One of the political phenomena that has long fascinated me is what some observers call consociationalism, or consociational democracy. Sometimes it is also labelled "elite accommodation." Arend Lijphart is one of the principal scholarly observers of this, while other names, e.g., Hans Daalder and Kenneth MacRae, have also devoted their attentions to it.
There is no single form of consociational polity, but it consists of any of a number of mechanisms intended to make it possible for citizens in a sharply divided political community to co-operate for common purposes, even when there is potential antagonism among the component communities. Such communities may be divided along ethnic, linguistic, religious or ideological lines. Rather than simply living by majority rule, particularly when there is a substantial minority which fears having its own interests constantly overlooked, a consociational polity places a premium on seeking as wide a consensus as possible in the interest of keeping domestic peace. It may do so by requiring qualified majority voting on significant issues affecting intercommunal relations, allowing for minority vetoes, power sharing within the executive body (as in Lebanon's National Pact from 1943 to 1975), and permitting substantial autonomy within the separate communities themselves over their own affairs.
There was an attempt to implement such a constitution in Cyprus when the island gained its independence from Britain in 1960. But it failed after only three years, leading to the present, longstanding stalemate that is only now easing.
However, the interesting thing about Cyprus is that, whereas in a conventional consociational polity, the elites co-operate to bridge a divide existing at the grassroots level (as in, e.g., Hugh MacLennan's Two Solitudes metaphor concerning francophones and anglophones in Montreal), in Cyprus the elites of the two communities, i.e., Greek and Turkish, only served to pull the communities farther apart when in fact they related quite well with each other on the ground. It was the ethnic nationalists in the two communities that attempted to persuade their respective constituents that they had more in common with their ethnic counterparts in Greece and Turkey than with each other. For a long time it looked as though they had succeeded in creating animosities where they had not existed before.
I myself am usually somewhat sceptical about claims of people power overturning unjust abusers of political authority. The notion that somehow the general will of the people is pure and righteous while government officials are venal and corrupt seems like a piece of Rousseauan wishful thinking. (This form of populism is at the base of the Canadian Alliance Party in this country.) But in Cyprus there certainly seems to be something to this. My father tells of growing up with Turkish Cypriot friends, with whom he still communicates quite amicably. Furthermore, the amazing stories coming out of Cyprus over the past two weeks are further evidence of the spontaneous good will that appears to be propelling recalcitrant elites towards a solution to that island's travails.
Half a century ago it was ethnic Greek nationalists who were the primary problem. More recently it has been the obstinacy of one man, Rauf Denktash, the 78-year-old Turkish Cypriot leader. Here is Gwynne Dyer writing on the "Old man and the siege mentality." And then there's the following: "Open border may seal Turkish Cyprus fate." Perhaps I've been too hard on populism.
07 May 2003
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Followers
Blog Archive
-
▼
2003
(596)
-
▼
May
(76)
- Turkey, Europe and the US The Bush administration...
- The average blogger? I have no idea whether anyon...
- Dr. Seuss again There is something mildly deflati...
- Jacques Maritain As I mentioned a few weeks ago i...
- Ascension Day Today is the feast of the Ascension...
- The "strange" phenomenon of fundamentalism The ot...
- Fall of Constantinople: a grim anniversaryToday is...
- A pro-life parable from Dr. Seuss? I have no idea...
- Emil Brunner's political and social ethics Althou...
- No unpublished thought One of my professors at No...
- I have been telling my students that since 1993 th...
- The open barrier: a month later The people of Cyp...
- Which Bible translation?When InterVarsity Press an...
- Incidentally, I do have a personal homepage, as we...
- Hearing Nicholas Wolterstorff this weekend has rem...
- The comics page Ever since Gary Larson stopped dr...
- The tragedy of protestant liturgy: a cri de coeurT...
- Graduation day Today was the Eighteenth Convocati...
- Differentiation and Robert Putnam's work Dooyewee...
- Famagusta Famagusta is located on the east coast ...
- Wolterstorff visits Redeemer This morning we Rede...
- It appears that my "Comments" are gone before they...
- A Kuyperian Catholic? Several years ago I came in...
- There seemed to be server troubles yesterday, and ...
- Book copy received Yesterday I received the first...
- Chimps reclassified as us I have usually consider...
- Children's television In addition to familiarizin...
- Victoria Day Happy Victoria Day, everyone! I d...
- It seems that my comments will not be operational ...
- I owe a debt of gratitude to Emeth Hesed Smith for...
- Strauss' influence in Georgetown Many thanks to G...
- Leo Strauss' influence in Washington Here is an a...
- Kazantzakis and The Greek Passion Nowadays the no...
- The hymns of the mass Despite my regret at the lo...
- Book now available I've just received word from m...
- The fate of the first Christendom One of the more...
- The ordinary of the massIn the western church for ...
- Old and Hart on the church year Having recently r...
- Another poignant return in Cyprus This is another...
- Leo Strauss' influence Eddie Thomas writes: Of t...
- The Genevan PsalterChristians have been singing th...
- Our anniversary Seven years ago today Nancy and I...
- My wife and I often watch ABC World News Tonight a...
- Other minorities in Cyprus In addition to the maj...
- The eastern cross I notice that the Rev. Fred Her...
- Another classic book from 1951 H. Richard Niebuhr...
- Every Orthodox church building carries an icon of ...
- Homage à Brubeck Last year I composed a piece ins...
- Our own Berlin Wall in Hamilton?On friday I wrote:...
- Growing up too quickly? Within the past week or s...
- The sign of the cross Is there something to be sa...
- Dave Brubeck's odd time signatures I cannot exact...
- Political message in a classic filmThis evening my...
- Differentiation and historical developmentThe Dutc...
- Another Berlin Wall is opened It's been nearly fo...
- More from Cyprus The Turkish Prime Minister is sc...
- Gideon again: This is important stuff, because as...
- Gideon Strauss writes: I would love to hear a con...
- One of the things that being a father to a four-ye...
- One of the political phenomena that has long fasci...
- We were back down to McMaster University Medical C...
- I recently discovered that, up until about a centu...
- The year 1951 was a banner year for the publicatio...
- There is an interesting tradition about this churc...
- One of the more interesting features of Cyprus is ...
- Here is the poem I mentioned earlier: ODE TO A TR...
- Kolossi CastleThis is Kolossi Castle in Limassol. ...
- Here is what Famagusta looked like in 1995, seen f...
- Here is one way to sing through the entire Psalter...
- When I first began this blog about a week and a ha...
- More on Cyprus from the International Herald Tribu...
- Paleoconservatives are an interesting lot. They s...
- More on Cyprus from Britain's Financial Times: Tur...
- My sense is that we in the Reformed tradition are ...
- Here is Sarah Hinlicky Wilson again: Prayer happ...
- Earlier in the week I was having a conversation wi...
-
▼
May
(76)
No comments:
Post a Comment