12 May 2004

American federalism off balance?

In the fifth chapter of my book, I allude to the passage of the 17th amendment to the US Constitution as part of a larger effort to democratize more thoroughly the American political system. This amendment provided for the direct election of Senators. Was it a good idea or not? Bruce Bartlett argues that it was not in "The problem with the 17th." Bartlett believes that the 17th amendment effectively upset the careful balance that is American federalism. He further argues, with less plausibility I'm inclined to think, that it paved the way for the huge expansion of the federal government in the mid-20th century. Here's Bartlett on the procedure replaced by the amendment:

Few people today know that the Founding Fathers never intended for senators to be popularly elected. The Constitution originally provided that senators would be chosen by state legislatures. The purpose was to provide the states -- as states -- an institutional role in the federal government. In effect, senators were to function as ambassadors from the states, which were expected to retain a large degree of sovereignty even after ratification of the Constitution, thereby ensuring that their rights would be protected in a federal system.

The role of senators as representatives of the states was assured by a procedure, now forgotten, whereby states would "instruct" their senators how to vote on particular issues. Such instructions were not conveyed to members of the House of Representatives because they have always been popularly elected and are not expected to speak for their states, but only for their constituents.

Bartlett is not the only person convinced that this amendment was a mistake. So is Ralph A. Rossum, in Federalism, the Supreme Court, and the Seventeenth Amendment: The Irony of Constitutional Democracy. Furthermore, there are a number of groups in the US dedicated to the repeal of the 17th amendment, mostly to defend states' rights and curtail an overweening Washington.

Although it's not clear to me that repeal will have the effect its proponents think it will, they have nevertheless called attention to a legitimate feature of federal systems, viz., the need for representation of the constituent governmental units at the federal centre. Here in Canada our Senate on paper represents the provinces, but the fact that our Senators are effectively appointed by the Prime Minister negates this representative character. Americans have the enviable luxury of debating whether state legislatures or the state's voters should elect Senators. We haven't got even that far in this country. In many respects, Canada is more decentralized than the US, with the provinces jealously guarding their interests. However, our upper chamber does not adequately represent these interests in Ottawa. In fact, because of the way its members attain their seats, the Senate has become one more arm of what many would see as an already excessively centralized prime ministerial government. Although Senate reform is a cottage industry among some academics and pundits, it has yet to go anywhere despite several false starts. Our neighbours to the south are considerably ahead of us on this score.
Catholic politicians and their church

Sen. John Forbes Kerry is the first Roman Catholic in more than a generation to be a serious contender for the US presidency. Yet, like an earlier JFK whom he claims to admire, Kerry too is claiming that he will be a president who just happens to be a practising Catholic. He will not be taking instruction from the Pope, or even from his church's social teachings. Here's is Fr. Robert Sirico, who finds Kerry's refusal to 'inform his conscience' detrimental. To those objecting to the church's role in forming the conscience of its members, Sirico writes:
If religious leaders cannot set the terms of their moral guidance, how are they religious leaders? To be sure, all Catholic politicians must follow their consciences. But the church must also be free to exercise its role as the former of conscience. To let the Catholic Church be Catholic is as essential to pluralism as people's freedom to accept or reject its teachings. Let us not confuse matters by claiming that a church that claims moral authority over the believer is violating anyone's rights.
A cutting remark

Somehow it seems appropriate to mow the lawn and to have one's hair trimmed the same day. . . just as long as one doesn't mix up the cutting instruments.

11 May 2004

Saturday's concert

On saturday evening at the Church of St. John the Evangelist, the senior, intermediate and junior choirs performed in concert. Our Theresa is a member of the junior choir and appears to be the youngest member. Last September, when she wasn't quite five years old, she began singing with them, but at that time she didn't seem quite to grasp what was going on and what was expected of her. Now she is quite an enthusiastic participant and keeps wanting to play the teaching cassette over and over so she can sing along. In keeping perhaps with Theresa's fascination for foreign languages, the director, Mrs. Susan McKay, a local award-winning elementary school teacher, had her small charges singing in Zulu and Latin. Theresa's favourite by far was O Sifuni Mungu, a southern African rendition of All Creatures of Our God and King. She is still singing it, three days after the concert.

The senior choir sang, among other things, my own Credo in Septuple Metre, a metrical version of the Apostles' Creed set to an original melody with a 7/8 time signature. This was the first time I had heard it sung by a group larger than a quartet. (An organ arrangement of this was played at my inaugural lecture last September.) It was also the first time the trumpet descant, which I composed later, was added. The members of the choir told me they were initially thrown off by the metre, which is common in Greek and Balkan folk music, but not at all in western music. But once they were used to it, they did quite well, I'm happy to say. A most enjoyable evening, all in all.
Baptists and church-state issues

If the Southern Baptist Convention does indeed adopt a resolution in favour of christian education, it could also portend a departure from the usual Baptist affirmation of a particular understanding of church-state separation. Baptists, at least in the US, have generally claimed to favour something approaching Thomas Jefferson's "wall of separation" between church and state. This is often taken to imply, among other things, a pro-choice position on abortion and an opposition to government financial support for independent schools, as seen in the American Baptist Policy Statement on Church and State of the American Baptist Churches. A much briefer "Affirmation of Our Faith" by the Baptist General Conference, a small body with Swedish origins, similarly claims that "Church and State must be kept separate as having different functions, each fulfilling its duties free from dictation or patronage of the other," although it refrains from drawing any specific implications.

The Southern Baptist Convention appears to have modified this somewhat rigid understanding of church-state separation. According to its website,
We stand for a free church in a free state. Neither one should control the affairs of the other. We support the First Amendment to the United States Constitution, with its "establishment" and "free exercise" clauses.

We do, of course, acknowledge the legitimate interplay of these two spheres. For example, it is appropriate for the state to enact and enforce fire codes for the church nurseries. It is also appropriate for ministers to offer prayer at civic functions. Neither the Constitution nor Baptist tradition would build a wall of separation against such practices as these.

The second paragraph would appear to lean very slightly towards what might be labelled a more accommodationist approach to church-state relations -- one which would have government treating the various religious communities and their activities in an even-handed, equitable fashion. This could open the door to the ecclesiastical acceptance of a legitimate government role in recognizing and supporting financially the prior rights of parents to educate their own children. If so, it would mark something of a watershed in the larger Baptist communion.
Another issue hits cyberspace

The latest issue of Comment is now available for reading. Here is the table of contents:

Cyberpunk, Orwellian Fears, and the Faces of Tyranny: Changes in the Future, and What They Tell Us about What We Fear By Daniel Silliman

George Grant and the Primacy of Economics, by David T. Koyzis

Gifts from "Father Abraham", by Vincent Bacote

In Defence of Unions, by Ed Bosveld

Lessons from Old Europe, by Jonathan Chaplin

The Age of Look and Feel, by Dave Bruce Hegeman

May readers far and wide be edified.

10 May 2004

Kudos to colleague

Congratulations are due to my friend and colleague, Dr. Elaine Botha, on the occasion of her retirement from Redeemer University College. May God bless her as she continues to live in the service of his kingdom.
Book should be banned

Some books are simply inappropriate for children. Here's one that should be avoided. (See the saturday, May 8 entry.)
The Cuomo syndrome comes to Canada

This is from Linda Frum's interview with Prime Minister Paul Martin in saturday's National Post:

LF: What is your position on gay marriage?

PM: I've been quite open that this is a question I have had to wrestle with. I have essentially come to the conclusion that it is a Charter [of Rights] question. It is a question of human rights and that tilts the balance. I don't think you can discriminate when it's a question of human rights.

LF: But what is your personal view of it?

PM: I just gave it to you.

LF: I've heard you say that as a Catholic, you are against abortion, though that's not how you would vote on it in the House.

PM: Absolutely. I am a legislator. I basically will vote where I think the public interest lies. I voted pro-choice.

My comments below would appear to be relevant here as well.

08 May 2004

Crete or Cyprus?

And it seems the Irish Republic's postal service is cartographically challenged: "EU stamp 'swaps' Crete for Cyprus."


