ontario liquor stores were to carry it, it would probably be given a sugar rating of 15!
This is Kolossi Castle in Limassol. It was built by the Knights of the Hospital of St. John of Jerusalem.

The Knights of St. John would eventually move to the Aegean island of Rhodes, over which they would exercise sovereignty until they were defeated by the Ottoman Turks in the sixteenth century. A few years later they were given Malta, which they held until expelled by Napoleon at the end of the eighteenth century. They are still known as the Knights of Malta and are based in Rome.
In Cyprus, on the grounds of the castle, they produced a famous dessert wine called Commandaria, which my father loves but which is far too sweet for most western tastes--even for a Byzantine-rite Calvinist! If the Ontario liquor stores were to carry it, it would probably be given a sugar rating of 15!
Here is what Famagusta looked like in 1995, seen from across the green line in Dherynia. At that time it had not been inhabited in twenty-one years.

During the 1960s, in the decade after independence, it was the centre of the tourist industry. The hotels are long abandoned and the sandy beaches--some of the best in the island--are bereft of sunbathers. However, if the current momentum is maintained, this may change in the not too distant future.

During the 1960s, in the decade after independence, it was the centre of the tourist industry. The hotels are long abandoned and the sandy beaches--some of the best in the island--are bereft of sunbathers. However, if the current momentum is maintained, this may change in the not too distant future.
03 May 2003
Here is one way to sing through the entire Psalter in the course of a week, following the canonical hours of daily prayer. Perhaps this is good reason to spend at least a week in a monastery.
When I first began this blog about a week and a half ago, I hadn't intended to devote so much of it to Cyprus. But the extraordinary events that started the very next day have effectively taken over this blog--at least for now. I myself am a Reformed Christian, but with paternal roots in Orthodoxy. This may seem an unlikely journey, but the link for many people is the American Academy in Larnaca, Cyprus, once associated with the Reformed Presbyterian Church in North America, the Covenanters, who also operate Geneva College in Beaver Falls, Pennsylvania. It is the American Academy that brought a number of particularly Greek Cypriots (but also members of the small Armenian community) into the Reformed and Presbyterian orbit.
My father attended this school in the mid-1940s. Not every one who attended wound up in the Reformed camp. Often parents would send their children there because English was (and is) the medium of instruction and it presented a good way to immerse them in what is effectively the world language.
Over the years I've come across a number of Cypriot ex-pats who once attended the American Academy. The institution still exists, and I saw the building from the outside during my visit to the island in 1995. But, sad to say, it does not appear to have retained its christian orientation, judging from the website. Moreover, the RPCNA website does not mention it either, although the denomination still seems to have a mission in Cyprus.
I've recently discovered that a former student of mine, now teaching at Eastern University, has a colleague whose roots are Armenian and Cypriot and whose father was a classmate of my own father's more than half a century ago. Small world indeed.
My father attended this school in the mid-1940s. Not every one who attended wound up in the Reformed camp. Often parents would send their children there because English was (and is) the medium of instruction and it presented a good way to immerse them in what is effectively the world language.
Over the years I've come across a number of Cypriot ex-pats who once attended the American Academy. The institution still exists, and I saw the building from the outside during my visit to the island in 1995. But, sad to say, it does not appear to have retained its christian orientation, judging from the website. Moreover, the RPCNA website does not mention it either, although the denomination still seems to have a mission in Cyprus.
I've recently discovered that a former student of mine, now teaching at Eastern University, has a colleague whose roots are Armenian and Cypriot and whose father was a classmate of my own father's more than half a century ago. Small world indeed.
02 May 2003
More on Cyprus from the International Herald Tribune: "Unofficially, Turkish Cyprus hails invading Greeks." The dateline is Kyrenia, the beautiful seaside city on the north coast of the island. Now for the first time in a generation Greeks and Turks are mingling freely here:
One senses that the huge surge in popular support for a united Cyprus is creating a momentum with which the leaders of the two communities will have to try mightily to keep up:
This is the sort of thing that brings tears to my eyes:
But naturally there are more poignant moments:
Many years ago I wrote a poem dedicated to Cyprus, and I will post it here at some point. KALH NYXTA CAC.
Kyrenia has not kept count, but every day the cafés along the harbor have been full of Greeks, eating, drinking, laughing. Turks have joined them as though there never was a war that tore them apart. Overnight, the Jewel of the Levant, as it was known in ancient times, has been jolted from its languid ways.
One senses that the huge surge in popular support for a united Cyprus is creating a momentum with which the leaders of the two communities will have to try mightily to keep up:
The flood of people has overtaken the long-term projects of politicians and diplomats who have agonized about reuniting the island with orderly plans, only to see them fail time after time. Among the unresolved questions is the issue of how to deal with the huge economic gap between the poor Turkish north and the rich Greek south.