BBC News

The offending stamp


"The stamp's makers say there was no mistake, and artistic licence was used." Well, I'm sorry, but a closer look indicates that the island in the lower right corner is definitely Crete, and not Cyprus. There's more from the Guardian:

Mr [Peter] Geoffroy suggested that Cyprus' postal service should take revenge by producing its own EU map issue - and connect Ireland to its neighbouring island and old imperial master, Britain.

In Northern Ireland, a part of the United Kingdom, symbol-sensitive Protestants also found fault with the stamp, which has erased the staunchly defended border between Irish south and British north.

Could this be the opening volley in a coming Great Philatelic War?
Hell freezes over

Someone across the pond has quite the sense of humour: "Turkey Becomes Christian and Unites with Cyprus."
Report just published

While we're on the subject of protégés, Shawn de Raaf, who graduated from Redeemer with a degree in political science, has co-authored a new publication under the auspices of the Social Research and Demonstration Corporation, a public policy consulting firm in Ottawa. It is titled, "Understanding Employment Insurance Claim Patterns: Final Report of the Earnings Supplement Project." Here is the summary:

This report contains a series of lessons learned from the Social Research and Demonstration Corporation’s research on work and reliance on Employment Insurance (EI) benefits. These lessons lead to the general conclusion that workers’ frequent reliance on EI should not be viewed simply as a problem of workers becoming familiar with the program and learning how to benefit from its rules and provisions; rather, in many cases, it is a symptom of their difficulties in finding year-round employment due to inadequate skills, insufficient education or limited job opportunities in their region. The lessons also caution against concluding that non-reliance on EI necessarily reflects better labour market outcomes. For many workers, their non-reliance on EI can reflect the barriers they face in securing stable employment or their inability to qualify for benefits. The report concludes by examining the EI program itself to better understand its shortcomings and to identify priorities for future research.

Congratulations to Shawn and his colleagues.

Incidentally Shawn is the husband of author Alison Gresik, also a Redeemer graduate.

07 May 2004

Acting our respective ages

Could it be that the general decline in social courtesies has something to do with children growing up too quickly and adults refusing to grow up at all? Judith Martin, aka "Miss Manners," thinks so. Perhaps adult men should start wearing bow ties and fedoras once again. It couldn't hurt.
Announcement

It's official: next autumn Mr. Michael C. Hogeterp will be teaching Introduction to Political Science (POL 121) at Redeemer University College during my upcoming sabbatical. He thus becomes the first Redeemer alumnus to teach in the department. Hogeterp is research co-ordinator for the Committee for Contact with the Government of the Christian Reformed Church of North America. Here is an excerpt from his testimonty before the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights of the House of Commons last year:

When the Charter [of Rights and Freedoms] is understood to be inflexible on a given point, opportunities for conciliation are suspended. This absolutizes rights and hinders the dynamic conciliatory interchange that gives rights meaning in the long term. Using rights claims as trump cards is not a recipe for social cohesion, inclusivity, or justice.

Living in a community with our differences is made possible by open conversation directed toward just policy and not by defences that absolute rights claims set up. We certainly hope Canadians are committed to an open, inclusive, and respectful dialogue.

One more protégé to take pride in.
Dramatic expansion for US christian education?

If the largest protestant denomination in the US were to come on side of the movement for christian primary and secondary schools, that would be a huge boost indeed for what is now only a minority phenomenon, even among Christians.
The New Pantagruel on line

Volume 1, issue 2 (spring 2004) of The New Pantagruel is now on line. Here are some of the articles to be found in its "pages":

Why Attack Liberalism? (I hope to respond to this myself, since its author misunderstands the character of liberalism.)

The Morality of Complacency, from Icarus Fallen by Chantal Delsol

Weddings and Wrong Choices by Ragan Sutterfield

Baylor 2012: Universal Vision in a Particular Place by Andy Black

The War for the Family by John Zmirak

Whig vs. Augustinian Thomists by Jeremy Beer

And don't forget the poetry and fiction. Happy reading!
Poli sci material?

Ordinarily I wouldn't write in this way about particular students, but here's one young man I'd love to see in more of my courses. He's already been in two of them. Scroll down to the Wednesday, April 21, 2004 entry to learn more about him.

06 May 2004

Kaliningrad

Pity the poor people of the Kaliningrad oblast, a piece of the Russian Federation stranded on the Baltic Sea and now completely surrounded by the European Union, as represented by Poland and Lithuania. Once known as Königsberg, its chief city, also called Kaliningrad, was the capital of East Prussia prior to 1945 and best known as the birthplace and lifelong home of Immanuel Kant. From The Globe and Mail: "'Paper Curtain' descends on Kaliningrad." Here is the predicament of the city's residents:

As of today [1 May], if Kaliningraders want to travel to Poland or Lithuania they have to get a visa, which they didn't need before.

Even if residents only want to travel to other parts of Russia, and can't afford to fly, they have to apply 28 hours in advance to the Lithuanian embassy for permission to board a specially sealed train that crosses Lithuanian territory on the way to Moscow.

What's the answer? Lawyer Sergei Pasko would have Kaliningrad effectively joining the EU, while remaining nominally part of Russia. Whatever happens, it seems evident that the status quo cannot continue.
Higher education: Canada versus the US

On our recent trip to the United States, I was reminded again of some of the differences between that country and Canada. They're not always easy to discern on the surface, but they're there. One of these concerns post-secondary education. Here in Canada -- at least in Ontario -- this field is dominated by a very few provincial universities, some of which may have had christian origins but are by now rather thoroughly secularized. These tend to be concentrated in the major urban centres. The universities may or may not include affiliated colleges, some of which are church-related. For example, as one drives past the University of Waterloo, one sees a rather patronizing sign calling attention to the "church colleges." These include Renison College, St. Paul's College, Conrad Grebel College and St. Jerome's University, affiliated with the Anglican, United, Mennonite and Catholic churches respectively. All are related in some fashion to the University of Waterloo itself. Nearby Waterloo Lutheran University retained its independence but changed its name to Wilfrid Laurier University some three decades ago, thereby abandoning its Lutheran heritage.

Then there are the colleges, such as Mohawk College here in Hamilton. Elsewhere this would be called a polytechnical school and, accordingly, it offers the bachelor of applied technology. The very word college in Canada -- and indeed throughout the Commonwealth countries -- has an indeterminate meaning. It could be a polytechnical school, a private secondary school (e.g., Upper Canada College), a graduate theological school (e.g., Knox College), a school affiliated with a university, or even a professional association (e.g., Ontario College of Teachers).

By contrast, in the US, where I grew up, post-secondary education is far more decentralized and encompasses a variety of types spread throughout the country, including metropolitan areas, middle-sized cities and small towns. There are the publicly-controlled state universities (counterpart to our provincial universities), independent universities and colleges, church-related and confessionally-based colleges, ivy league schools, and so forth. These are scattered far and wide, popping up in the unlikeliest places but firmly rooted in the hearts of their supporters. Driving through Michigan, as we did last week, one frequently encounters signs alerting travellers to Eastern Michigan University, the University of Michigan, Spring Arbor University, Albion College, Kalamazoo College and -- somewhat off the beaten path -- Hillsdale College, Ave Maria College and -- way up in the UP -- Finlandia University. There education is not simply a matter of state governments undertaking to educate their citizens. It is a matter of particular communities -- some overtly confessional and some not -- becoming aware of the need to educate their young people, refusing to wait for someone else to take the initiative, and deciding to do something themselves.

Despite its Canadian location, Redeemer University College conforms to this American pattern. It was established 22 years ago by Reformed Christians of Dutch heritage, who sought to establish a university rooted in an overtly christian worldview. One of its models was certainly the Free University of Amsterdam, but it also joined several institutions south of the border, including Calvin College, Dordt College and Trinity Christian College, established along similar lines. Yet Redeemer is definitely a Canadian institution.

I must confess to preferring the decentralized, bottom-up approach to post-secondary education, of which Redeemer is a part. I rather like driving into a small American town and seeing an equally small college (read: undergraduate university) there. Its very existence speaks well of the people who have sacrificed to make it possible and to keep it going through the ensuing decades. That many of these supporters are Christians with a vision of education in the service of God's kingdom makes their efforts all the more praiseworthy. I could wish for more such efforts in this country.

05 May 2004

Turkey and the EU

Turkey is feeling the negative effects of the latest European Union enlargement: "Cyprus Technicality Ticks Turkish Truckers."
Too bad about those Leafs

Condolences to Toronto hockey fans.
Marriages stronger, lasting longer

Good news for Canada; not so good news for Ontario, Alberta, BC, Yukon: "Canadian divorce rates declining."

04 May 2004

Reining in the courts

Larry Kramer puts a different twist on the usual arguments in favour of a "living constitution," which is generally supposed to entail something approaching judicial supremacy. He argues instead, in "We the People: Who has the last word on the Constitution?", for something he calls popular constitutionalism, in which the courts would defer to the judgements of the electorate on issues of constitutional significance. Writes Kramer:

Making this shift would not entail major changes in the day-to-day business of deciding cases. There would still be briefs and oral arguments and precedents and opinions, and the job of being a Supreme Court justice would look pretty much the same as before. What presumably would change is the justices' attitudes and self-conceptions as they went about their routines. In effect -- though the analogy is more suggestive than literal -- Supreme Court justices would come to see themselves in relation to the public somewhat as lower-court judges now see themselves in relation to the Supreme Court: responsible for interpreting the Constitution according to their best judgment, but with an awareness that there is a higher authority out there with power to overturn their decisions -- an actual authority, too, not some abstract "people" who spoke once, two hundred years ago, and then disappeared.

One could, of course, argue that this popular supremacy is already enshrined in the formal amendment process, yet amending an entrenched constitutional document, in both the US and Canada, is "practically impossible." What is required instead is a sense of restraint on the part of judges themselves.
Sudan and the US

Paul Marshall believes that the Bush administration is effectively abandoning Sudanese Christians who have been fighting for more than two decades to free themselves from the domination of islamic law: "Saving Sudan: The State Department should stand up to Khartoum."
Another byzantine Calvinist?

Who on earth could this be? (Look at the web address.)
The real reason the UN plan was rejected

If Greek Cypriots had approved the UN plan to reunify their island, they would have been saddled with an abysmal national anthem chosen from hundreds of entries submitted last year. Not only is it filled with basic harmonization errors, such as parallel octaves and fifths; it also resembles the mediocre Soviet national anthem, recently readopted as the Russian anthem by President Vladimir "Stalin Lite" Putin. I guess that's what happens when political efforts to conciliate diversity peacefully are allowed to override sound aesthetic judgement.

03 May 2004

Trip to the States

I have just returned from 9 days south of the border in Illinois and Michigan, along with my family. Our trip had two purposes. First, we were in the Chicago area for the baptism of my wife's infant niece a week ago sunday. Second, this past weekend we went to Grand Rapids, Michigan, where I attended the second annual Symposium on Religion and Politics, sponsored by The Henry Institute at Calvin College.

We stayed the first night in Battle Creek, Michigan, making our way to Elmhurst, Illinois, the second night, where we stayed with my sister-in-law and her family. The baptism was administered according to the Maronite rite in a largely Lebanese congregation. The liturgy has some similarities to both Roman and Byzantine rites, with generous use of Aramaic, the language of the very first Christians two millennia ago. The weather was delightful. It was the first time in years we had been back in "home" territory without it being oppressively hot. We were pleasantly surprised at the number of flowering trees in the central DuPage County region where I grew up. The topography is generally not very interesting, but spring is little short of spectacular this year, making it a wonderful time to be visiting. We found a number of things to do with the extended family, including visits to the DuPage County Historical Museum and the Cosley Zoo, both in Wheaton. The former boasts an elaborate model railway in the basement, showing the Chicago & North Western and Chicago Aurora & Elgin railroads as they once made their way through the middle of the county. Another highlight of our stay was a brief visit to First Presbyterian Church in Glen Ellyn, Illinois, where Nancy and I were married and Theresa baptized. I suppose it could be considered our home church in a sense. They have just opened a new and impressive addition to the church building. This is obviously a thriving and growing congregation in an otherwise shrinking denomination.

After our stay in the Chicago area, we made the drive up to Grand Rapids, where I attended and presented a paper at the Henry Institute Symposium, which took place at the new Prince Conference Center at Calvin. The schedule offered a number of interesting papers and presenters. I was pleased that my own paper was scheduled for the very first session, when people are still fresh and enthusiastic and able to come up with good questions. The paper's title was "Redeeming Authority: towards a recovery and proper understanding of authority and its place in human society," which was a slight reworking of my inaugural address. The discussant was Stanley Carlson-Thies, who is with the Center for Public Justice and worked in the White House in 2001-2002.

Among the other sessions I attended was one devoted to Catholic political thought, a perennial interest of mine. Brian Peterson of the University of Dayton gave a paper on Fr. Richard John Neuhaus in which he argued that Neuhaus' embrace of Catholicism has everything to do with his perception of this historic faith's political utility in upholding the American democratic experiment. I think Peterson is right to a large extent, but I suppose I would wish to give Neuhaus more credit than that. Then Fr. Peter Bisson, SJ, delivered a paper describing the Jesuits' commitment to liberation theology since 1975. Although the paper was interesting and made some good points, one would hardly know from his account that liberation theology had long passed its sell-by date.

The most discouraging session was titled "Beyond Kuyperianism" and was chaired by my former colleague, John Bolt, now teaching at Calvin Seminary. David Van Drunen and Darryl Hart argued for the most dualistic and lutheranizing reading of Calvin imaginable. Those arguing for the cosmic scope of redemption in Christ, including my current colleague and great friend Al Wolters (who was mentioned by name), came in for a drubbing. It's almost as if someone were to defend, and even glory in, the residual platonic and manichaean elements in Augustine's thought at the expense of the obviously more biblical elements. Why on earth would anyone, particularly a Reformed Christian, do this? Why would one wish to affirm that Christ's redemptive grace touches only a part of our lives, leaving aside the full range of cultural activities for which we were created?

Two of the saturday sessions are worth mentioning as well. One was on religion and American foreign policy. Robert O. Smith of Baylor University discussed the phenomenon of christian zionism among American evangelicals. Joe Kickasola of Regent University discussed Bush's middle eastern policy, especially with respect to Iraq. In response to a question I posed to him, he professed to favour a redrawing of state boundaries along ethnic lines. He even said -- perhaps hyperbolically -- that he prays for the creation of an independent Kurdistan, of all things. A Wilsonian commitment to self-determination still lingers in some places, it seems. One can only hope it stays out of the corridors of decision-making power.

The second session was devoted to evangelicalism and political and social life. It featured one Debra Daniels, who gave an interesting paper titled, "Evangelical Egalitarianism and Mutual Submission," as well as Robin Weinstein, whose presentation dealt with welfare reform in the US, particularly under Bush. Weinstein is a recent graduate of Eastern University, where he took courses with Paul Brink, one of my own protégés who is now teaching there.

On friday evening we heard a keynote address delivered by Dr. Kwame Bediako, "A New Christian World: Reading the Signs of the Kingdom Amid Global Geopolitics," which he had earlier presented as the first of the Stone Lectures at Princeton Theological Seminary some weeks earlier. Bediako sounded many of the same themes as Philip Jenkins in The Next Christendom, particularly with respect to the shifting of the global centre of Christianity towards the African continent.

In summary, the conference was worthwhile, and our travels a success. Now back to work.