This is the sort of thing that brings tears to my eyes:
It is hard to tell who is more excited, the Turks or the Greeks. Some Greek families said they had spent the night in their cars at the checkpoint in the buffer zone, afraid to lose their place in line. Now they were telling their life stories to perfect strangers in the harbor cafes.
Kyrenians seemed eager to listen. "We are all in a dream, in a state of shock," said Ayla Djemal, whose Turkish family had just made friends with Greeks arriving from the southern port of Limassol. "It's marvelous," she said. "Our lives were far apart, but we all shared the same dividing wall."
But naturally there are more poignant moments:
Beneath the goodwill and newfound fraternity, though, other, less visible emotions linger. For instance, Soulla and Irini Mathiti, two Greek sisters, came back to Kyrenia after visiting a small village in the mountains.
When their family fled south in the war, their father, an Orthodox priest, insisted on staying, refusing to abandon his church and his flock. He was never seen again.
This week, for the first time, his daughters returned to his little church, now a mosque. The imam heard them sobbing. He apologized and embraced them, then he led them to a small room in the mosque.
''He gave us my father's books. He gave us his Bible," said Soulla. Now, the sisters said, they could mourn their father at last.
Many years ago I wrote a poem dedicated to Cyprus, and I will post it here at some point. KALH NYXTA CAC.
Paleoconservatives are an interesting lot. They seem to include a number of Confederate sympathizers, nearly a century and a half after the start of the American civil war. Check out Jim Lancuster's homepage for someone in favour of what he calls "homerule for Dixie." Perhaps he's the American equivalent of our Jacques Parizeau, Bernard Landry and Lucien Bouchard.
01 May 2003
More on Cyprus from Britain's Financial Times: Turks and Greeks edging closer on Cyprus. There is definitely momentum, prompted from a number of quarters, including the European Union, Kofi Annan, and even Ankara. But there will be a lot of issues to sort out before anything like lasting unity can come about.
All the same, at this point I can't help but be optimistic, which is an uncharacteristic mood for me. The joyful reunions we've witnessed between Greeks and Turks in Cyprus seem to indicate that there is a general will to make things work. It's difficult to imagine the same scenes between Israelis and Palestinians.
All the same, at this point I can't help but be optimistic, which is an uncharacteristic mood for me. The joyful reunions we've witnessed between Greeks and Turks in Cyprus seem to indicate that there is a general will to make things work. It's difficult to imagine the same scenes between Israelis and Palestinians.
Here is Sarah Hinlicky Wilson again:
For more than twenty years now I have regularly prayed the daily office, using the traditional western liturgical forms of morning and evening prayer, or matins and vespers, as they are also called. It started when I purchased a copy of Herbert Lindemann, The Daily Office (St. Louis: Concordia, 1965), at the bookstore of Luther Seminary in St. Paul, Minnesota. It's a form of prayer regimen originating in the monasteries and carried into the Anglican Book of Common Prayer and, in part, into the Lutheran tradition as well.
Morning prayer begins with an opening versicle from a Psalm, the Gloria Patri, the Venite (Psalm 95), a hymn (usually an ancient Greek or Latin hymn translated into English), a Psalm, one or more scripture lessons, a canticle (usually the Benedictus from Luke 1 or the Te Deum), prayers and petitions, the Lord's prayer, and a closing sentence. Evening prayer takes the same general approach, but the canticle is the Magnificat (also from Luke 1), and the Venite is absent. In the monasteries prayers are said several times a day, usually at three-hour intervals. I've never participated in these canonical hours in a monastery, but I would love to do so some day.
The wonderful thing about this prayer regimen is that it takes one through the Psalms on a regular basis, perhaps through the entire 150 Psalms over the course of a week or month. Over the years I have discovered that there is nothing like the Psalms for teaching one to pray. To be sure, I don't always feel like praying, and there are times when I've not followed this daily prayer for months. But I always come back to it, and it's difficult to imagine abandoning it altogether, because it's been such a source of strength for me. Hinlicky Wilson is right: it's a wonderful way to discipline the undisciplined heart.
Prayer happens because a soul loves God and can’t keep quiet about it. I think it’s that simple. Or: prayer happens because a soul is angry at God and can’t keep quiet about it. (Take a look at those psalms of lament!) Or: prayer happens because a soul is sorrowful without God and can’t keep quiet about it. In each case, prayer happens. It’s not a plan or a program. It’s more like a reflex or a reaction. Whether the prayer is spontaneously composed or read out of a devotional book, it starts in the desire of the soul. We all know that you can’t just talk someone into believing in God, and I suspect you can’t talk someone into talking to God either. It has to start somewhere deep, in joy or in pain, and — this is the critical part — because of the presence and action of the Holy Spirit.