02 May 2004

Ramachandra on the Psalms

I have recently read Vinoth Ramachandra's Gods that Fail: Modern Idolatry & Christian Mission, which was recommended to me by a contact at Princeton a few weeks ago. There are some similarities between his thesis and my own, as expressed in Political Visions and Illusions. I will be indicating some of these in future posts. But on this weekly celebration of the Resurrection I've chosen to highlight a passage from his book relevant to christian worship:

The gulf between modern Christianity and the spirituality of the Bible is . . . seen in our selective use of the Psalms, which were the song-book of the people of Israel and the New Testament church. The psalms not only reflect every human experience (e.g. confusion, anger, fear, anxiety, depression, uninhibited joy) but they force us to stop pretending that everything is fine with the world. The psalms of lament (e.g. Psalms 10, 13, 35, 86) are passionate complaints at God for the contradictions between his promise and the reality the people experience. These psalms are rarely used in Christian worship today. Yet these psalms are acts of courageous faith: courageous, because they insist that we must face the world as it is and give up every childish pretence; but also of faith, because they stem from the conviction that there is nothing out of bounds where conversation with God is concerned. To withhold any part of human experience, including the darkness of unanswered prayer and the negative aspects of life, from that conversation is to deny the sovereignty of God in all of life. So, paradoxically, it is those who suppress their doubts under a litany of jolly choruses who may well be guilty of unbelief: for they refuse to believe that God can handle their rage (pp. 42-42).

01 May 2004

Cyprus as Atlantis

No sooner did Cyprus join the EU, but Robert Sarmast has now launched his promised expedition to find Atlantis off the southeastern coast of the island.
Pro-choice march

Here is the latest Breakpoint commentary on the misnamed March for Women's Lives that took place in Washington last weekend: "Don’t Tell Me What to Do: The Words That Are Unraveling Our Society." The issue is, of course, abortion:

What we are seeing, of course, is the logical consequences of the desire for personal autonomy in an era of moral relativism. People can say with a perfectly straight face and without a twinge of conscience, “Yeah, it is wrong. It is murder. But nobody is going to tell me I can’t do it.” . . .

The “don’t tell me what to do” mentality will unravel the very fabric of our society. If people actually believe that their autonomy is so important that it gives them the right to kill the innocent, then none of us is safe. I wonder how many of those folks getting bused to Washington ever thought of that.
EU expansion

Europe is now a bigger place, as 10 new members take their place in a 25-member European Union.



Eight of these are former communist countries. Two island nations, Cyprus and Malta, complete the number of entrants. Cyprus enters under a cloud, due to the failure to unify the island nation in advance of EU membership. Will there be another chance at a settlement of the 30-year-old Cyprus issue? Perhaps not.

30 April 2004

Muddled US mideast policy

In the latest Capital Commentary from the Center for Public Justice, James W. Skillen asks, "Why Save Arafat?" Writes Skillen:

Last year, the U.S. joined with the European Union, Russia, and the U.N. to endorse a "road map" to an eventual Middle East peace settlement. Then, suddenly, in the middle of April, without consulting the other three partners or considering the Palestinians, the president endorsed an Israeli plan by Sharon to annex permanently some sizable, illegal, Israeli settlements in the West Bank and to remove Israeli settlers in Gaza sometime next year. Most of the deal violates 40 years of U.S. and international agreements. Senator, and presidential candidate, John Kerry, also endorsed the plan.

On April 27, following the Bush-Sharon meeting, 100 former British diplomats, hardly America's enemies, wrote to Prime Minister Tony Blair, to express dismay. The "new policies" announced by Bush and Sharon "are one-sided and illegal and...will cost yet more Israeli and Palestinian blood."

Do Bush and Kerry imagine that U.S. interests in freedom, democracy, peace, and oil can all be secured with only one Middle East ally amidst growing anti-Americanism both in and far beyond that region?
Philpott and sovereignty

Last week I obtained a copy of Daniel Philpott, Revolutions in Sovereignty: How Ideas Shaped Modern International Relations. Philpott teaches at my alma mater, the University of Notre Dame, where he is assistant professor of political science and director of undergraduate studies. I was given his name and alerted to the existence of his book by one of my contacts at Princeton last month. I understand he is a serious Christian grappling with the relationship between faith and international politics. He received his PhD from Harvard in 1996 and looks very young from his photograph. He is someone to watch out for in the future, as I am sure we will be hearing more from him. Students with an eye to graduate studies in international relations might cast their eyes in the direction of South Bend, Indiana, thus following others who have done the same.

28 April 2004

Infant baptism

Few people know this, but I was baptized twice, once as an infant in a Presbyterian church and again 11 years later in a Baptist church. Much later again, after returning to my Reformed roots, I came to see my "second baptism" as a reaffirmation of my earlier baptism. Here is Hughes Oliphant Old on baptism:

Baptism when it is administered to children is a particularly clear sign that God out of his grace has taken the initiative for our salvation. If the classical Reformers of sixteenth-century Protestantism continued the practice of administering baptism to infants, it was because they had a very strong theology of grace. While the Reformers were strongly Augustinian, their opponents were openly Pelagian! The Anabaptists believed in decisional regeneration. That is, they believed one is saved by making a decision for Christ. There is a big difference between decisional regeneration and justification by faith. While the baptism of infants was perfectly consistent with a strong doctrine of grace and with the doctrine of justification by faith, it was not consistent with any kind of theology that makes salvation a matter of human decisions (Worship Reformed according to Scripture, p. 19).

While Old might have put the matter a bit less provocatively, I believe he is fundamentally correct to tie baptism to God's grace rather than to our own decision. I myself have always been conscious of belonging to Christ. To be sure, I have had moments of heightened sensitivity to my own sins and to the need for conversion. But these did not and could not save me. God's grace did that.

27 April 2004

‘I’m personally opposed, but. . .'

The following opinion piece was published as part of my Principalities & Powers column in the 22 September 2003 issue of Christian Courier:

In 1984 the then-governor of New York, Mario Cuomo, made a famous speech at the University of Notre Dame, one of the best known Catholic universities in the United States. As a Catholic Christian himself, Gov. Cuomo used the occasion to clarify the way his faith affected his conduct in public office, particularly with respect to the abortion issue. Recognizing that his church condemns abortion in no uncertain terms, he affirmed his church’s teaching, indicating that he and his wife would never themselves have considered ending a pregnancy prematurely. Yet as a public office-holder, he believed it improper to impose his personal moral beliefs on others. In this way he justified his own pro-choice position on the issue.

Since then many other Christians in public office have taken the same approach, which amounts to saying, “I’m personally opposed, but. . . .” This strategy is almost always applauded by the secular media, whose representatives are formed from their earliest days by the assumption that religion is a purely private matter, never to intrude upon ordinary political discourse. When someone enters the political arena claiming to favour a particular position, and if it is known that her religion plays a role in this, the secularist mindset invariably cries foul.

In a recent National Post opinion piece, Claire Hoy pointed out the incongruity of this response. After all, every political agenda entails the imposition of a particular policy on one’s fellow citizens who may disagree with it. Thus when Brian Mulroney’s Conservatives won the 1988 election, they quite naturally used the opportunity to impose free trade with the United States on this country, despite the fact that it was disliked by anti-free-traders. Yet even among the latter, few claimed that Mulroney was doing something intrinsically wrong or undemocratic.

However, it is only when a political leader’s motives are known to be overtly religious in origin that this “imposition” is suddenly deemed illegitimate. Yet Mary Ann Glendon argues that when people advance their moral viewpoints in the political arena, they are proposing, not imposing. This is simply what democracy is about: citizens propose their preferred policy alternatives and defend them in public debate, after which they are voted on and implemented. “It’s a very strange doctrine,” writes Glendon, “that would silence only religiously grounded moral viewpoints.” By contrast, justice requires that, if secularists of the various ideological persuasions are permitted to advance their own agendas, so also should be the Canadian Jewish Congress, the Christian Coalition, and similar groups.

In a way one can understand secularists attempting to exclude from political deliberation those viewpoints that would explicitly undermine their own hegemony. For the past three centuries the followers of the secular ideologies have looked upon traditional religions as deeply divisive, seeing themselves as better positioned to keep domestic peace than their Jewish, Christian and Muslim fellow citizens. Thus they have no difficulty privileging their own point of view above that of these others.

However, it is harder to see why so many Christians have acquiesced in their own marginalization in the public square. Why would Gov. Cuomo so easily accept the secularists’ terms by sidelining his own moral convictions concerning the protection of the unborn? The cynical answer is that the abortion issue was simply not all that close to his heart, and there may well be something to that. But, more to the point, he and many other Christians are part of a culture where the marginalization of one’s ultimate beliefs is understood to be the normal state of affairs. The time has come to break through this apparent normality and to open up the public square.

26 April 2004

What? A king for the US?

Many of us have probably heard of the Monarchist League of Canada. Since Canada is a constitutional monarchy, its role would seem clear enough. But check out these links: Monarchist Society of America and The Constantinian Society. Whom would they place on this nonexistent throne? Are there any claimants?

25 April 2004

Cyprus unity very far away

There are always at least two sides to an issue. Turkish-Cypriots favoured the UN plan, while Greek-Cypriots decisively repudiated it yesterday. The EU, UN, US, &c., are now frustrated with the Greek side. Some are asking: "Do Greek Cypriots want a unification deal at all?" I will, of course, have more to say about all this at some point.
Isaac Watts


Christian Biography Resources


Here is a wonderful liturgical resource: The Psalms and Hymns of Isaac Watts. I will obviously have to add this link to my Genevan Psalter webpages. Here is a sample from this rich collection by the 18th-century hymn writer:

PSALM 23

My Shepherd is the living Lord;
Now shall my wants be well supplied;
His providence and holy word
Become my safety and my guide.

In pastures where salvation grows
He makes me feed, he makes me rest;
There living water gently flows,
And all the food's divinely blest.

My wand'ring feet his ways mistake,
But he restores my soul to peace,
And leads me, for his mercy's sake,
In the fair paths of righteousness.

Though I walk through the gloomy vale
Where death and all its terrors are,
My heart and hope shall never fail,
For God my Shepherd's with me there.

Amidst the darkness and the deeps
Thou art my comfort, thou my stay;
Thy staff supports my feeble steps,
Thy rod directs my doubtful way.

The sons of earth, and sons of hell,
Gaze at thy goodness, and repine
To see my table spread so well
With living bread and cheerful wine.

How I rejoice when on my head
Thy Spirit condescends to rest!
'Tis a divine anointing, shed
Like oil of gladness at a feast.

Surely the mercies of the Lord
Attend his household all their days;
There will I dwell to hear his word,
To seek his face, and sing his praise.


24 April 2004

Cypriots at the polls

I wonder how many Cypriots on either side of the green line have read the exceedingly lengthy Annan Plan For Cyprus Settlement - Full Text? Probably as many as have read the equally lengthy 1960 Constitution. Greek and Turkish Cypriots go to the polls today to vote on the Annan Plan.

23 April 2004

Anniversaries

One year ago yesterday I began this blog, which I initially named, Notes from Above Ground (a play on Dostoevsky's Notes from the Underground), but quickly changed to Notes from a Byzantine-Rite Calvinist.

Today is the one-year anniversary of the sudden and unexpected opening of the green line in Cyprus, allowing people on both sides to travel back and forth for the first time in almost three decades. Much has happened since then, but not nearly enough.
Bishops of Cyprus should read Skillen

Readers of this blog know that I think highly of James W. Skillen and his writings. Here is something from the latest issue of the Public Justice Report, articulating the Center for Public Justice's understanding of its own mission, and the limitations of that mission:

We, like many other Americans, wish we had the answers to all questions and could simply declare what is just and unjust in all situations. But that is not the case and never will be. Humans have been called by God to act justly, to govern wisely for the public good, and to be the kind of citizens who give as much attention to the welfare of their civic neighbors as they do to themselves. But what this means in any given policy area cannot be known ahead of time or from outside the arena of public responsibility. Moreover, we are all sinners, often blinded by selfishness and bad judgment.

For these and other reasons, even with the Center's statements of principle we will never claim that the Center is doing or speaking God's will. We claim no more than that we are trying to respond in obedience to God's call to do justice. And we fully expect and hope that others will respond by affirming or challenging the stances we take and the arguments we publish. That is the way to strengthen Christian civic responsibility.

Perhaps the bishops of the Church of Cyprus need to read this and take some lessons about the role of Christians in the political realm.

First lesson: Prudential judgements on concrete political issues are always fallible and should be advanced with humility. The principles undergirding such judgements, e.g., the rule of law, the need to punish crime and protection of the vulnerable, are on a firmer footing. But we will always disagree when it comes to application of these principles.

Second lesson: Ecclesiastical officers are not in the best position, structurally speaking, to make such prudential judgements. To begin with, they lack sufficient information, unlike government policy-makers. But, more seriously, their offices, along with the tasks that go with them, are limited. Clerics properly give voice to the biblical call to do justice. When they start to apply those principles themselves, blessing and anathematizing Christians who agree or disgree respectively, they are pushing the normative bounds of their offices pretty far. Better to have Christians organized separately for political purposes.

22 April 2004

Pro-natal policies needed?

Here is a story with huge implications for the future but which few are making much of: "Canada's Birthrate Falls to Lowest Since Records Began in 1921." There are, of course, all sorts of legitimate reasons why specific couples may choose fewer children. Yet I wonder whether over the long term we will be forced to re-examine our priorities in light of the coming apparent decline in population. This may prompt a reorientation of government policies as well, particularly with respect to abortion and tax incentives encouraging larger families. We may be made to ask fundamental questions, for example, whether there is a responsibility -- and perhaps even a duty -- to produce the next generation or whether it can simply be left as a matter of personal choice and public indifference.

21 April 2004

A captive church

In my introductory level course on political ideologies, I admit to my students that, while I can see good in virtually every ideology, I have a blind spot when it comes to nationalism. I have difficulty seeing any good in nationalism, particularly the ethnic variety. This is due to the role Greek nationalism played in dividing the island of Cyprus and making it difficult, if not impossible, for the two ethnic communities to live together. I have argued in my book that Christians, above all people, have resources enabling them to see through the attractions of the secular ideologies. Unfortunately, it is often the followers of Jesus Christ, who ought to know better, who have succumbed to the allures of nationalism.

There are few things that can get my blood boiling more than this sort of story: "Bishop warns ‘yes’ voters will go to hell," from the Cyprus Mail.

Be good and you will inherit the Kingdom of Heaven, said Jesus. Vote ‘yes’ in the referendum on the Annan plan on Saturday and you will go to hell – or so says the [exiled] Bishop of Kyrenia.

On Sunday, he warned Greek Cypriots they faced damnation if they approved the UN plan.

"Those who say ‘yes’ will be party to this injustice, will lose their homeland and the kingdom of heavens," Bishop Pavlos said in a sermon on Sunday.

He went on to criticise those politicians who were in favour of the plan, saying “they want to sway the people into adopting their own submissive stance, but the people cannot be fooled”.

As if that weren't enough, Chrysostomos, Bishop of Paphos, is adding fuel to the fire his colleague started:

“I am positive that on May 1 we shall enter the European Union. That which we failed to achieve back in 1955-1959, namely Enosis (union) with the motherland Greece, we shall achieve through EU membership.

“I have invited all freedom fighters of the 1955-59 period to come to the bishopric after mass, at 10 o’clock; the bishopric’s fridges are packed with champagne bottles, and we shall crack them open to celebrate Cyprus’ enosis with Greece.”

The reference to enosis alludes to the long campaign, spearheaded by the Orthodox Church of Cyprus, to unite the island with Greece. After Great Britain gained control of Cyprus in 1878, Cypriots began agitating for London to cede it to the Greek kingdom which had been established half a century earlier. This was part of the Meghali Idhea, or Great Idea, which proposed to unify all Greek Orthodox Christians under a single political rule -- tantamount to a revival of the Byzantine Empire at the expense of the muslim Ottoman Empire. The Church was at the forefront of this effort.