The great thing about the Holy Spirit here is that he upsets the categories of motivation and accomplishment to make everything point away from self and back to God. The Holy Spirit responds to the desire of a heart longing for God, but he also creates in the first place a heart that can long for God. Desires get turned into disciplines, and disciplines hold steady even as desire comes and goes. That’s why the whole history of the church has testified that a discipline of prayer is a good way to express and teach the undisciplined desire of the soul.
For more than twenty years now I have regularly prayed the daily office, using the traditional western liturgical forms of morning and evening prayer, or matins and vespers, as they are also called. It started when I purchased a copy of Herbert Lindemann, The Daily Office (St. Louis: Concordia, 1965), at the bookstore of Luther Seminary in St. Paul, Minnesota. It's a form of prayer regimen originating in the monasteries and carried into the Anglican Book of Common Prayer and, in part, into the Lutheran tradition as well.
Morning prayer begins with an opening versicle from a Psalm, the Gloria Patri, the Venite (Psalm 95), a hymn (usually an ancient Greek or Latin hymn translated into English), a Psalm, one or more scripture lessons, a canticle (usually the Benedictus from Luke 1 or the Te Deum), prayers and petitions, the Lord's prayer, and a closing sentence. Evening prayer takes the same general approach, but the canticle is the Magnificat (also from Luke 1), and the Venite is absent. In the monasteries prayers are said several times a day, usually at three-hour intervals. I've never participated in these canonical hours in a monastery, but I would love to do so some day.
The wonderful thing about this prayer regimen is that it takes one through the Psalms on a regular basis, perhaps through the entire 150 Psalms over the course of a week or month. Over the years I have discovered that there is nothing like the Psalms for teaching one to pray. To be sure, I don't always feel like praying, and there are times when I've not followed this daily prayer for months. But I always come back to it, and it's difficult to imagine abandoning it altogether, because it's been such a source of strength for me. Hinlicky Wilson is right: it's a wonderful way to discipline the undisciplined heart.
Earlier in the week I was having a conversation with a friend about, inter alia, prayer. I was thinking about prayer again today after coming across an article, "Teach me to pray," by Sarah Hinlicky Wilson, a young Lutheran pastor in North Carolina. The central question raised by the command to pray is whether prayer actually changes God. I suppose my answer to this would be that I don't know. Scripture portrays God, especially in the Old Testament, as constantly changing his mind, as, for example, in relenting from a previously threatened punishment. This happened during the forty years of wandering in the desert. It happened in the book of Jonah when God called off the destruction of Nineveh. It happened when King Hezekiah talked God into extending his life by another fifteen years.
Hinlicky says she is uncomfortable with the notion of God changing his mind and dismisses this--rather too glibly in my view--as a reason for prayer. But prayer is efficacious. My wife and I found this out for ourselves when our daughter Theresa was in hospital for just over ten weeks after her premature birth. Around that same time I became aware of studies indicating that prayer has a definite effect on bringing about the recovery from illness, even if the patients are unaware of being prayed for. I must admit to being put off initially by the notion that God's acts in his world can be subjected to scientific scrutiny, but perhaps it's not essentially different from studying photosynthesis, whose very functioning is due to God's grace manifested in creation.
In any event, Theresa eventually came home and, despite a less than even chance of her suffering no ill effects from her early entry into the world, she is doing remarkably well. More than 300 people (that I'm aware of) were praying for her during this time. A number of people--quite independently of each other--have dubbed her a "miracle baby," and I believe it. Here is her story, for those interested.
Hinlicky says she is uncomfortable with the notion of God changing his mind and dismisses this--rather too glibly in my view--as a reason for prayer. But prayer is efficacious. My wife and I found this out for ourselves when our daughter Theresa was in hospital for just over ten weeks after her premature birth. Around that same time I became aware of studies indicating that prayer has a definite effect on bringing about the recovery from illness, even if the patients are unaware of being prayed for. I must admit to being put off initially by the notion that God's acts in his world can be subjected to scientific scrutiny, but perhaps it's not essentially different from studying photosynthesis, whose very functioning is due to God's grace manifested in creation.
In any event, Theresa eventually came home and, despite a less than even chance of her suffering no ill effects from her early entry into the world, she is doing remarkably well. More than 300 people (that I'm aware of) were praying for her during this time. A number of people--quite independently of each other--have dubbed her a "miracle baby," and I believe it. Here is her story, for those interested.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