In 1948 the Labour government in Britain offered Cyprus, along with a number of other British-controlled territories, a full measure of self-government short of complete independence. The Church of Cyprus campaigned against this, demanding either enosis or nothing. Needless to say, they received nothing. This has been the strategy of the church ever since. Rather than being a force for peace and reconciliation, the church has blocked any sort of compromise falling short of their ideal notion of hellenic unity. Had Cypriots been more politically savvy and accepted the 1948 proposal, they would have bought themselves some time to come up with a longterm solution to the problem of Cyprus' status -- something that would have been acceptable to the ethnic Turkish minority in the island. In the meantime, both Greek and Turkish Cypriots would have acquired valuable experience in the art of politics, defined by Bernard Crick as the peaceful conciliation of diversity rather than as the use of the coercive power of government to reach for an impossible ideal.

The Church's activities over the last more than half a century have made matters considerably worse for ordinary Cypriots, both Greek and Turkish. Bishops are claiming God's stamp of approval for their own shortsighted aspirations, which someone less charitable than I might be inclined to label blasphemous. The flag of Greece flies outside church buildings and monasteries, in preference to the admittedly pedestrian flag of the Cyprus Republic. A contact in the island reports to me that this has only served to empty the pews of the churches.

The Orthodox Church has not fallen for some of the crazier trends affecting protestant churches, particularly those positioning themselves within the somewhat misnamed mainline. Yet the genuine weakness of the Orthodox Church is precisely its tendency to embrace the various ethnic nationalisms that have so marred the political landscape in the Balkans and elsewhere.
Public Justice Report

The new issue of the Center for Public Justice's Public Justice Report (2nd quarter, 2004) is now on line. Here are the contents:

James W. Skillen, "Heaven Above and Our Way on Earth"

Mark A. Noll and James W. Skillen, "Religion and American Politics"

James W. Skillen, "Same-Sex 'Marriage' is Not a Civil Right"

"Faith, Jobs, and Social-Service Politics," an interview with Stanley Carlson-Thies and Stephen Lazarus

"Pledge of Allegiance and the First Amendment," excerpts from a brief filed by the Christian Legal Society, the Center for Public Justice and other organizations in the Newdow case currently before the US Supreme Court

James W. Skillen, "Religion, Elections, and the Public Justice Report."

Happy reading.

20 April 2004

Another boost to your vocabulary

Relativism, n. a variant of ancestor worship.
Unwise strategy

This is not a smart move by the Canada Family Action Coalition: "Family coalition seeks halt to hate law: Robinson's theft cited by lobby group." If Robinson had proposed a law to protect the unborn, I doubt they would now be arguing against it on the grounds that he is an admitted thief.

19 April 2004

What's going on? Am I missing something?

For some odd reason I keep seeing all these cars driving around bearing little flags with a white maple leaf on a blue field. Either this has something to do with hockey or they're reopening the four-decade-old flag debate.
Two federal elections this year?

Will Stephen Harper be forced to relive Joe Clark's 1979 humiliation? Chantal Hébert speculates about the increasing possibility of a hung parliament and a shortlived Conservative minority government: "Election nightmare shapes up for Harper."
A musical blog?

Well, maybe not. At least not all the time.
Settling for indefinite warfare

Here is Tamar Mayer on the latest "peace overture" by Bush and Sharon: "A perilous line to be drawing." Writes Mayer:

Territorial homelands, where nations believe they were born, are crucial. They differentiate us from them and here from there. Boundaries that mark national territory, whether real or imagined, are intertwined with identity, collective memory, myths about the nation's creation - and security. To protect the nation's territory, its boundaries must be well defined.

In Israel, this has never been the case. For thousands of years the Jewish nation has had a clear notion that its ancestral homeland is in Zion, but the boundaries of the homeland were never clearly defined - not on the ground and not in the nation's mind. . . .

[T]he United States, Israel and the other signers of the 1993 Oslo Accords were careful not to discuss specific boundaries. They never mentioned directly the 1949-1967 borders, or the Green Line, referring to these areas instead as the West Bank and the Gaza strip. . . .

Now we seem to be on the verge of something more final. While previous U.S. administrations engaged Israel in discussions about withdrawal from the West Bank and Gaza, the Bush administration appears to support Sharon's settlement policies, his plan to annex parts of the West Bank and his vision of a Greater Israel. . . . The great risk is that with Sharon's new map imposed in perpetuity, the bloodshed will continue in perpetuity as well.
From China back to Jerusalem

Could 100,000 Chinese Christians complete the evangelization of the globe in our lifetime? Read Mark Earley on "An Army of Worms: Completing the Circuit to Jerusalem." The title of the movement is Back to Jerusalem. Why?

Back to Jerusalem gets its name from the fact that, since Pentecost, the Gospel has primarily spread westward from Jerusalem — first to Europe, then the Americas, then to the Far East. But there is “no firmly established church” among the two billion people in the area from China’s western border back to Christianity’s origination point. So thousands of Chinese Christians sense God nudging them westward to complete the circuit “back to Jerusalem.”

Perhaps Philip Jenkins will see fit to include this effort in a future second edition of The Next Christendom.

18 April 2004

Sunday of St. Thomas

In the traditional one-year lectionaries in both eastern and western churches, the sunday following Easter is the sunday of St. Thomas. On this day the story of Jesus' post-resurrection appearance to the disciples, including doubting Thomas, is read from John 20:19-31. In those churches that have moved to a three-year lectionary, the reading of this gospel lesson on the first sunday after the Paschal feast is still maintained.


Orthodox Family Life


Is it unusual that the church should celebrate a famous doubter in its calendar? I don't think so. After all, if Jesus died and rose to save us from our sins, then this would include the sin of actively doubting the reality and efficacy of his redemptive grace.

On this day is often sung the well-known hymn, "O Sons and Daughters, Let Us Sing," four of whose stanzas run as follows:

When Thomas first the tidings heard,
How they had seen the risen Lord,
He doubted the disciples’ word.
Alleluia! Alleluia!

“My piercèd side, O Thomas, see;
My hands, My feet, I show to thee;
Not faithless but believing be.”
Alleluia! Alleluia!

No longer Thomas then denied;
He saw the feet, the hands, the side;
“Thou art my Lord and God,” he cried.
Alleluia! Alleluia!

How blessed are they who have not seen,
And yet whose faith has constant been;
For they eternal life shall win.
Alleluia! Alleluia!

Later: Here is a particularly ancient version of "O Filii et Filiae," and here is the midi.

16 April 2004

A rare bird indeed

Among other things, Tim Roemer has the virtue of being one of a very, very few pro-life Democrats active in the political arena. May there be many more like him in the future.
Who was it that said. . .

. . . that God allows bad liturgy in his churches so that Christians living in otherwise comfortable circumstances will know first hand what it is to suffer for the cause of Christ?

15 April 2004

Oh boy, another award

It seems I've been awarded The Byzantine Bow Tie Award for Outstanding Beardedness by Boerishbwoy. Do I get a plaque for this?
Troubling move by Bush

This will definitely not bring peace to the middle east: "Sharon buoyed by U.S. support." The US has approved Israeli plans to withdraw altogether from Gaza and from four West Bank settlements. But Israel gets to keep much of the West Bank on which some 150,000 Jewish settlers now live.

There are just two problems with this. First, settling occupied territory by citizens of the occupying state is illegal under art. 49 of the Fourth Geneva Convention. The US cannot simply waive its provisions unilaterally for its own policy purposes. Of course, one can envision a scenario in which at least some existing settlements might have to be tolerated under a general peace accord agreed to by all sides. One could argue that this is what Kofi Annan's plan for Cyprus involves. But that plan is being put to a referendum in both sides of the island, where its future is in doubt.

This brings us to the second, and more serious, problem: the Palestinians have not agreed to this and have not even been brought into the process. This has only stiffened the resolve of such groups as Hamas to mount armed resistance. What could Bush and company have been thinking?
The 9/11 Commission

"Roemer grills Tenet on lack of contact with Bush." I knew Tim Roemer when we were both graduate students at Notre Dame in the early to mid 1980s. He was the Democratic representative of the third congressional district in Indiana throughout the 1990s until his retirement from that position last year. He must be one of the few politicians anywhere to have earned a PhD in political science.

14 April 2004

Chesterton on the madness of modernity

Gilbert Keith Chesterton is always worth reading. If he weren't so Catholic, he'd be very nearly a neo-Calvinist. Here he is on the trouble with the modern age:

The modern world is not evil; in some ways the modern world is far too good. It is full of wild and wasted virtues. When a religious scheme is shattered (as Christianity was shattered at the Reformation), it is not merely the vices that are let loose. The vices are, indeed, let loose, and they wander and do damage. But the virtues are let loose also; and the virtues wander more wildly, and the virtues do more terrible damage. The modern world is full of the old Christian virtues gone mad. The virtues have gone mad because they have been isolated from each other and are wandering alone. Thus some scientists care for truth; and their truth is pitiless. Thus some humanitarians only care for pity; and their pity (I am sorry to say) is often untruthful (Orthodoxy).

One needn't follow Chesterton's negative view of the Reformation, but I do detect in him a certain affinity with the kind of christian antireductionism some of us support on this side of the Tiber.
Writing award finalist

I have just received word that Political Visions and Illusions has been shortlisted by The Word Guild for its annual Canadian Christian writing awards. Four books have made it to this stage in the category of culture, including Brian C. Stiller, Jesus and Caesar, Jean Vanier, Finding Peace, and Ray Wiseman, A Bridge to the Mountain, in addition to my own. The winners of these awards will be announced on 18 June at the 20th annual Christian writers' conference in Guelph, Ontario.
The great commission and cultural mandate

A lively exchange about neo-Calvinism has been taking place between Graham Ware and Andrew Vis, with Gideon Strauss (of course) putting in his two cents. One of the issues is the relationship between the cultural mandate in Genesis 1:28 ff and the great commission in Matthew 28:18-20. There is a tendency in some circles to play the two off against each other.

A good antidote to this thinking can be found in Paul Marshall, Heaven Is Not My Home: Living in the Now of God's Creation. Marshall emphasizes that the great commission actually reinforces the cultural mandate:

We can be sure of this commission's success, because Jesus tells us he has authority not only in heaven but on earth as well. And because Jesus has authority over the nations, then the disciples are called to teach the nations to observer all he has commanded. The Great Commission itself includes our tasks in the world. The Great Commission is a calling creation-wide and creation-deep: it calls the nations to obey God.

When men and women turn to Jesus Christ in real, concrete repentance from sin and, by grace through faith, are restored in God's favor, they are called to begin to live out the healing and restoration of Christ's redemption, taking up their Christian responsibility for the direction of human life and culture. Evangelism is, in a way, the recruiting process for this life whereby people are called out for service to God's kingdom. Evangelism calls people to repentance and to love for God. We are called to a new life of service to our neighbors. This is the Christian life (pp. 209-210).

To those who would argue that the cultural mandate somehow detracts from the importance of the great commission, Marshall cogently argues:

Sometimes it seems that our evangelism is about calling people to join an army that consists of nothing but recruiting officers -- people who call other people to join the army. But people should be recruited into the army that is the Church in order to carry out a task beyond mere recruitment (p. 208).

We are, in other words, calling people to membership in a kingdom where there are flesh and blood people living out redeemed lives in ordinary and extraordinary ways. They are engaged in the tasks of farming, manufacturing, trading, rearing children, teaching, learning, writing and reading books, composing and singing music, running foot races and, yes, preaching and hearing the word of God. The kingdom of God consists of life lived in all its fulness in conformity with God's law.

The great commission calls the nations to obedience -- obedience to the cultural mandate given by God at the beginning of creation.

13 April 2004

Singing his praises

On sunday in church Theresa's junior choir sang with the combined choirs Handel's famous Hallelujah Chorus. For days she had been singing her part around the house and even in the tub the evening before. There's something that touches the heart of a father to hear his five-year-old daughter singing one of the more familiar classics in praise of God.
A tragic anniversary

This month marks the 800th anniversary of the sack of Constantinople during the Fourth Crusade in 1204. Although the Crusade was originally directed at Egypt, the Doge of Venice, Enrico Dandolo, succeeded in diverting it to the fabled first City of what was then still known as the Roman Empire. That Christians would prey on other Christians is, of course, nothing less than a scandal. Much of the booty wound up in the Venetian Republic, including the famous bronze horses that had once graced the hippodrome.


Ecumenical Patriarchate

Hagia Sophia, Constantinople


Greeks have long memories and are still bitter over this offence from the west. In fact, 1204 looms much larger in their minds than 1054, the year in which the churches of Rome and Constantinople formally broke ties. Here is one contemporary account from the Greek side by Nicetas Choniates: "The Sack of Constantinople." In 2001 Pope John Paul II visited Athens and issued an historic apology on behalf of his Catholic ancestors for the Fourth Crusade. It is worth noting, however, that even Innocent III, who was Pope at the time, was horrified by the crusade and subsequently excommunicated the crusaders. Furthermore, since the crusaders also attacked the Catholic city of Zara, along the Dalmatian coast, this tragic episode ought not to be portrayed as exclusively a Catholic-Orthodox dispute.

Two decades ago I was privileged to attend an exhibit at the Art Institute of Chicago titled, "The Treasury of San Marco, Venice." Included was a wealth of Byzantine artefacts from La Serenissima. My enthusiasm at viewing this fantastic collection was tempered by the realization that this was stolen wealth. Nearly a decade earlier I had stood in Venice itself, once a vassal of the Empire but which had broken with it, remaining an independent republic until Napoléon extinguished it in 1797.


Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche

San Marco's bronze horses


My genealogical research has revealed that Alexios IV Angelos, the ill-fated Byzantine Emperor who lost his throne just prior to the sack of the City, was variously my 24th, 25th and 27th great grand uncle.

12 April 2004

Subsidiarity, sphere sovereignty and the CDA

Gideon Strauss was kind enough to translate a key section from the CDA's 1990 research report, Publieke gerechtigheid: Een christen-democratische visie op de rol van de overheid in de samenleving (Public justice: a Christian democratic vision of the role of government in society):

The principle of sphere sovereignty and the idea of subsidiarity can probably not be identified with each other. They give expression to distinct values and it is meaningless to try and hide the differences under the table. But, as has been said before, it is not necessary to identify sphere sovereignty and subsidiarity in the effort to arrive at a consistent vision of government. Each complements and corrects the other. . . . For that reason the CDA has in its very brief history been able to achieve a close, authentic fusion of principles with the common denominator of the responsible society. The idea of subsidiarity borne by Catholic social teaching and the idea of sphere sovereignty current among protestants has been woven together into a view of the person, society, and state in which both dimensions are on a sound footing. The fusion of the two traditions had resulted in a single political philosophy that strives to develop a correct relationship between personal, social, and political responsibilities, taking into account the distinctive value of each of the terrains of life, as these have come to flourish in society (pp. 133-4).

Two decades ago I began writing a dissertation on precisely this topic, comparing the political theories of Herman Dooyeweerd and Yves R. Simon with respect to differentiated authority or responsibility. At the time I was much impressed by the seeming practical convergence between the two concepts in support of what is nowadays known as civil society. My tendency then was to tone down the differences between the two. Since then, however, it's become increasingly apparent to me that subsidiarity is really a federal principle devolving authority to a subordinate body within a larger, more encompassing structure. It is embodied in the tenth amendment of the US Constitution and in the European Union's Maastricht Treaty of 1992. It characterizes the relationship between two entities of the same intrinsic nature. Subsidiarity is less effective in enabling us to differentiate between entities characterized by distinctive structural principles.

This is where Kuyper's sphere sovereignty, particularly as modified and systematized by Dooyeweerd, constitutes an advance over subsidiarity. It enables us to differentiate among different kinds of things without having to locate them within some sort of ontic hierarchy. We need not try arbitrarily to assign higher and lower status to institutional church, state, school, business enterprise or labour union in order to make subsidiarity work. Subsidiarity thus applies well to, say, federal, provincial and municipal governments; sphere sovereignty, or differentiated responsibility, properly applies to, say, government and family.

One wonders whether the CDA is still able to affirm the distinction between subsidiarity and sphere sovereignty. A decade after the merger of the three christian parties, it was still able to do so. Another decade and a half have passed, and much has undoubtedly changed in the Netherlands. Given the huge tide of secularism that swept over the country after the end of the Second World War, it may be that Dutch Christians have enough on their hands to maintain any sort of public witness to their faith at all. Ensuring that the public understands the differences between subsidiarity and sphere sovereignty may seem to some like straining at gnats. Yet much is at stake here, namely, a recognition of diversity in God's world, as opposed to the monistic reductionisms of the various secular ideologies.

Those interested in a more detailed discussion of this issue would do well to read chapter 8 of my book.
What? No Easter?

I'm still waiting for our stereotypical Old School Presbyterian to let us all know that yesterday was just one more sabbath observance as far as he is concerned.
Today's vocabulary lesson

Bebop, n. 1. a sophisticated type of jazz developed after the Second World War, employing experimental tonal and rhythmic forms; 2. the name of one of the juvenile dinosaurs in Barney and Friends.
Church life in need of revival

This is an all too familiar report for those acquainted with the sorry state of church life in the Netherlands: "The Dutch Sea of Secularization: Church in the Netherlands Awaits a Turning Point." Although the report concerns the Catholic Church, a similar trend has affected the protestant churches over the past four decades. Pray that the Holy Spirit will work mightily once again in the Low Countries.
Did you know. . .

. . . that hymnwriter Fanny Crosby's married name was Van Alstyne?
Only Marilyn Monroe is missing

After My Big Fat Greek Wedding, what does one do for an encore? Try this: "Wedding girls Vardalos, Collette team up for 'Connie and Carla'." Is it just me, or does this sound like a remake of Billy Wilder's Some Like It Hot?

11 April 2004

A 6th century paschal hymn

This morning in church we sang two versions of the same hymn, Salve Festa Dies, by Venantius Fortunatus. These are "Hail Thee, Festival Day," sung to a rousing tune by Ralph Vaughan Williams, and "Welcome, Happy Morning." Unfortunately we did not sing those two wonderful hymns by St. John of Damascus, "The Day of Resurrection" and "Come, Ye Faithful, Raise the Strain," much beloved by Byzantine-rite Calvinists everywhere.
The Lost Continent: a feline presence

If Robert Sarmast is correct, then cats were kept as pets, not so much by aboriginal Cypriots, as by Atlanteans.
Anastasis

Christ is risen! He is risen indeed! Alleluia!


Monastery of Chora, Constantinople

Christ is risen from the dead,
by death trampling down death,
and giving life to those within the grave.


From the Orthodox Paschal Liturgy

10 April 2004

Cypriot 'first nations'

It seems rather amusing that Cyprus should contain the earliest evidence that human beings kept cats as pets, since nowadays throughout the entire Greek-speaking world cats appear to be regarded largely as nuisances. They wander around the neighbourhoods, seemingly belonging to no one, and when people see them they shoo them away. But apparently Cypriots' remote ancestors esteemed cats.

Who were these aboriginal Cypriots? They were probably not Greeks, as the Greeks arrived in Cyprus around 12 centuries before Christ, and people had already been living there for more than 6 thousand years. It seems more likely that their culture was related to those of the Asiatic or African mainlands closest to the island. My wife has suggested to me that, since the Egyptians were known to regard cats as sacred animals, there might have been an ancient connection between the cultures of the Nile and of Cyprus. If Linear A is ever decyphered, it might yield clues as to who the aboriginal inhabitants of Cyprus were.
What? Is this a joke?

Kim Campbell is one of the 50 greatest leaders in the history of the world? I suppose nearly finishing off Canada's second major political party counts for something. But let's be real.
Murdered ancestor

One-hundred-thirty-nine years ago yesterday the American Civil War ended and my 3rd great-grandfather, David W. Wells (c 1815-1865), was reputedly murdered. There is more than one account of how this happened. Here is the event as related very briefly by Lucy Jane Bentley Hyder (1875-1948), my great-grandmother:

On the 9th day of April 1865, (the day the surrender was made) during the Civil War my grandfather, David Wells, and my uncle, Hiram Creech, were murdered (shot) by the Raiders of the Ku Klux Klan as they were sometimes called. They first removed his (David Wells') Sunday vest which he was wearing, and then shot him.

A more detailed account is written by Tom Smith, a descendant of Hiram Creech (c 1827-1865), and thus a distant cousin of mine. He appears to have supplemented his account from Lucy Jane's recollections, as found on my own genealogical pages. I have corrected his spelling.

Hiram Creech and at least one of his daughters were visiting family in Lee County, Virginia. On the 9th day of April 1865, the day the Civil War surrender was made, Hiram Creech and his brother-in-law David Wells, were murdered (shot) by Rebel [i.e., Confederate] guerrillas (sometimes referred to as the Raiders of the Ku Klux Klan). They removed Hiram Creech's boots and David Wells' Sunday vest, and then shot them. Hiram's daughter managed to get away. They apparently were sitting on a rail fence when the Rebels approached them. One of the Rebels supposedly had been like a brother to Hiram many years earlier there in Virginia. This is the one that shot him and then took the boots off his feet. From all the traditional stories I conclude this may also have been true. When they saw the Rebels coming, they hid but the Rebels saw them and told them to come out and they would not be harmed. So they came out and climbed up on a rail fence. The Rebels then proceeded to shoot them. Hiram's boots were made by his son, Alexander. After the war Alexander spent some time looking for the man who killed his father.

David Wells and Hiram Creech were married to two sisters, Nancy Jane Elkins (1822-1887) and Mary "Polly" Elkins (1824-1875) respectively.
Christ's sacrifice

The following hymn, "O Sacred Head, Now Wounded," is beloved by generations of Christians grateful for the sacrifice of Jesus Christ for their sins. The original Latin text is attributed to Bernard of Clairvaux, translated into German by Paul Gerhardt and finally into English by James W. Alexander:

O sacred Head, now wounded, with grief and shame weighed down,
Now scornfully surrounded with thorns, thine only crown;
How pale thou art with anguish, with sore abuse and scorn!
How does that visage languish, which once was bright as morn!

What thou, my Lord, hast suffered, was all for sinners’ gain;
Mine, mine was the transgression, but thine the deadly pain.
Lo, here I fall, my Saviour! ’Tis I deserve thy place;
Look on me with thy favor, vouchsafe to me thy grace.

What language shall I borrow to thank thee, dearest friend,
For this thy dying sorrow, thy pity without end?
O make me thine forever, and should I fainting be,
Lord, let me never, never outlive my love to thee.

09 April 2004

Vote yes on 24 April

The editors of Greece's Kathimerini think Greek Cypriots should vote in favour of the Annan plan, despite its flaws. Could we see a repeat of Canada's Charlottetown Accord fiasco in the island of Aphrodite?
Important book missing

Conspicuously absent from the bibliography of the Law Commission of Canada's report on electoral reform is Nick Loenen's excellent book, Citizenship and Democracy: A Case for Proportional Representation. How they managed to overlook this I don't know. For a review of this book see "A Call to Reform the Canadian Electoral System," by yours truly.
Here, kitty, kitty

It seems my Cypriot ancestors were the first people to keep cats as pets more than 9 millennia ago. Makes me sneeze just thinking about it.

08 April 2004

Electoral reform

This afternoon I received in the mail from the Law Commission of Canada a volume titled, Voting Counts: Electoral Reform for Canada, which is also available online. A perusal of the table of contents indicates that the Commission is asking the right questions about the role of electoral systems in strengthening or weakening democratic governance. It thoroughly investigates the various forms of proportional representation functioning in different political contexts, weighing their respective advantages and disadvantages. The publication of this report is a positive sign from the federal government that it is taking seriously the pressing need for electoral reform in this country.

07 April 2004

The well dressed student

On this, the last day of class for Political Science 122, the brothers Kuiper wore exceedingly tasteful purple and peach coloured bow ties. It seems my students are learning some fashion sense, in addition to the material in the book and the lectures.

Followers

Blog Archive

About Me

My photo
Contact at: dtkoyzis at gmail dot com